Manhattan Diner

2532 Broadway, New York
(212) 932-0068

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This is our diner on our block that we have eaten at several times and ordered takeout from. Food quality is inconsistent. Lunch and dinner options are decent - good salads, gyros, and burgers. Breakfast is normally ok if a bit unseasoned, hash browns are usually a bit soggy but this time the French toast was undercooked with raw egg in the middle. If we have the time, we typically go to other diners in the area which is unfortunate because this one is closest to us.
Service: great. Attentive server.

The vibe: cute, cozy, 60s diner.

However. The food was NOT it. The waffles were $14 for a single dry waffle (think motel continental breakfast), without maple syrup (?) or fruit or anything other than cold butter packets. We ordered three and finished none of them. Generally the food lacked flavor and was expensive. Best value? The side of corned beef or side of home fries by itself.

Also,...
Thanksgiving Dinner at Manhattan Diner.
1. Winter Squash Soup: A
2. Cream of Turkey Soup: C+ (wish it had more turkey and pasta)
3. Roast Turkey with Chestnut Stuffing: B-
4. Roast Prime Rib with Au Jus: C+ (more like a ribeye)
5. Bread Rolls: D (texture was dry/stale)
6. Cranberry Sauce: B+ (liked the whole cranberries)
7. Apple Pie: C (served cold. Pie crust wasn't flaky)
8. Pumpkin Cheesecake: C+ (pumpkin...

More Reviews