Maxwell's Central Park

1325 5th Ave, New York
(646) 657-0993

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Opentable Diner

This restaurant is permanently closed, but is open to make reservations. Don't waste your time assuming they're open.

PatriciaCM

I had to put one star,otherwise the system would not allow me to write a review,otherwise it would have bern a cero star . The restaurant was closed,out of business,2 people doing inventory,seat turned upside doing. I had out of town friends stating in a apt in thevarea and made reservations through Open Table. eservations were confirmed twice by email. I arrived earlier to find the place as described above. There's nothing nearby,we had to go to the west side for lunch. Please update your website. And ,by the way,the cero star would have been for Open Table. Terrible service

YolandaD

I gave 1 star due to making a 8pm reservation and upon arrival Maxwells was closed. There was nothing stating they would be closed, not even on the website which allowed me to make reservations.

SuzyZ

Food was good Service acceptable but not outstanding I was from out of town & had difficulty locating the restaurant. It's not really at Central Park.

Tiana Villar

Miguel the manger was amazing and super sweet. Jasmine was really sweet too and they were very attentive. They always checked on us and made sure we were good. Highly recommend! And Miguel made us special drinks that were great!

Service: 5

N Sadé

It was super fun here, the vibes were amazing, MIGUEL the tall handsome Virgo waiter was THE BESTTTT server & really gave us a good birthday experience. Jasmine really gave us good laughs & a candle for the birthday girl. Zack gave amazing vibes with great conversation & laughs.

Aaliyah

Miguel the tall handsome Virgo king took very good care of us! He delivered on the vibes and the generosity for the night. 100000/10 and the food slaps crazy ✨✨✨ ? ? ?

Service: 5

Dan Vazquez

The food is sub par. Thin and over cooked sliders, under seasoned fries, lukewarm French onion soup, yellow mustard instead of Dijon. Not worth it

oneishac

The table wasn't clean, we had to keep calling someone to get help. Food wasnt fulfilling.

Thorin Drozd

A great experience! Food was great and staff very friendly and accommodating! Portion size is great

Service: 5

JanineH

We were very disappointed. Restaurant is miss managed. Not all items on menu available to consume. One waitress for entire facility. Long wait for drinks. Bench seating tapped to repair tears in seats. We had had a good experience last time we were there but this visit left a bad taste in our mouth.

JulineP

The food & drinks were just ok. Nothing exciting about any of it. The service was pretty slow but it was a Friday evening.

Ryan Tongue

Food was great but had the most unattentive waitress. Over 2 hours she did not return to our table once after taking our order. Took 45minutes to get a check, flagged our waitress down multiple times, had to bother a bus boy, a different waitress, eventually went to the bar to get our check. Should have just left.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Top Shelf Burger

Victoria Hayes

Just save your money and time by not eating here. We sat 40 mins with no drinks. Then they don't even bring out enough water for everyone at the table. In addition they cant figure out 2 diet cokes and 1 cherry coke. All cherry cokes, awesome. The food took over an hour to come out but at least you'll have alot of time to be hungry and aggravated whilst looking at a mediocre atmosphere. When the food finally came out it was terrible. Burgers were insanely dry and they didn't get any of the orders correct. DO NOT order the belgian waffle unless you want 3 triangles of a tiny waffle, cant even give thw whole freaking waffle. All in all the food was tereible and over priced. The service was terrible they never came around looking to fill water or even give us utensils. We spent an hour and half here and regretted every minute. Thanks for coming to my ted talk

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

GabyP

We were there for brunch, the menu has variety and the whole table doesn't have to order the bottomless as they do it per person. Service was excellent and were allowed to stay longer than the 90min

Loading...