Mayhem & Stout

230 Park Ave, New York
(212) 986-1600

Recent Reviews

Brian Smith

This place is great - always high quality beer list, served well. Always a good chat with the bartenders - was my go to on the way home via Grand Central.So disappointed to hear that they will be closing because the Urban Space team pushed them out for their own mediocre, over priced bar (with a terrible beer list). Especially disappointing considering Mayhem kept Urban Space alive during the pandemic. No loyalty means I am done with Urban Space once Mayhem closes. Sad.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Larry The Native Guy

They no longer serve meals, but a great place to try their beer or wine.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Christoffer Jakobsen

Apparently they've moved within the Urbanspace food hall, so don't freak out you don't find them at first. They are still open! They no longer serve food but there's plenty of that around. A short but sweet beer list with a dozen or so options on draft, plus cans. Friendly and knowledgeable bartenders if you need a recommendation.

Christopher H.

I am so sick of the customer service at this place. They sell out and just stay open, which makes no sense. And then when I go up to them, they ask "how they can help" and then proceed to have me order multiple sandwiches before telling me they're sold out for the day. It's annoying.

Annie G.

Oh my God, Mayhem Sandwiches was really cool. Very unique environment that you have to experience. Many of the menu items are heavenly. Very flavorful and excellent service. Found Mayhem Sandwiches with the help of yelp and would return any time.

Rich H

I had the pulled pork with the regular fries I was really disappointed the pork was watery which made the sandwich extremely difficult to eat!. I couldn’t even finish it!. Mayhem you certainly live up to your name and not in a good way. Someone said not to bother with this place I couldn’t agree more!

Jon W

Fantastic sandwiches!!!!

Eline C.

The best banh mi and the coolest lady manning the place makes this a favorite every time.

Mrtubbula

Fantastic sandwiches!!!!

John H.

The best beer selection and great food!! Can't wait to go back. Every beer I tried was delicious and lover the bahn mi.

Chris L.

I got "The Dragon" my first time and loved it. I keep trying to talk myself into doing one of the other sandwiches, but I like The Dragon too much to branch out. The rotating taps are great as well.

Karen

Had the banh mi sandwich, which wasn’t really banh mi, more like pulled pork in a bun with shredded daikon and pickled carrots. But, it was still delicious! A steal through MealPal!

Kevin Rosado

Great craft beer selection. for a small place. you an also get the pitchers. The dragon BBQ sauce and Coleslaw were solid and the meal definitely filled me up.

Sheily Agurto

had the truffle Mac and cheese. Never again. It was not good at all. Cold. I know my tastebuds won’t be the same as yours but just saying I’ve had a couple different things with truffle in it and it’s never tasted that. Bad. Besides that the woman who took my order was so nasty. She didn’t look at me in the eyes once, told me the truffle and bacon Mac and cheese tasted the same so to just pick either one, i know we all have bad days but she was on another level. If i could give them 0 stars i 100% would :/.

Rich Hong

I had the pulled pork with the regular fries I was really disappointed the pork was watery which made the sandwich extremely difficult to eat!. I couldn’t even finish it!. Mayhem you certainly live up to your name and not in a good way. Someone said not to bother with this place I couldn’t agree more!

Load More