Midtown Catch Seafood

405 E 57th St, New York
(646) 918-7560

Recent Reviews

Sort by
James Canales

Freshest seafood in the City and no one provides better service than Mikey Fish!

carolyn scott

I read the specials board when walking to my friend's building next door and always wonder, what are the prices like? Why don't they post menus on their google map site?

Georgina Rosenblatt

The best in every way.

Vee Va

The service is awesome … The prepared clams for spaghetti and clams fantastic& if you are fortunate when they have Stuffed Artichokes a not to miss … this is one if not the best in Manhattan

Tracey Dryden

Our family has been getting fish from Mike for years. The fish is amazing, the service knowledgeable and friendly. And if you like creamed herring--and my father adores it--Mike's is heavenly!

Laura J

Just came across the shop and it’s wonderful! Mike the owner is super friendly and the fish is fresh. Cooked the scallops and baccalà we bought today

Z L

The location and service is great. But seafoods here are more expensive than those sold in New Jersey.

cecile komplita

The fish is always fresh and Michael is very helpful and nice. I order for the holidays every year and he always has the best. His cooked fish, crab cakes and sauces are very good. I won't buy my fish anywhere else.

Jeremy Behmoaras

Very fresh and very delicious fish!

Galen Morgan Cooper

Best shrimp on the East Coast!!!!

David Behmoaras

This place is fantastic. The best choice in midtown, if not all of Manhattan, for fresh fish. And reasonably priced too.

Cindy Chin

Best Fresh Salmon! It was delicious!

Aleksandra Kim

Great seafood store. Everything is very fresh and great quality. Staff is kind, knowledgeable, super nice. Good price for the quality you get. I love coming here.

Caroline Hufschmitt

I highly recommend this place. My husband and I wanted to celebrate our anniversary with a seafood platter. The quality and freshness of our feast was exceptional. The service is outstanding, it made me think of NY years ago, very personalized, they take the time to listen to what you actually want to accommodate the best they can. We will go back without a doubt.

Francesco

Great fish, good service and very clean.I was hoping in more selections and more shellfish, I guess isn’t the period.Let’s check next time!I’ll be back next week for some Sanpietro (I guess here is John Dory)!

Loading...