Milk Bar

561 Columbus Ave, New York
(212) 256-0586

Recent Reviews

Manny Sergentakis

What a great soft serve. Got to try both flavors and loved them both. Can't wait to take the kids there. I am sure they will love it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarail Graves

If I could give 0 stars I would. I order a cake from this location to pick up today an no one is there. Prepaid and everything. Unacceptable. Now I have drive an extra hour to a different location to get a cake at one of there others locations. I expect a refund when they contact me back

Alex Chernyaev

Some friendly folks work

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Akarsh Rastogi

Cookies were ~

Food: 2

Marc T.

Arrived here for a sweet treat break with my colleague around 4 pm on Thursday! It wasn't busy at all; we were ordering immediately. The store itself is so cute with its pink neon lights, merchandise and decor. I ordered their DIY pint and got the following: cereal milk, double chocolate, fudge, and chocolate crumb. It was splendid! Lots of sweetness packed into a pint. The elements of sugar added sweetness, decadence, and richness, especially with the dark chocolate. Sweet memories made!

Anna S

I wanted to try the Milk Bar Pie since seeing it on Chef's table. It was everything I dreamed of. If we were heading right home I'd have bought a whole pie ?

Lara F.

My bf wants a slice of cake and Milkbar was in front of us. He tried a $12 slice of bday cake as well as the chocolate cake with vanilla icing. He was hoping it would be an moist sponge cake with not too sweet buttercream. This was not the case....Milkbar added cream cheese into the bday cake which made it unappealing. Then on the chocolate sponge cake it was heavy with odd crunchy bits within it. With all the good bakeries around the city I'm not sure how they stay afloat.

Jonna M

My sister and I walked 0.7 miles in pouring rain to visit Milk Bar. We were mesmerized by the many menu options. I settled on a slice of Birthday cake that was freaking delicious!! The cake was so moist with good icing ratio and cake wasn't super-cloyingly sweet.

Ashley Rivera

Best cake the frosting isn’t too sweet it’s perfect I’ve been addicted to the pie for some time and I was wanting to try the cakes for some time I finally was able too and it did not disappoint

Christina M.

I had a terrible experience here years ago and was hesitant to come back. However, got excellent service tonight from Kaitlyn, she deserves a raise!!!!! Sweet and lovely person, inside and out!!

Lex Minniti

Beautiful store and products. Julie the manager keeps a gorgeous clean , tidy and fun store! All the displays are so gorgeous, everything so clean. And staff so accommodating with a large group that bought treats and enjoyed in store.

Vinay Saggar

Sugary dessert shop with a good blend of salty+sweet options including cookies and soft-serves with topping options. A bit extreme on the contrasts and the cookies are definitely the stronger of the options. $4 a dessert. 3.5/5 stars as a dessert shop.

Nino L.

Had a large hot chocolate for $5.75, could have had more powder in it

Kinji

Today I went to the Milk Bar for the first time and I was overwhelmed by all the options they have! Thankfully an employee named Nate was able to answer all my questions and help me figure out what to purchase. He made my experience one to remember and I will most certainly will be returning to this Milk Bar!

Nicole Camm

We ordered online because we were craving cake. Magnolias was closed so we thought to try a new place. Cake was disappointing. A $12.50 slice you would think it would not be overly sweet, stale, and smashed. Also expected it to be a bit bigger. We ended up throwing it out after two bites. Next time will stick to Magnolias!

Load More