Mulligan's Pub

267 Madison Ave, New York
(212) 286-0207

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eduardo Bueno

Shawn is the man, he’s the best. Such a kind genuine soul and makes the best drinks ever, made me wanna be a bartender. GIVE THIS MAN A RAISE PLEASE !!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Mother Ofboys

Was very excited to return to mulligans after our last visit a few years ago. Was so disappointed. The food was awful. Couldn’t eat it. Atmosphere is great though and definitely recommend having a drink in there if your a Liverpool fan.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Charley Wojcik

Great cheese burger cold draft beer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dylan Kerr

It’s a Liverpool pub hahaha
Only joking with the one star atmosphere but it is a Liverpool pub should be zero stars hahaha
If your a Liverpool fan it’s a great bar to come too it’s a great sports bar

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Stephanie Iaconetti

Stopped here on the way to MSG. Good food, good beer selection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brenda Sheehan

Super Friendly Waitress. Food was good.
Fun place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isabelle Katz

Sophie was an amazing waitress, she was so attentive and had great recs - we had the best time me and Roberto ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Rivera

I went to mulligan’s with my partner and enjoyed my dinner. It was close to grand central station and packed on a week night in December (of course) however our server was attentive and led us to a free table. We were helped after given a few minutes to look over the menu and we also started with two wines. Found out my partner does not like either of the wines but that’s alright for me I’m not a sommelier so I’ll just focus on on the food. Our appetizer to start was bang bang shrimp the sauce accompanying it has a good portion and consistency and flavor refreshing with a nice kick. The size was medium but a good price for an app for 2-3 people to share . Only con was the arugula under neath for fresh garnish fell flat on the arrangement and presentation but for the peak service around 8:30pm I understand. The other food items we had was the black jack burger and chili. Firstly, the black Angus burger was excellent and best of the three food items we had. The fries were a nice medium petite with a nice crisp and although the onion could have been sliced thinner, the portion size was satisfying.

The chili was good, maybe a bit mild for some but it isn’t.t spicy chili so just add black pepper to taste. The grit was on the finger size but my partner mentioned the chess blend was great and the nachos on the side were festive and fun.

Only con for service was that the passer , not the waitress could have slowed down a bit and placed the plate gently on the table it was placed as an angle and about 5-8 fries fell off. If he had announced himself or stopped his motion , I know super har om a tight space, but it was just close to out other dishes and had our wine glasses been there it would of been non optimal.

Otherwise it was a pleasant evening, again for the prices those items rounded out to about 100$ after tip so if you want budget just go to a quick service venue and also the noise volume remains load here and the bar can be tight on exit so accessibility for larger folks and sensory sensitive — maybe try elsewhere or come during opening hours during the day.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Emily Aldous

My friends and I stumbled upon this restaurant after going to the Bryant Park Christmas markets. Initially we planned to grab a quick drink and then head to a different dinner spot. However, the fun and vibrant energy of the pub encouraged us to stay for dinner. The food was amazing, the drinks were delicious, and the vibes were great. If you are looking for a no frills, go Irish pub in NYC this is the place to go.

Recommend: the fried chicken sandwich. Seriously this is the best chicken sandwich I have EVER tasted

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Saul Kaiserman

Irish pub with midtown crowd

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Shannon Harknett

Great place for happy hour! Love meeting friends here. Drinks, staff, and vibes are great!

Service: 5

Thomas Kelly

Sorry never been there

Charlotte Nielsen

Always a good time! Great atmosphere and service! The potato skins are a great treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Abraham Vergara

How sad, the bartender gave us terrible service and was discriminatory towards my wife.

I don't recommend this place

Gaea Erlich

A true hidden gem! Everything is just 1000/10 - food, drinks, service, atmosphere, music. Best buffalo wings we’ve had by far & great cocktails 🤍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...