My Pie Pizzeria Romana

690 Lexington Ave, New York
(212) 317-1850

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joletta Windley

I do not like pizza but after having the truffle oil and mushrooms I can honestly say it was best and if I come back - would definitely come back . The girl who was behind the counter was absolutely wonderful—lovely customer service!!

Jake Sklodowski

Great atmosphere great pizza too. The prices for New York aren’t too shabby. The workers are super super nice. Can’t recommend more.

Malcolm Longaker

Great Vegan Slices!!!

Lauren Helene

My favorite spot to grab a slice of pizza in NY! I love the crispiness of the crust, the variety of flavors, and how generous they are with every topping. Plus, the staff here are super friendly and go out of their way to provide a good experience! I only get to come every 3-6 months because I live out of state but they somehow remember me every time, which is always a nice feeling. The last time I was here, I came a little after the dinner rush and was disappointed that they had run out of my favorite flavor - and they offered to make me a pie fresh!

The inside only has 5 small tables so it can get a little crowded during a rush but they have great to go boxes so you can enjoy your slices on the go or in one of the many nearby parks.

Nat Tripodi

The crisp, thin crust is the best reason to try this place out. The various selections are very tasty.

Stephanie McCauley

Always delicious and not overly greasy! Note that there is limited seating but usually not an issue.

Scott MacDonald

Wonderfully nice staff and delicious pizza!!

Noraly Tillemans

Loved it! By far the best pizza ever had

Suraya D

Crunchies crust! It's very tasty. Most ingredients are directly from Italy.

Henrik Pettersen

Fantastic good pizza ! Best for take-away since the place is very small and just some few places to sit.

Roman Denysenko

Very tasty pizza, atmospheric place ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amarachi Okorom

The best vegan pizza options - I go out of my way to come here!

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options (to be expected) and vegan options (pleasantly surprising!)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D J

Small pizzeria had some delicious pizzas by the slice. The base is amazingly good crunchy and topping’s fresh and generous. Staff were very friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Truffle Oil & Mushroom Slice

Harry Otto

So, this is your basic super-duper ‘we think we’re in Italy’ pizzeria, where they pile on grated cheese to make you feel special. But when I asked for something without Pecorino Romano, they went above and beyond to make sure I got the perfect slice of pizza. These guys are incredible, even though it seems like the owner might be Chinese, lol.

As a sidenote, when the pizza comes out, it does not look crispy but when you bite it, it definitely is the real deal. I don’t know how they do it, but they mess with the crust to make it crispy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Waleska Pizzo

Best pizza in NY… the crust is something else!! You won’t regret it! ♥️♥️ also, the personality and recommendations of Heba were amazing, can’t wait to go again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...