Mysttik Masaala

230 Park Avenue, New York
(917) 306-3128

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ashwin K

Just read the reviews, I changed my mind.. And I saved my Money and will not go here.. Bad reviews.. Even 5 star review said tlit was OK and expensive $15 for a bhel.. Glad I saved.. Thank you for all the reviews..

José Tomás Fernández

Very expensive and food was terrible. Wasn't even worth it to take a picture for the bad review.

Butter chicken: Dry shredded chicken, no gravy, for $20? Never again

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Makhani - Butter Chicken

Jacqueline W

Worse Indian food I've ever had and is certainly not authentic. I hate to waste money on something so precious as my stomach and this was a total waste of money get new recipes or don't call yourself Indian food. Why is my masala chicken so red it's supposed to be orange isn't it?? This was red and crunchy from coleslaw?? and not tasty except for cilantro? I don't know if it's because food has Portuguese influence or what. Just terrible 🤢my stomach is appalled. Either the cook doesn't care, doesn't wash their hands or both that's how I feel about this garbage. Y'all are playing with my stomach and I don't appreciate it because it is unsettled and I only had a few bites before turned off. Samosa was old not fresh like it had been sitting all day baking out under lights and spice covered up the flavor. Glass bottled Mango juice was good.

Food: 1

Mindy Romero

I would give this place negative stars if I could. It's expensive $18.50 for white rice and a main dish. I ordered chicken saag. I was given rice chicken vindaloo with a little spinach on the side. I brought the food back to the cashier and explained this is not what I ordered. She said that is what it is, chicken vindloo and saag on the side. I knew it eas that because my friend ordered chicken vindaloo. It didnt even taste good anyhow. The cashier stated the only difference was the spinach wasn't blended. I said no, chicken saag is chicken stewed in the saag not separate items. She argued with me and continued to say the same thing. I asked for a refund and she continued to tell me different places make it differently. She kept saying that's what you ordered. It's ridiculous. I said if that's what you're giving people then you need to change the name and the picture. Then another worker came over and said we're just workers and don't control the food or signs. The two if them started talking to each which appeared as if she was telling her she gave me the wrong thing. But she never admitted it and it was one of the worst experiences I've had in a long time. The workers are rude and clueless. Please save your money and go somewhere else. Small portion, high cost, didn't taste good, and horrible service. The
Urban Hawker is hot and doesn't have comfortable seating. Much rather spend a little more and go to an actual restaurant.

Hi. Thank you for replying to my review. It was at the Urban Hawker location. I did get a refund. The employees should be trained better to know the food they are preparing and serving. They were also arguing with me which was not a pleasant experience especially with the uncomfortable confrontation it caused.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kenneth Fevre

Wow. Very tasty Chana Masala. As always I go for the vegan choices, preferably the healthy ones.
This Masala was very tasty, a bit on the hot side. Got it with salad of course. And there was a great amount of chick peas that made it quite nutritious.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

George Mallory

hello guys,Actually to be honest I dont want to give even one star to this shop but I dont have a choice to give one star.I had faced worse experienced and I dont recommend to anyone.One and only expensive ordinary Samosa I have ever had in my life.Foods was expensive and not hygienic as well as not provide utensil too.

Chantel Watson

super delicious quick and friendly service i would definitely do dinner for me and my family here again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Tikka, Roll, Chicken Vindaloo, Chicken Biryani

Cassandra S.

I had the Chicken Tikka Masala. The service was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Tikka

Manoj Thomas

I had a chicken tikka masala. The wrap was too thick and cold. The raw onions seemed a bit stale. And the tea was too sugary, tasting more like a dessert. The Kati Roll Company is definitely a better choice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Daniel Finnie

Ordered the chicken Tikka masala bowl and naan. They were out of samosas. Chicken Tikka masala was dry and not very flavorful. Naan was not fresh, had no flavor, and was soggy from being out so long in foil. Cashier was on Instagram and did not answer questions.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Michael Engel

Chicken tikka masala was sub-par. Mediocre overly salty sauce, bad cuts of chicken and rice is drenched through with sauce. 3 bites of it unsettled my stomach. After that, I ended up tossing it and went somewhere else for lunch.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

ADITI KURUTALA 20BCY10006

Mysttik Masala is a true gem for anyone craving authentic Indian cuisine. The food is absolutely delicious, with rich flavors that transport you straight to India.

The hospitality here is exceptional – the staff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcome and ensure you have an amazing dining experience. Whether it’s a friendly smile, quick service, or thoughtful recommendations, their attention to detail is top-notch.

What makes it even better is the value for money. The portion sizes are generous, and the quality of the food surpasses expectations for the price.

If you're a fan of Indian food or just looking to try something new, Mysttik Masala should be at the top of your list. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Tikka, Chicken Vindaloo

Sergey Barinov

Overpriced with watery curry, dry chicken, rancid vegetables and absolutely flavourless.
After eating their tikka masala and vindaloo my stomach immediately did not feel good, and some of the bites I took tasted really off.
2 hours later I had full blown food poisoning.
Stay away from this disgusting place.

Arham Jain

The cashier is so rude and doesn’t listen to the customers even after spending almost 50$

Service: 1

Dr Roli Nath

We ordered Bhel Puri from the Mysttik Masala Bryant Part stall. Contrary to our expectations, it was salty with no tanginess. We clearly ordered a spicy Bhel, so we were expecting a blend of tanginess and spiciness but for sure no salt. We had a bite and decided to return, but we found the guy at the counter was rude. He tried convincing us this is how it is, and when we said it’s salty, he said, I can’t replace it. Order something else in a very disrespectful and rude way. We were quiet till then. Later, he gave us a samosa chat with an attitude of “ go now” as if he favored us. This is the point we had to ask him to be a little humble, respectful, and empathetic to customers. We have never heard him say please or sorry at any moment. Lastly, neither Bhel Puri nor Samosa chat was worth it. We had to dump the Samosa chat box as it was not made correctly. Don't recommend!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...