Employees are attentive and courteous. The meals and dessert are not typical of an Italian restaurant. Nevertheless, we had fun and were able to enjoy the evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
dan K
My wife and I stopped for a quick bite and had a bad experience. I came here often before pandemic but 1st time since. Feel kind of bad because definitely not the same. Atmosphere wasn’t very warm. Paid $60 for pasta and pizza. Blasted 60s rock so we real couldn’t talk. Judge for yourself how it went.Parking: Easy parking
daniel Krevis
My wife and I stopped for a quick bite and had a bad experience. I came here often before pandemic but 1st time since. Feel kind of bad because definitely not the same. Atmosphere wasn’t very warm. Paid $60 for pasta and pizza. Blasted 60s rock so we real couldn’t talk. Judge for yourself how it went.Parking: Easy parking
Billypea
2nd time in a row we were burned by this place. Great when they were on 2nd and 10th but now Nicoletta is a bad joke. Last time they gave us a pepperoni/mushroom pizza with 4 pieces of pepperoni on it. Yes. 4. … This time, after waiting more than an hour and ten minutes, we called to hear that the pizza had been delivered quite some time ago. Apparently the driver decided to leave it on the sidewalk, (and sent in a pic of the pizza sitting in front of our building) rather than ring our bell and actually make a delivery. We tried hard to let them make it right but the best response we got was that we would be refunded sometime after they closed out the night. Will update this review if no refund is made. Sad they never did anything to fix it, one less customer (and friends) for Nicoletta.
Henry Torres
The meatball pizza is delicious! Crust is nice and toasty, meatballs are yummy and sauce is just right too! Perfect place to people watch on a Saturday evening! The server was attentive friendly and quick! Will definitely be back soon!
Jerry Werner
great ambiance \\u0026 decor. the bill was reasonable i would say.
Brian Psota
Outstanding Buffalo pie, very fresh.
Meg Rios Moser
My favorite pizza in NJ, so good! Thanks for staying open, making pies and keeping us all happy during this crazy time!!
Joey Song
Absolutely love their pizza, wings, and arancini
Deeski Rivera
Love the pizzas wish they had more of a vegetable pizza
I had the pleasure of eating at Nicoletta Pizzeria with some friends. It’s funny - there are so many places to eat in NYC, but some of the best spots don’t get the notoriety they should - like Nicoletta. The food was SO good, from the small plates to the delicious pizza that I (sadly) polished off and woke up craving the next day.
Stephen Pokoj
Not bad. Good selection from which to choose. Would go again.
Emily Naphtal
I love Nicoletta especially their Parmigiana pizza. Heaven! I hope they get a new store front soon but will continue to order from them until they do.
Dionne Cochrane
Had an amazing 3 course meal here. The Funghi pizza with mushrooms and spinach was perfect. For dessert I customized my gelato sundae with my favorite toppings.
Yashad Kirtane
Wood fired oven pizza, gourmet toppings, worth every penny
Employees are attentive and courteous. The meals and dessert are not typical of an Italian restaurant. Nevertheless, we had fun and were able to enjoy the evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
My wife and I stopped for a quick bite and had a bad experience. I came here often before pandemic but 1st time since. Feel kind of bad because definitely not the same. Atmosphere wasn’t very warm. Paid $60 for pasta and pizza. Blasted 60s rock so we real couldn’t talk. Judge for yourself how it went.Parking: Easy parking
My wife and I stopped for a quick bite and had a bad experience. I came here often before pandemic but 1st time since. Feel kind of bad because definitely not the same. Atmosphere wasn’t very warm. Paid $60 for pasta and pizza. Blasted 60s rock so we real couldn’t talk. Judge for yourself how it went.Parking: Easy parking
2nd time in a row we were burned by this place. Great when they were on 2nd and 10th but now Nicoletta is a bad joke. Last time they gave us a pepperoni/mushroom pizza with 4 pieces of pepperoni on it. Yes. 4. … This time, after waiting more than an hour and ten minutes, we called to hear that the pizza had been delivered quite some time ago. Apparently the driver decided to leave it on the sidewalk, (and sent in a pic of the pizza sitting in front of our building) rather than ring our bell and actually make a delivery. We tried hard to let them make it right but the best response we got was that we would be refunded sometime after they closed out the night. Will update this review if no refund is made. Sad they never did anything to fix it, one less customer (and friends) for Nicoletta.
The meatball pizza is delicious! Crust is nice and toasty, meatballs are yummy and sauce is just right too! Perfect place to people watch on a Saturday evening! The server was attentive friendly and quick! Will definitely be back soon!
great ambiance \\u0026 decor. the bill was reasonable i would say.
Outstanding Buffalo pie, very fresh.
My favorite pizza in NJ, so good! Thanks for staying open, making pies and keeping us all happy during this crazy time!!
Absolutely love their pizza, wings, and arancini
Love the pizzas wish they had more of a vegetable pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I had the pleasure of eating at Nicoletta Pizzeria with some friends. It’s funny - there are so many places to eat in NYC, but some of the best spots don’t get the notoriety they should - like Nicoletta. The food was SO good, from the small plates to the delicious pizza that I (sadly) polished off and woke up craving the next day.
Not bad. Good selection from which to choose. Would go again.
I love Nicoletta especially their Parmigiana pizza. Heaven! I hope they get a new store front soon but will continue to order from them until they do.
Had an amazing 3 course meal here. The Funghi pizza with mushrooms and spinach was perfect. For dessert I customized my gelato sundae with my favorite toppings.
Wood fired oven pizza, gourmet toppings, worth every penny