Pizza was okay, somewhat raw tbh. This business does not recycle. In a realm of limited resources, this is an atrocity. Liberals should have their priorities examined.
Adam Sanford
Weird, but this place is very good. Been in nyc 50+ years, haven't had a 'wtf, this is awesome' pizza moment in awhile. VERY surprised, but they really care about the food. Nice to see. Again.
Natasha Gayle
If you’re shopping in Herald Square and need a quick bite, this pizza spot inside Macy’s is a convenient option. The slice was surprisingly good garlicky buttery, not too greasy, and hit the spot. The atmosphere leaves a lot to be desired; it was a bit dirty and there was only one person working, so don’t expect fast or polished service. Still, if you’re looking for something quick and easy that’s not McDonald’s, this does the trick.
Amara V
the pizza was edible... it was a super greasy, large & thin slice. only stopped by bc i was hungry while at macy's and was curious since it looked busy. i would not recommend it though.
Frances
Another delicious meal with attentive service from the same waiter we had last week. Great space, comfortable seating. Wonderful location for those needing to get to NJ Transit and LIRR trains.
Frances
Had a delicious, relaxing meal with wonderful attentive service from our waiter, Mr. S Saleem, at Stella 34 Trattoria. I was hot from the walk across town and our waiter quickly provided glasses of ice water. The fig and prosciutto pizza recommended by our waiter was very tasty! We also had the fried calamari, eggplant parm, and the salad with the salami and dates - all delicious. We enjoyed our meal and was able to have wonderful conversations as it was a quiet environment. We will be back.
Angela
This is my go to place in midtown for good food, nice and friendly service, lovely setting and a moderate level of noise which makes it easy to catch up with a friend or conduct business with a client. I've been there more often for lunch and have also had a good experience when I've been there for dinner.
Jacqueline
We were going to see a show at MSG. I booked Stella's as it had good reviews and had an early dining reservation to allow us to enjoy dinner without having to rush. It was only a block from MSG and parking was extremely close to both the restaurant as well as MSG. We all enjoyed our dish selections as well as the dessert choices. We would definitely return again and recommend Stella's.
Margaret Ann
If your in Macy's 34th Street and have the time, do plane to eat at Stella 34. Hard to get a table by the windows as everyone wants to be there, but regardless it's a lovely well-lit space. Good is delicious and service too
I love this restaurant! It is conveniently located, whether you are arriving at Penn Station,shopping at Macy's, or doing chores in the midtown west side. The menu offers a nice variety, including soup, salads, main courses, and desserts. . The service is prompt, accurate,and unobtrusive. If you want to linger, they don't act as if they mind. I did not feel hustled to leave. Last but definitely not least: I have had lunch at Stella 34 several times and everything I have ever eaten there has been delicious.
Huseyin
Service and people who work here are good, from Maitre D to our server, they are friendly and helpful. It's clean, bright, airy (high ceilings) so noise level is also lower than some other restaurants, but still can get noisy at busy times. Food is OK, I know some complained but there are some great choices, good food options like pastas and some seafood dishes, but if you are into salads, you might be disappointed. For the price, the portion should be larger and the ingredients should be better quality. Caesar salad is decent, fresh but small, this time we didn't get olive oil and bread on the table either, we usually get that without asking. Di Farro salad had crumbled cheese, it said feta in the menu but I barely tasted the feta, the Farro was chewy. I went with plus chicken but I expected a better salad for $27, it kinda felt like salad-bar salad. Branzino was good according to people in my party. Drinks are reasonably priced for the place. I would go back without a doubt but I would probably skip the Di Farro and maybe ask the server for the recommendation for the day.
Massimo
Buona cucina italiana. Pasta cotta perfettamente. Un po' di eccesso di pepe nel condimento che ha coperto i sapori. Prezzi nella norma, anche se i primi sono forse un po' troppo cari
Lory
What a wonderful surprise to have such a great restaurant in Macy's with great vibe beautiful large windows and nice seating. Great service! We went at lunch time, and we did not feel rushed or have that loud buzz. It was so great to be able to enjoy great lunch great space and vibe! Loved it!
Mary
Food as always was great. Service was mediocre at best. Forgot about lemon for water till end. Said she would wipe table and didn't between courses and ordered a cappuccino with desert - came afterwards. Said would take off bill wanted. Instead of taking off. Disappointing service.
Very good pizza
Pizza was okay, somewhat raw tbh. This business does not recycle. In a realm of limited resources, this is an atrocity. Liberals should have their priorities examined.
Weird, but this place is very good. Been in nyc 50+ years, haven't had a 'wtf, this is awesome' pizza moment in awhile. VERY surprised, but they really care about the food. Nice to see. Again.
If you’re shopping in Herald Square and need a quick bite, this pizza spot inside Macy’s is a convenient option. The slice was surprisingly good garlicky buttery, not too greasy, and hit the spot. The atmosphere leaves a lot to be desired; it was a bit dirty and there was only one person working, so don’t expect fast or polished service. Still, if you’re looking for something quick and easy that’s not McDonald’s, this does the trick.
the pizza was edible... it was a super greasy, large & thin slice. only stopped by bc i was hungry while at macy's and was curious since it looked busy. i would not recommend it though.
Another delicious meal with attentive service from the same waiter we had last week. Great space, comfortable seating. Wonderful location for those needing to get to NJ Transit and LIRR trains.
Had a delicious, relaxing meal with wonderful attentive service from our waiter, Mr. S Saleem, at Stella 34 Trattoria. I was hot from the walk across town and our waiter quickly provided glasses of ice water. The fig and prosciutto pizza recommended by our waiter was very tasty! We also had the fried calamari, eggplant parm, and the salad with the salami and dates - all delicious. We enjoyed our meal and was able to have wonderful conversations as it was a quiet environment. We will be back.
This is my go to place in midtown for good food, nice and friendly service, lovely setting and a moderate level of noise which makes it easy to catch up with a friend or conduct business with a client. I've been there more often for lunch and have also had a good experience when I've been there for dinner.
We were going to see a show at MSG. I booked Stella's as it had good reviews and had an early dining reservation to allow us to enjoy dinner without having to rush. It was only a block from MSG and parking was extremely close to both the restaurant as well as MSG. We all enjoyed our dish selections as well as the dessert choices. We would definitely return again and recommend Stella's.
If your in Macy's 34th Street and have the time, do plane to eat at Stella 34. Hard to get a table by the windows as everyone wants to be there, but regardless it's a lovely well-lit space. Good is delicious and service too
Restaurantji Recommends
I love this restaurant! It is conveniently located, whether you are arriving at Penn Station,shopping at Macy's, or doing chores in the midtown west side. The menu offers a nice variety, including soup, salads, main courses, and desserts. . The service is prompt, accurate,and unobtrusive. If you want to linger, they don't act as if they mind. I did not feel hustled to leave. Last but definitely not least: I have had lunch at Stella 34 several times and everything I have ever eaten there has been delicious.
Service and people who work here are good, from Maitre D to our server, they are friendly and helpful. It's clean, bright, airy (high ceilings) so noise level is also lower than some other restaurants, but still can get noisy at busy times. Food is OK, I know some complained but there are some great choices, good food options like pastas and some seafood dishes, but if you are into salads, you might be disappointed. For the price, the portion should be larger and the ingredients should be better quality. Caesar salad is decent, fresh but small, this time we didn't get olive oil and bread on the table either, we usually get that without asking. Di Farro salad had crumbled cheese, it said feta in the menu but I barely tasted the feta, the Farro was chewy. I went with plus chicken but I expected a better salad for $27, it kinda felt like salad-bar salad. Branzino was good according to people in my party. Drinks are reasonably priced for the place. I would go back without a doubt but I would probably skip the Di Farro and maybe ask the server for the recommendation for the day.
Buona cucina italiana. Pasta cotta perfettamente. Un po' di eccesso di pepe nel condimento che ha coperto i sapori. Prezzi nella norma, anche se i primi sono forse un po' troppo cari
What a wonderful surprise to have such a great restaurant in Macy's with great vibe beautiful large windows and nice seating. Great service! We went at lunch time, and we did not feel rushed or have that loud buzz. It was so great to be able to enjoy great lunch great space and vibe! Loved it!
Food as always was great. Service was mediocre at best. Forgot about lemon for water till end. Said she would wipe table and didn't between courses and ordered a cappuccino with desert - came afterwards. Said would take off bill wanted. Instead of taking off. Disappointing service.
Loading...