Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew

66 Madison Ave, New York
(929) 281-3222

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Plain Italian or Old Bay Fries
Garlic Battered Cheddar Bites
Buffalo Cauliflower Bites
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
Philly Cheesesteak
Roast Pork Special
Craft Beers on Tap
Sweet BBQ Wings
Italian Fries

Menu

Starters
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
Side of Queso
Buffalo Cauliflower Bites
Side Spicy Honey
Garlic Battered Cheddar Bites
Side of Marinara
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Side of Garlic Aioli
Roasted Brussels
Balsamic Glaze, Parmesan
Real Deal Philly Pretzel (3)
Side of Yellow Mustard
Real Deal Philly Pretzel (5)
Side of Yellow Mustard

Fries
Plain Fries
Italian Fries
Italian Seasoning Topped with Parmesan Cheese
Old Bay Fries
Seasoned with Old Bay
Cheese Fries - Whiz
Smothered in Whiz
Cheese Fries - Queso
Smothered in Queso
Bacon Cheese Fries - Whiz
Whiz and Crispy Bacon
Bacon Cheese Fries - Queso
Queso and Crispy Bacon
City Fries - Steak (8oz)
Whiz or Queso, Fried Onions, Cherry Peppers
City Fries - Chicken Steak (8oz)
Whiz or Queso, Fried Onions, Cherry Peppers

Cheesesteaks (8oz) - Served on Fresh Baked Liscio's Hoagie Rolls
Cheesesteak
Chicken Steak
Pizza
Marinara, Provolone
Special
Broccoli Rabe, Cooper Sharp
Buffalo
Hot or Mild; Blue Cheese or Ranch
Club
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, American
Garlic Aioli
Garlic Aioli, Grilled Tomatoes, Sweet Peppers, Fried Onions, Provolone
Mango Habanero
Mango Habanero Sauce, Ghost Pepper Jack, Fried Onions

Smash Burgers
Cheddar Smash Burger
Bacon Cheddar Smash Burger

Salads
House Salad- Crispy Chicken
Romaine, Cherry Heirlooms, Red Onion, Garlic Parm Croutons, Side of Oil & Vinegar
Caesar Salad- Crispy Chicken
Romaine, Parmesan, Garlic Parmesan Croutons, TOSSED IN Caesar Dressing
Bacon Ranch Salad- Crispy Chicken
Romaine, Cherry Heirlooms, Bacon, Side of Ranch

Vegetarian Cheesesteaks
Green Special
Broccoli Rabe, Cooper Sharp
Veggie Combo
Broccoli Rabe, Sweet Peppers, Mushrooms, Fried Onions, Cooper Sharp; Marinara on the Side

Philly-Style Specialties
Roast Pork Special
Thinly Sliced Center Cut Pork Loin, Broccoli Rabe, Cooper Sharp, Side of Au Jus
Italian Hoagie
Mortadella, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Pepperoni, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions, Banana Peppers, Oregano, Side of Oil & Vinegar

Crispy Chicken Sandwiches
Crispy Buffalo Chicken
Hot or Mild Buffalo Sauce, Blue Cheese or Ranch, Provolone
Crispy Chicken Special
Broccoli Rabe, Cooper Sharp
Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch
Bacon, Romaine, Tomato, Red Onion, Provolone
Crispy Chicken Garlic Aioli
Garlic Aioli, Romaine, Tomato, Red Onion, Provolone
Crispy Chicken Spicy Honey
Spicy Honey, Ranch, Pickles, Ghost Pepper Jack
Crispy Chicken - Cheddar

Dipping Sauces/ Dressings
Queso- Side
Spicy Honey - Side
Marinara - Side
Garlic Aioli - Side
Honey Mustard - Side
Hot Buffalo Sauce - Side
Mild Buffalo Sauce - Side
Garlic Parmesan - Side
Blue Cheese - Side
Ranch - Side
Whiz- Side
Yellow Mustard - Side
Mango Habanero - Side
Oil & Vinegar - Side
Mayo - Side
Au Jus
Side of Carrots & Celery
Philly Gold - Side
Sweet Thai Chili - Side
Honey BBQ - Side
Hot & Spicy BBQ - Side
Chipotle BBQ - Side
Lemon Pepper Sauce - Side

Wings
Sauced Wings- Mild Buffalo
10-Piece Served with Blue Cheese or Ranch
Sauced Wings - Hot Buffalo
10-Piece Served with Blue Cheese or Ranch
Sauced Wings - Mango Habanero
Blue Cheese - Side
Ranch - Side
Sauced Wings - Philly Gold
Sauced Wings - Sweet Thai Chili
Sauced Wings - Hot & Spicy BBQ
Sauced Wings - Honey BBQ
Sauced Wings - Chipotle BBQ
Sauced Wings - Lemon Pepper

Tenders
Sauced Tenders - Mango Habanero
Sauced Tenders - Philly Gold
Sauced Tenders - Sweet Thai Chili
Sauced Tenders - Hot & Spicy BBQ
Sauced Tenders - Honey BBQ
Sauced Tenders - Chipotle BBQ
Sauced Tenders - Lemon Pepper

Madison Soda Bottles/Cans
Coke Can
Diet Coke Can
Sprite Zero Can
Sprite Can
Ginger Ale Can
Bottled Water
Red Bull Can
Lacroix Sparkling
Sugar Free Red Bull Can

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
Photo credit: facebook
+52 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+51 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

It's becoming a favorite of mine despite its preferance to Philly teams (so they can brag a little) . Different folks of different strokes come thru resulting in good times and plesant atmosphere .
I am a daytimer for afternoon events . Nice menu with cheesesteaks on top .
September 2025
This restaurant had fantastic service I was just underwhelmed by the cheesesteak. It felt like it was missing something that I get in Philly. The interior of the restaurant was also super cute!
July 2025
Cheesesteaks are super good. They also have a really good lunch happy hour special that comes with cheesesteak fries a beer and a shot really good deal. Good service to bartender was nice. We also ordered again for the second time from here to go and it was also just as good hard to find good cheese sticks here. I say this is as good as anywhere else you could findin Philly or anywhere else. They are definitely legit I recommend.
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cloves Indian Cuisine - 66 Madison Ave Store B
Indian
Chez Francis - 411 Park Ave S
French, Brasseries
Rocco Steakhouse - 72 Madison Ave
Steak House, American, Seafood, Vegetarian

Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew

66 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
(929) 281-3222