Our waiter (Gabriel) was so nice. Foods were so good. Definitely place to visit if you are in NYC
Naho
Great food and excellent wine! Nicholas is a wonderful and attentive waiter! We recommend highly.
Alina
The waiter was too rude, showed annoyance when I asked for recommendations, tossed my credit card instead of giving it back to me, etc. And the food portion was too small compared to the price. I ordered a fettuccine alfredo with truffle slices which was $56, but I could not even smell or taste the truffles. I specifically put in the note section that we rsvpd to celebrate a birthday and they forgot about it. Would not recommend.
isidro
Food is really average. Not worth the price-point at all. Service was great, ambiance great, but wouldn't recommend eating here compared to other italian restaurants in the area.
Ellen
Everything was amazing from start to finish! They made my birthday celebration so special!
Opentable Diner
Had Spaghetti Carbonara. Pasta was handmade and in the traditional style (egg yolk on top). Try it, it's great. Paired with Lallier champagne. Great ambiance and decor.
Nomy
Druk, enorm klein en gehaast. Eten was niet speciaal lekker of goed. Gezellig kader maar gezelligheid was er niet
Milica
I was celebrating my birthday at Olio e Più, and our server Jose made the evening truly special! He was so friendly, attentive, and gave amazing recommendations — especially the truffle pasta, which was absolutely incredible. Everything he suggested was perfect. Thank you, Jose!
Courtney
We had a wonderful experience at Olio e Più! The food was absolutely delicious. We ordered the insulate do spinac, tartufata pizza, spaghetti alla carbonara and for dessert the panda cotta Al pistachio. Nicholas, our server, was fantastic. He was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect. He went above and beyond to make our celebratory dinner feel extra special. Highly recommend!
Kiersten
Cesar was an awesome waiter. Knowledgeable on the menu, friendly, and happy to celebrate a birthday. Thanks Cesar for the great experience. -Karen
Overall loved this place! Have been wanting to go for a while now. I got the spaghetti carbonara and it did not disappoint. The service was great as well! The environment was lively even for a 9:00PM reservation. Would definitely come back again!
Hannah
Food was delicious (we ordered the gnocchi and carbonara) and service was excellent! Our waiter noticed we were cold and brought us blankets, which was highly appreciated!
Meredith
Caesar was wonderful! The carbonara was outstanding... creamy goodness. The mushroom tagliatelle was also divine. We will be back to see Caesar again.
annie malouf
Gokce was amazing, super attentive and kind!! Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ally Hall
Loved the vibes here !! We had the most amazing waitress named Gokce who was so great. All of the pasta tasted freshly made and definitely will be back!
Our waiter (Gabriel) was so nice. Foods were so good. Definitely place to visit if you are in NYC
Great food and excellent wine! Nicholas is a wonderful and attentive waiter! We recommend highly.
The waiter was too rude, showed annoyance when I asked for recommendations, tossed my credit card instead of giving it back to me, etc. And the food portion was too small compared to the price. I ordered a fettuccine alfredo with truffle slices which was $56, but I could not even smell or taste the truffles. I specifically put in the note section that we rsvpd to celebrate a birthday and they forgot about it. Would not recommend.
Food is really average. Not worth the price-point at all. Service was great, ambiance great, but wouldn't recommend eating here compared to other italian restaurants in the area.
Everything was amazing from start to finish! They made my birthday celebration so special!
Had Spaghetti Carbonara. Pasta was handmade and in the traditional style (egg yolk on top). Try it, it's great. Paired with Lallier champagne. Great ambiance and decor.
Druk, enorm klein en gehaast. Eten was niet speciaal lekker of goed. Gezellig kader maar gezelligheid was er niet
I was celebrating my birthday at Olio e Più, and our server Jose made the evening truly special! He was so friendly, attentive, and gave amazing recommendations — especially the truffle pasta, which was absolutely incredible. Everything he suggested was perfect. Thank you, Jose!
We had a wonderful experience at Olio e Più! The food was absolutely delicious. We ordered the insulate do spinac, tartufata pizza, spaghetti alla carbonara and for dessert the panda cotta Al pistachio. Nicholas, our server, was fantastic. He was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect. He went above and beyond to make our celebratory dinner feel extra special. Highly recommend!
Cesar was an awesome waiter. Knowledgeable on the menu, friendly, and happy to celebrate a birthday. Thanks Cesar for the great experience. -Karen
Restaurantji Recommends
Overall loved this place! Have been wanting to go for a while now. I got the spaghetti carbonara and it did not disappoint. The service was great as well! The environment was lively even for a 9:00PM reservation. Would definitely come back again!
Food was delicious (we ordered the gnocchi and carbonara) and service was excellent! Our waiter noticed we were cold and brought us blankets, which was highly appreciated!
Caesar was wonderful! The carbonara was outstanding... creamy goodness. The mushroom tagliatelle was also divine. We will be back to see Caesar again.
Gokce was amazing, super attentive and kind!! Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the vibes here !! We had the most amazing waitress named Gokce who was so great. All of the pasta tasted freshly made and definitely will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...