One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St, New York
(212) 255-8649

Recent Reviews

Liza Shakhova

This place has a unique romantic atmosphere. It was a pleasure to spend an evening there

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

M M

Shocking how you respond to your low reviews. As if the reviews are fake or the reviewer is at fault. Why would the reviews be fake? Who wants to hurt your business that much? The fact is OBLTBS is a has been. Top chefs and restauranteurs do not remain open for 40 years. This was bought out at some point and running on a previous reputation.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brian Rinaldi

Perfect place for a romantic date night. Every course in the prix fixe menu was delicious. The servers were extremely attentive and gracious. This really was a perfect dinner experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Soufflé with Vanilla Ice Cream

Bri Chang

Went here for a birthday dinner, hoping for a lovely evening. Instead, we were seated next to two influencers with a massive ring light that kept flashing in our eyes the entire time. If the restaurant agreed to their use of such disruptive lighting, then they should not have placed us right next to them, especially given the abundance of open tables elsewhere. My displeasure was evident, and in an attempt to make amends, the manager offered us two glasses of wine. Sadly, the constant flashing light overshadowed what should have been a joyous birthday meal. It was a disappointing experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Ellen Veden

A favorite, great place to have a holiday dinner romantic candlelight , great food and service?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Raisza Latif

Such an amazing date night experience!!! So romantic! ❤️?? Nick and Staka were amazing and so thoughtful!!! They me and my husbands night. Thank you to both of them!!! The food was *chefs kiss*! Definitely recommended and will come back again!Dietary restrictions: Gluten and dairy free

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sorbet, Individual Beef Wellington, Wine Pairing

Peta W.

I had a birthday dinner here. I went for the four course prix fixe menu. It was amazing. Each mean was beautifully created, plated and paired. The ambiance was swanky, luxe, but also a rustic vibe. I say next to a window with a garden view. The restaurant was beautifully decorated with a colossal Christmas tree and ribbons along the stairs. The service was tip top, timely and I found our server yo be attentive and courteous. I was pleasantly pleased. And they cherry on top was a daintily decorated dessert platter. Can't wait to go again!

Emilio Beckett

are the regulars coming out Oneif by land two if by

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Iddrisu Adjei

Most beautiful and quiet place with quality

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Rabito

Absolutely love this

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Individual Beef Wellington

Brian C.

Went there last night to celebrate my wife's birthday. My wife, our son and myself could not have been happier. When we checked in, the hosts immediately said Happy Birthday to her. We each had the prixe fixed meals. We also added a special of oysters. Outstanding. The service was great. Our waiter Ousane D and the rest of the staff were great. The evening could not have been better. Highly recommend going. The history, the decor wonderful. We had octopus, froi gras, lobster risotto, scallops, beef Wellington, steak au poivre, chocolate soufle and crème brute. They even had a special dessert for my wife. Amazing.

sal t.

My third time here. It was an excellent restaurant. Unfortunately not anymore. I called twice to let them know it was my wife's birthday and to put a candle on her dessert. They forgot. There was a fight in the restaurant where a customer and the sommelier threw punches at each other. The customer was taken away by ambulance. This whole situation ruined our dinner. On a $500 bill they offered to take off a $15 drink. Sorry but the experience was terrible. When I told the maitre d how upset I was they forgot my wife's birthday he looked at me like I was speaking a foreign language.

John Brigaudit

I was searching in the web the best place to propose to my gf. This is the place that showed up and I had search other places as well but this place was the one that I kept going back too. I had inquire early in the morning while I was at work and within a couple hours they got back to me and explain what kind of service they can provide. I am glad that we went here. Food was amazing, staff is very attentive and the ambiance of the place was just perfect. 10/10 would recommend. I would go back here in the future.PS. she said yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was not as reputable as I expected to be. We end it up with receiving 5 times of services, which is not including pouring water and wine and the server is “accidentally” avoiding eye contacts with me when I needed services. We have to wait for 15+ mins for them to come and collect our plates after we finished the meal and moving forward to the next course. I don't know why I was pretty interested in take a solid experience here but what I'm actually getting is me and my wife in this stunning atmosphere with flowers and candles but in a tiny table while suffering with our finished plates and self- pouring drinks. I hope that is helpful.

GL

They do a good job with their signature dishes and consistent in the delivery. It’s not the best food you will have but good for what it is (first date, milestone celebrations etc) but by no means a high end gourmet restaurant. Service is courteous and prompt, the wait staff always have an opinion and good recommendations for you. Everyone says it is romantic but I don’t really feel that vibe although the interior is very nice it can get too loud for conversations. They have a nice bar area and a piano near the entrance.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Individual Beef Wellington, Seared Hudson Valley Foie Gras

Load More

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014
(212) 255-8649