Osteria Cotta
513 Columbus Ave, New York
(212) 873-8500
Customers' Favorites
Farmhouse Lasagne with Beef Bolognese Ragu
Wood Fired Rosemary Wings
Banana Bread Pudding
Buon Giorno Pizza
Amatriciana Pizza
Unlimited Mimomas
Chicken Milanese
Burrata for Four
Margherita Pizza
Fried Calamari
Menu
Photos
+49 photos
+48 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Stopped in for a drink and to try out the red sauce at Cotta. We love that the portions are reasonable here and they have small plates as well. We had an excellent IPA from Vermont and a mule. Then shared a bowl of the best bolongese with fresh ricotta. Amazing red sauce here.
Osteria Cotta has the most delicious food, the loveliest atmosphere, and the greatest service! I had the best experience here, I came for Sunday brunch while on the Upper West Side near Central Park West & I will absolutely plan to return in the future. They also have a great wine list and their sangria is excellent as well. Highly recommend!
UPDATE (6/18/2025): I’ve been back to Osteria Cotta several times since I wrote my initial review, and this place...
UPDATE (6/18/2025): I’ve been back to Osteria Cotta several times since I wrote my initial review, and this place...
Great meal sitting outside on the weekend. The Pomodoro and vodka sauces were so good on our pasta. The pizza was excellent, Neapolitan style, wouldn’t have been surprised if it was from the five star boutique pizzeria across the street!
You May Also Like
The Viand - 517 Columbus Ave
![]()
Diner, American, Mediterranean, New American, Vegan
Tasca NYC - 505 Columbus Ave
![]()
Spanish, Caribbean, Vegan, Latin American
Prohibition - 503 Columbus Ave
![]()
Bar, American, Music Venues, New American