I was killing time in the city before my flight later that day. This was the 4th spot I visited and I decided to post up for the remainder of my visit. Very chill vibe and the bartender, Lucas, was awesome. Thanks for helping me kill some time! Will definitely stop in on the next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jane hutchins
Found this place by accident when we got lost looking for The Edge. We had a Short rib cottage pie, Dangerous Dave's Dublin Dip and the Nachos, they were all very good. We went back a second time because we like it so much. A shout out to Lucas the bar man, who was very efficient and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Hall
The manager is rude and this place has horrible hospitality. I came on a whim and the hostess was not friendly or welcoming. I wanted to grab drinks and bites and was told I had to order dinner food and figure out if I was before I was seated. I was hungry but didn’t feel welcome being required to know what I was eating before sitting down. It was also so crowded at the bar and the tables were open and tons of reservations available for sit down. They make more money off drinks than food why would any real manager in hospitality require this. We did end up ordering food but I felt so unwelcome.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Linda Fung
My party and I came here after a trade show. To be honest, we didn't have the highest expectations and being a NY'er, I don't like being impressed. We were blown away. The restaurant was very accommodating, even though I changed our party size last minute. The food was delicious, far better than what I had expected. The service was impeccable, even though they were clearly very busy as it was a football play-off night and a trade show had just ended. The front desk hostess, the waitress, the people who cleared dishes, and the manager Manny, were all wonderful. They made us feel welcomed and made our night very enjoyable. I recommend this place highly and will definitely be here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie
Eduardo Arjona
Irish pub style food with a variety of beers and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TomK
Was looking for a nice place to catch up with my brother rising from DC. Wanted a nice environment with good food but as he was treating did not want it to be too expensive. O'Toole's Way checked all the boxes. We had a lovely evening at O'Toole's Way!
Giulia Daly
Place was very clean and modern. Our waiter was super nice. The food came out fast, good portion sizes. Wasn’t expecting the bar pie to be good but it was my fav. Def
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Pizza
Robert Ambriano
Great experience, amazing food and really good bar. I would definitely recommend if your in the Hudson Yards area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
TK719
I had been looking forward to trying O'Toole's since it opened, and am so glad that I finally did. The space is simply beautiful. The potato and leek soup and squash ravioli were both delicious, and the brown butter chocolate chip cookie skillet was just divine. My servers Riley and Jesus were both amazing, and took exceptional care of me. It's a bit out of the way - but definitely worth seeking out.
Lauren Grote
Great experience & location in Hudson Yards! Our party of 5 visited on a Sunday evening & were greeted & seated immediately. Our server was very friendly, knowledgeable & attentive. We ordered the salmon, baked oysters, high line salad, burger & run rebellion. Everything was delicious! Food was served in average portions & was average-priced. They brought out a complimentary dessert with a candle for my daughter's birthday, which was much appreciated. All of the staff provided excellent customer service & attentiveness. Would definitely return!
People seem to love the food here but I found it average. Potato leek soup was ok. Chicken sandwich fair but the slaw was over seasoned. Salad was good. The space is very lovely both inside and outside. I recommend sitting outside on a nice day. It's quiet and secluded and charming. Servers were helpful. Bar was very nice with very attentive bartenders. I'll definitely give it another chance.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Stephanie S.
Great drinks and outdoor seating. This was our resting spot after walking the High Line. Could have spent longer if we didn't have more exploring to do.
Crista C.
Be careful when you split the check because the tip that they put on the split check is for the full amount. Quite deceptive.
Jean-Marie Maio
Great service, staff very welcoming.Drinks were great, waffles and chix very good.Fantastic salad with a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maryla Soma
Loved our experience hereCarb cutting ...they were more than happy to accommodate and had awesome options!!!!
I was killing time in the city before my flight later that day. This was the 4th spot I visited and I decided to post up for the remainder of my visit. Very chill vibe and the bartender, Lucas, was awesome. Thanks for helping me kill some time! Will definitely stop in on the next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Found this place by accident when we got lost looking for The Edge. We had a Short rib cottage pie, Dangerous Dave's Dublin Dip and the Nachos, they were all very good. We went back a second time because we like it so much. A shout out to Lucas the bar man, who was very efficient and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The manager is rude and this place has horrible hospitality. I came on a whim and the hostess was not friendly or welcoming. I wanted to grab drinks and bites and was told I had to order dinner food and figure out if I was before I was seated. I was hungry but didn’t feel welcome being required to know what I was eating before sitting down. It was also so crowded at the bar and the tables were open and tons of reservations available for sit down. They make more money off drinks than food why would any real manager in hospitality require this. We did end up ordering food but I felt so unwelcome.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My party and I came here after a trade show. To be honest, we didn't have the highest expectations and being a NY'er, I don't like being impressed. We were blown away. The restaurant was very accommodating, even though I changed our party size last minute. The food was delicious, far better than what I had expected. The service was impeccable, even though they were clearly very busy as it was a football play-off night and a trade show had just ended. The front desk hostess, the waitress, the people who cleared dishes, and the manager Manny, were all wonderful. They made us feel welcomed and made our night very enjoyable. I recommend this place highly and will definitely be here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie
Irish pub style food with a variety of beers and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was looking for a nice place to catch up with my brother rising from DC. Wanted a nice environment with good food but as he was treating did not want it to be too expensive. O'Toole's Way checked all the boxes. We had a lovely evening at O'Toole's Way!
Place was very clean and modern. Our waiter was super nice. The food came out fast, good portion sizes. Wasn’t expecting the bar pie to be good but it was my fav. Def
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Pizza
Great experience, amazing food and really good bar. I would definitely recommend if your in the Hudson Yards area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
I had been looking forward to trying O'Toole's since it opened, and am so glad that I finally did. The space is simply beautiful. The potato and leek soup and squash ravioli were both delicious, and the brown butter chocolate chip cookie skillet was just divine. My servers Riley and Jesus were both amazing, and took exceptional care of me. It's a bit out of the way - but definitely worth seeking out.
Great experience & location in Hudson Yards! Our party of 5 visited on a Sunday evening & were greeted & seated immediately. Our server was very friendly, knowledgeable & attentive. We ordered the salmon, baked oysters, high line salad, burger & run rebellion. Everything was delicious! Food was served in average portions & was average-priced. They brought out a complimentary dessert with a candle for my daughter's birthday, which was much appreciated. All of the staff provided excellent customer service & attentiveness. Would definitely return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
People seem to love the food here but I found it average. Potato leek soup was ok. Chicken sandwich fair but the slaw was over seasoned. Salad was good. The space is very lovely both inside and outside. I recommend sitting outside on a nice day. It's quiet and secluded and charming. Servers were helpful. Bar was very nice with very attentive bartenders. I'll definitely give it another chance.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great drinks and outdoor seating. This was our resting spot after walking the High Line. Could have spent longer if we didn't have more exploring to do.
Be careful when you split the check because the tip that they put on the split check is for the full amount. Quite deceptive.
Great service, staff very welcoming.Drinks were great, waffles and chix very good.Fantastic salad with a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved our experience hereCarb cutting ...they were more than happy to accommodate and had awesome options!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5