Penny Jo's

3898 Broadway, New York
(646) 609-2216

Recent Reviews

Sort by
ImBroke Rob

• June 29th 2025 back again and still lovely

So already went back for Father’s Day and yes I enjoy this place will definitely be here a lot

Pro tip ask for Valerie,

although everyone will help you and assist in your service experience and everyone is amazing she recommended an amazing drink for me. She recommended the sazerac!!! Never heard of this before but it was nothing short of spectacular.

I truly enjoyed my experience here from the staff the customers to the food to the vibe to the music to the energy in the room. This place checks all the spots a small local hidden gem 💎 I hope it blows up but doesn’t at the same time. The decor was great when u see wu tang signs you know you in the right place.

Another pro tip get the meat and cheese board you will not be disappointed I promise this was hands one of the best I’ve had and I’ve had a lot 😂 I was truly impressed. I’ll be definitely making this place a spot I visit often I will be here atleast once a month. I will continue to update with what to eat and what to order and drink.

Another pro tip never say I didn’t put you on.

They have Brugal 1888 it’s one of the best rums you will ever have trust me!!!!

I hope you enjoyed this review if you come please tell me what you think and what you had.

Like always thanks for the support the likes and follows I truly appreciate it.

Also follow me on IG @imbroke_eats and @imbroke_rob

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Arantxa Sánchez

Nice place to drink and there are cheap beer options, but also whiskey variety.The Ambient is calm with the music not being to loud so you can have conversations without screaming.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

XAVIER MARTINEZ

Amazing staff

Frank Alonso

Free Jazz/Blues pickup on Wednesday. Drinks are priced accordingly. Staff is awesome.

Nick Clifford

Absolutely peak vibes. Great service from the bartenders, but they also don't mind if you're just chilling on your phone. So glad I popped in during my visit.

Allysa Saggese

Super cute, drinks are good and live jazz we saw tonight was fantastic. We will be back

Brad Klipner

Great corner bar. Seth gets an A+ from this out-of-towner. Super friendly.

Salem Jenkins

we had the dirty martini and the chai martini and they were absolutely to die for! will be back. prices were great and servers were attentive without being overbearing. had a lovely experience and will be returning!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicolás Rojas

Where walking around. Live jazz music, nice waitress, great vibe, affordable.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Sparthy X

An impressive gem in Upper Manhattan sorely needed. A healthy number of music events happen here and the interior is warm and inviting.

A modern take on the neighborhood bar.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Marjorie Korn

Easily the best bar in Upper Manhattan. Great cocktails, thoughtful food menu, music is FIRE, bartenders create an amazing atmosphere. Have had my past two birthdays here, plan to make it a third.

Vegetarian options: They’re great about having veg and vegan options on the menu. (Some veg things can be made vegan.)

Dietary restrictions: Their spirit-free drink game is strong if you feel like imbibing without alcohol.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Liquor Shelve, Malbec, Fig & Goat Cheese, Soup of the Day, Meat and Cheese

Colin Rink

Favorite bar in the neighborhood. Great staff & friendly staff that make you feel at home plus they make some excellent cocktails too. Food is pretty on point too. And great music almost every night of the week.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Sandra Schatten

Service was good and friendly different drink options

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jose Miguel Bello Valera

Aplace to escape from a sordid city.Nice and friendly staff, great cocktails. With friends or alone, you will enjoy it anyway.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charis Brakatselos

Fantastic bar in washington heigthts. Very good in every aspect. Warm and vibrant atmosphere. In my top5 for NYC.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pinot Grigio

Loading...