Pepo’s Pizza

1522 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(917) 261-6476

Recent Reviews

Vinay Raghavan

Real nice folks and food

Chastity Machado

Please save your money & order somewhere else. My coworkers & I placed an order with multiple items each including chicken. I am unsure how they wash or where they get their chicken from because the chicken smelled so bad not just one order but the whole entire order. We wanted to give the benefit of the doubt & try the chicken tenders they were burnt & gross. She took a bite and immediately felt sick. We saw the pictures on google of the food & wanted to try..BIG REGRET!!We reached out to the pizzeria to address the matter in a civil way & to warn them about the chicken because it was under cooked & that smell was not normal which can make other customers sick. The two people we spoke with were rude, not helpful said the chicken is always fresh which was not the case. We would not lie. We just wanted to have a good lunch instead we had to dispose of it because it was smelling up the place & order from another spot. Pepo needs to give his staff a training on customer service it was our first time ordering & it will be our last. They need to reevaluate their definition of “FRESH”because this chicken looks dry & spoiled The health department should take a trip to this location. I wish I could give this place a negative star.. DO NOT BE FOOLED BY THE PICTURES ON THE MENU! This place is disgusting ?… we only took a picture of the wings & couldn’t even open the other set because of the smell. YUCK

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jennifer Aguilar

Customer service was horrible and so was the food. I got food poisoning. Find somewhere else to eat.

Lizzette Beltran

So today we ordered lunch for our clinic and it was an epic fails. The chicken tenders were burnt and the Buffalo wings were old and smelly and very undercooked, the tried to madk it with a whole lot of hot sauce but the smell of bad chicken came right through. We called the restaurant back and got alit if attitude and run around, they didn't even try to accommodate us in any way. Please be aware when ordering from this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andrea Donaldson

Very mandible and make your ? pizza just right the way you like to eat it crunchy hot tasty very good please don't

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Haqieqat Jawando

Their pizza is very well made, but I wish they had more drink options. I enjoy coming there after a long day. Being by a school, it tends to get busy often, yet the quality is always top-notch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pan Pizza

Gina M

Love their pizza! Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pan Pizza

Nelson Ureña

Great slices and even better customer

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Caleb

Nice small pizza joint. It seems to be a family run business with some good people working there. The pizza tastes good too and for a fair price. I enjoy the 2 slice and coke deal or sometimes I will get a whole pie. A nice addition to the neighborhood, I can't think of anywhere else that I would grab some pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Soda

Omnia Abuzeid

Best tasting pizza I've ever eaten ,, very good quality ♥️♥️

Sam DeLuca

Really good pizza, my go-to spot for a quick bite. Nice guys too

Anjali Vishwanath

Solid place for a slice. Wish it were open later!

Toeka Harvin

Pizza is great and comes with great service. Little spot but I love coming here

Rose S.

Very good pizza. It's hard to find a good pizza in Manhattan especially upper Manhattan (Harlem).

Sahib Mostafa

A great pizza place, very friendly service and delicious perfect size slices.

Load More