Pick A Bagel
251 Vesey St, New York
(212) 786-9200
Customers' Favorites
Bacon Egg and Cheese on Rainbow Bagel
Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese
Smoked Fish and Appetizers
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
Served on your choice on bagel.
Nova Scotia Salmon by the pound.
Nova Scotia Delux Sandwich
Fresh sliced Nova, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onions,capers and avocado.served on choice of bagel.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of Bagel Or Bread
Nova Scotia Salmon Platter
Fresh slice hand nova scotial served with lettuce tomatoesCucumber red onion with plain cream chhese on side.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of bagel Or Bread.
Low Fat Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of bagel Or Bread.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of Bagel Or Bread.
Egg Salad Platter
Home egg salad served with lettuce tomatoes cucumber. redonion& your choice of bagel.
Whitefish Salad Platter
Homemade white fish salad served with lettuce tomatoes Cucumberred onion & your choice of bagel.
Low Fat Chicken Salad Sandwich
Served On your Choice Of Bagel or Bread.
Chicken Salad Platter
Home chicken salad served lettuce tomatoes cucumber red onin.&your choice of bagel.
Low Fat Tuna Salad Platter
Homemade albocore low fat tuna saled served with lettucetomatoes cucumber red onion & your choice of bagel.
Low Fat Chicken Salad Platter
Home made low fat chicken salad lettuce tomatoes cucumber redonin & your choice of bagel.
Tuna Salad Platter
Home made albacore tuna salad served with lettuce tomatoesCucumber red onion & your choice of bagel.
Baked Salmon Salad Platter
Homemade baked salmon salad served with lettuce tomatoesCucumber red onion & your choice of bagel.
Hot Breakfast Sandwiches & Omelettes
Bacon Egg and Cheese Sadwich
Tow Eggs Three Strips of Pork Bacon American Cheese Served Onyour Choice Bagel or bread.
Sausage Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Tow Eggs One Pork Sausage Patty American Cheese Served on yourChoice Bagel Or bread.
Egg sandwich.
Served Two Eggs Any Style On Your Choice Bagel Or Bread.
Egg Cheese Sandwich.
Tow Eggs and american Cheese Served on you Choice Bagel Orbread.
Creat Your Own Omelette Platter
Served with Three Eggs Four Topping Home fries and bagel withbutter.
B.L.T Sandwich
Bacon Lettuce Tomatoes.Mayo. Served On Your Choice.Bagel orBread.
Turkey bacon egg cheese sandwich.
Tow scrambled eggs 3 strips of turke baon american cheeseServed on yuor choice of bagel or bread.
Ham egg Cheese Sandwich
Tow Scrambled Eggs American Cheese. Served On Your Choice ofBagel Or Bread.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Creat Your Own Breakfast Platter
Served Tow Eggs With Home fries and Bagel with Butter.
Western Omelette Platter
Served With 3 Eggs Ham Bell Pepper.Onions. Home fries.and Bagelwith Butter.
Turkey Bacon Sandwich
Served on your Choice Bagel or bread.
BLT Sandwich Delux
Bacon Lettuce Tomato melted american cheese and avocadochipotle mayo served on your choice bread or bagel
Bacon Sandwich
served on your Choice Bagel Or Bread.
Veggie Omelette Platter
Served With 3 Eggs Mushroom Bell pepper onios. Home fries andBagel with Butter.
New Yorker Omelette Platter
Eggs smoked salmon Bermuda Onions Served WITH Homefries andBagel with Butter.
Spanish Omelette Platter
Onions, bell peppers and tomatoes. Served With Homefries.Andbagel.With butter.
Cream Cheese and Spread Sandwiches
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on yuor choice of bagel.
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Bagel with butter
Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Lox Spread sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Jalapeno Asiago Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Strawberry Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Low Fat Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Butter and Jelly Sandwich
Low fat Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich.
Served On your Choice of Bagel.
Walnut and Raisin Cream Chese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Low fat Veggie Cream Cheese Sandwich.
Served on Your Choice of bagel.
Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Low Fat Lox Spread Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Salamon Delight Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice of bagel.
Peanut Butter Sandwich.
Served on your choice of bagel.
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
Served on your choice ofbagel.
Coffee Bar and Iced Coffee
Iced Coffee
Large Coffee
Small Coffee
Espresso over Ice.
Two shots of Espresso over ice.
Hot Cocoa
Espresso shot
Large Hot Tea
Box of Coffee
Muffins, Pastries and Hand Rolled Bagels
Bagel
New York Bakers Dozen Bagels
Fouteen To a Dozen Please Specify In Special box If You WouldLike More than one of Any Kind. All Our Bagels are Rolled ByHand And Baked Everyday. And With Prepared with High QualityIngredients.
Jumbo Cookies
Choose your cookies.
Coffee Crumb Cake
Almond Croissant
Apple Turn Over
Cheese Danish
Croissant
Chocolate Croissant
Breakfast Wraps
Breakfast Burrito Wrap
Egg, bacon, american cheese and home fries. Served on wholewheat wrap.
The Healthy Wrap
Egg white, spinach, mushrooms, avocado and Swiss cheese. onwhole wheat wrap.
California Omelette Wrap
Eggs avocado scallion tomato pepper jack cheese served on wholewheat wrap.
Rachero Wrap
Eggs ham bell pepper onion tomato cheddar cheese Served onwhole wheat wrap.
Mexican Style Wrap
Eggs fresh hot pepper tomato onion pepper jack cheese Avocadoserved on whole wheat wrap.
Salad Spread Sandwiches.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of Bagel Or Bread
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of bagel Or Bread.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Served On your Choice Of Bagel Or Bread.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of Bagel Or Bread.
Low Fat Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served On Your Choice Of bagel Or Bread.
Low Fat Chicken Salad Sandwich
Served On your Choice Of Bagel or Bread.
Extras and Sides
Bag Of Chips
Slice Tomatoes Order.
Side Sour Pickle
Side of saliced Onions
Side Capers
Side--Cucumber
Side Veggies Platter
Served With Lettuce Tomatoes Cucumber Red onios
Lunch.Sandwich And Wraps.
Turkey Club Sandwich
Classic New York. Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, romainelettuce, tomatoes and light mayo. Recommended on CiabattaBread.
Breaded Chicken Wrap.
Breaded Chicken Melted Swiss Cheese Lettuce Tomatoes AvocadoHoney Dijon Served On Whole Wheat Wrap.
Grilled Chic Club Sandwich
Grilled chicken bacon Romain lettuce Tomatoes. Moyonnaise.ontoasted ciabatta bread.
Pastrami Sandwich
Beverages
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Gatorade
Can of Soda
Poland Spring Water
Snapple
Tropicana
Nesquick Chocolate
Cream Cheese and Spreads By The Pound
Plain Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Lox Spread
Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese
Low Fat Cream Cheese
Butter
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Olive Cream Cheese
Jalapeno Asiago Cream Cheese
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese
Low Fat Lox Spread
Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese
Salmon Delight Cream Cheese.
Grape Jelly
Peanut Butter
Tofu Cream Cheese
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese
Salad Spreads By The Pound
Tuna Salad
Egg Salad
Chicken Salad
Whitefish Salad
Low Fat Tuna Salad
Boar's Head Sandwich Cold Cut Sandwiches
Turkey Breast Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
B.L.T Sandwich
Bacon Lettuce Tomatoes.Mayo. Served On Your Choice.Bagel orBread.
Pastrami Sandwich
Sesaame Chicken Sandwich
Ham Sandwich
Boar's Head Meat by the Pound
American Cheese
Pastrami
Booar's Head Ham.
Swiss Cheese
Cheddar Cheese
Pepper Jack Cheese
Catering Menu
Bottled Water (Per Person)
Coffee Service
Coffe Box 96 oz 'La Colombe' serve 10-12 pplIncludes complementary 12 oz cups,sugar and stirrers,whole milk, half and half and skim milk
Healthy Start
Minimum 6Fresh Fruit Salad and Berries, Low-Fat Granola and Non-FatYogurt, Accompanied with Our Homemade Muffins.
Smoked Norwegian Salmon Breakfast Platter
Minimum 6Hand Sliced Norwegian Salmon, Beautifully Garnished withAssorted Whipped Cream Cheeses, Bermuda Onion, Tomatoes andCapers. Served with an Array of Bagels.
Executive Breakfast
Minimum 6Continental Breakfast Platter, Accompanied with a BeautifulArray of Fresh Sliced Seasonal Fruit and Berries. Coffee andOrange Juice.
Scoop Platter -Minimum 6
A Vibrant Array of Salads Beautifully Garnished in a Garden ofFresh Vegetables and Served with Our Hand Rolled Bagels andGourmet Breads.Your choice of Salad Spread (Tuna,Egg,White Fish and Chicken)
Breakfast Sandwich - Minimum 6
Includes 2 Eggs per Sandwich, Cheese and Meat BreakfastSandwich on Your Choice of Bread.
Sliced Fruit Platter Minimum 6
Fresh sliced seasonal fruit and berries.
Assorted Cans of Soda (Per Person)
Sweet Bakery Basket -Minimum 6
A Scrumptious Selection of Brownies, Crumb Cakes and HomemadeCookies.
New York Cuts -Minimum 6
A Hearty Array of Fresh Thinly Sliced Cold Cuts, HandsomelyGarnished and Served with a Variety of Our Gourmet Breads, HandRolls, Bagels and/ or Rolls. Served with Coleslaw, Macaroni andPotato Salad. Accompanied by Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers,Onions and Pickle Spears.
Filled Green Salad -Minimum 6
Colorful Mix of Greens, Grape Tomato Halves and BalsamicVinaigrette.
Chicken Caesar Salad -Minimum 6
Hearts of Romaine with Garlic Croutons, Shaved ParmigianaReggiano Cheese and Grilled or Breaded Chicken
Continental Breakfast
Minimum 6 ppl. Price per personAn Arrangement of Our Freshly Baked Danish,Crossiants, Muffins and Hand-Rolled Bagels. Servedwith an Assortment of Flavored Cream Cheeses, WhippedButter and Fruit Preserves.
Continental Breakfast with Fresh Orange Juice
Minimum 6An Arrangement of Our Freshly Baked Danish,Crossiants, Muffins, and Hand-Rolled Bagels. Servedwith an Assortment of Flavored Cream Cheeses, WhippedButter and Fruit Preserves.
New York Smoked Fish Platter -Minimum 6
Hand Sliced Norwegian Salmon Beautiful Garnished with AssortedWhipped Cream Cheeses, Cucumbers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Capers andSweet Bermuda Onions and Array of Our Own Hand Rolled Bagels.
Continental Breakfast with Fruit
Minimum 6An Arrangement of Our Freshly Baked Danish,Crossiants, Muffins and Hand-Rolled Bagels. Servedwith an Assortment of Flavored Cream Cheeses, Whipped Butterand Fruit Preserves.
Continental Breakfast with Coffee Service
Minimum 6An Arrangement of Our Freshly Baked Danish,Crossiants, Muffins, and Hand-Rolled Bagels, Servedwith an Assortment of Flavored Cream Cheeses, Whipped Butterand Fruit Preserves.
Caesar Salad -Minimum 6
Hearts of Romaine with Garlic Croutons and Shaved ParmigianaReggiano Cheese.
Cheese and Crackers Platter -Mknimum 6
Your choice of domestic cheese.
Cheese and Sliced Fruit Platter -Minimum 6
Imported and Domestic Semi-Soft and Hard Cheeses Arrangedwith Seasonal Fruit and Berries, Flat Breads and Crackers.
Crudites and Cheese -Minimum 6
Accompanied with Flat Bread and Crackers.
Crudites with Low-Fat Dip -Minimum 6
A Famer's Market of the Freshest and Most Appealing CrunchyVegetables Cut to Finger Food Size. Served with OurSpecial Dip.
Sandwich Platter -Minimum 6
Choiceof Mix Green Salad or Fresh Sliced Tomato, Red Onions,Cucumbers and Lettuce.
Lunch Box -Minimum 6
Choose Any Sandwich to be Packed in a Box for Your Convenience.With a Bag of Potato Chips, or a Side Dish (Coleslaw, PotatoSalad or Macaroni Salad), Fruit (Banana, Apple or Orange) and aCan of Soda.
Sweet Bakery and Fruit Basket -Minimum 6
A Scrumptious Selection of Brownies, Crumb Cakes and HomemadeCookies, and Sliced Seasonal Fruit.
Fresh Juice (Per Person)
minimum 6(per catering only)
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Daniel Pinkwater said “Bagels can be an enormous power for good or for evil”. Hmm. Well the jury is out at Pick A Bagel. The Everything Bagel was fresh and everything it should have been says my sister. I got a Plain Bagel and it was slightly stale. But it was 4th of July weekend and I don’t think fresh bagels were on their minds. The Diet Cokes (in cans) were atrocious. Just waaaaay off,but that the Coca Cola CO’s fault not Pick a Bagel’s…but it added to the “No...
July 2025
you can meet New york stereo type bagels, bagel sandwiches. bagels dont have a specific taste. mainly savory and light . sandwiches are full of chicken, bacon, and vegetables others. lentils soup was also light(doesnt have any other taste)
in the morning, many people to go to work places come to have breakfast
in the morning, many people to go to work places come to have breakfast
June 2025
$6 for a bagel with cream cheese. Bagel was nothing special Tasteless wound up throwing out the last few bites bc I got bored of chewing it. I know the area is pricey. So I’ll leave this place to the tourists. Only stopped here bc it was between the Fast Ferry and my job. Girl at the counter was very nice though.
June 2025
You May Also Like
El Vez and Burrito Bar - 259 Vesey St
![]()
Mexican, Salad, Vegan
Del Frisco's Grille - 250 Vesey St
![]()
Steak House, Salad, Chicken Wings, Vegan
Wei West - 235 Murray Street
![]()
Asian Fusion, Japanese, Chinese, Gluten-Free, Asian