Ordered online for pick up still had to wait for my order, came to work and found out they gave me wrong danish and bagel just horrible. On top of that not sure how tip got charged ??♂️ ordered 1 chocolate danish n 1 cheese danish, chocolate one was replaced by cream bun which I never ordered. Ordered 1 everything bagel n 1 egg everything bagel but both bagels were everything
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Maira Layla Matos
Bagel well served, well filled, very tasty. Serves two people who don't eat much. You have to ask for it to be baked, otherwise it won't be dry. The place has benches to sit on, but no bathroom.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eleonora Carisi
The bagel is good but 21 dollars seems a bit excessive to me. I chose it with cream cheese with olives and salmon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
John Collins
Ordered 4 items:
Two plain bagels toasted with butter - both came plain, untoasted, no butter.
A combo with two pancakes, sausage, bacon and eggs. - They forgot the pancakes.
Two more pancakes with eggs - they forgot the eggs
They put no utensils in the bag. They put no napkins in the bag.
In fairness I had been told these guys were screwups but I ignored it since the other pick a bagel isn't like this. Well it's my turn to warn you, don't go here.
Food: 1
Service: 1
S.H An
It tasted good, but I read that the staff was kind, but the female employee was a little annoyed because I couldn't speak English.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Linda Chan
I was waiting for my food to be prepared and witnessed an interaction between a customer and the 2 ladies working the cash register, that quite frankly was uncalled for. A customer had paid for his food and accidentally left his food on the counter and left the store. The cashier saw it, opened the bag, and brought it to the guys who prepare food and asked who's it was. No one could figure it who the order belonged to. Then, the customer returned asking the cashier about his forgotten bag. The 2 ladies played dumb and said they didn't see any bags left behind. The customer said it was left on the counter just for a few minutes, how could they not notice it? The cashier kept saying they aren't responsible for any bags left behind. They bantered back and forth, I was about to chime in. But then the guy who was preparing food grabs the bag that was given to him by the cashier and hands it to him. The customer then left. This is how the cashiers treat their customers. What a class act. They knew they had the customers food and they played dumb. I will never return to this place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
아밀리인
You can walk from the MET. I had the green onion cream cheese bagel and the cheese was rich and delicious. However, the person taking the order is a bit unfriendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Benz Tran
We stopped by Pick A Bagel in New York on our way to the Met, and I have to say, it was easily one of the best bagels I’ve ever had. We ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese, and it was absolutely perfect.
The bagel had a crunchy outer layer and a soft, chewy inside, and the cream cheese was incredibly fluffy and delicious. Everything about it was just spot on. I’m giving it a straight-up 5 stars. If you’re looking for an amazing bagel experience in NYC, this is the place to go!
Was a regular customer time for a change foods good
Ada Y
Pick A Bagel offers standard texture bagels, but they can prepare your order within minutes, saving you the disappointment of heading to the nearby Starbucks. The bagel egg sandwiches costed $5.61. While there's a small seating area and the sound level is acceptable, there are no restroom facilities available.
Overall, I had a positive experience, mainly due to the quick service they provide.
Fast paced, busy bagel shop. Used to always come here when I worked at the hospital but since then prices have become ridiculous and the cashiers have become more rude. $28 for lox & chive cream cheese on a flat bagel with OJ?! Bagel was over salted and not even as enjoyable to rationalize that outrageous cost. Would not come back, theres plenty of good bagel spots in NYC. Disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Scallion Cream Cheese, Fish, Everything, Pick a Bagel
raul santacruz
I order all the time and always is something people they take orders by phone first they have attitude plus when I order always send me run order no sugar no salt no ketchup,is like you money don’t have a value,please I inform to the manager change this people take the orders I think they don’t like to work there,I don’t recommend this place not good if is a revue lest the one ⭐️ star I give you cero 0️⃣
Michelle Chiasson
Went in to get a quick bite for lunch with my two hungry, hot and tired kids. Service was great and fast. We had soup and sandwiches and everything was delicious. I’d drive back from Toronto to get the chicken noodle soup again.. was some of the best soup I’ve ever had! We will pop in again on our next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gao Fang
Food is good but the Menu was a bit confusing for first timers
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Cédric Duclos
I expected much better, dry bagel, mediocre toppings but the worst part is the welcome! Not at all friendly with tourists, the one at the checkout with a headband on her head was the worst of all! I won't go back there, that's for sure! There are a lot better and nicer things! The New Yorkers are nice, if we don't understand well they explain to us, or speak slowly, nothing! We felt it when they laughed at us.... Horrible with children too ? not patient at all
Ordered online for pick up still had to wait for my order, came to work and found out they gave me wrong danish and bagel just horrible. On top of that not sure how tip got charged ??♂️ ordered 1 chocolate danish n 1 cheese danish, chocolate one was replaced by cream bun which I never ordered. Ordered 1 everything bagel n 1 egg everything bagel but both bagels were everything
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Bagel well served, well filled, very tasty. Serves two people who don't eat much. You have to ask for it to be baked, otherwise it won't be dry. The place has benches to sit on, but no bathroom.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The bagel is good but 21 dollars seems a bit excessive to me. I chose it with cream cheese with olives and salmon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ordered 4 items:
Two plain bagels toasted with butter - both came plain, untoasted, no butter.
A combo with two pancakes, sausage, bacon and eggs. - They forgot the pancakes.
Two more pancakes with eggs - they forgot the eggs
They put no utensils in the bag. They put no napkins in the bag.
In fairness I had been told these guys were screwups but I ignored it since the other pick a bagel isn't like this. Well it's my turn to warn you, don't go here.
Food: 1
Service: 1
It tasted good, but I read that the staff was kind, but the female employee was a little annoyed because I couldn't speak English.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I was waiting for my food to be prepared and witnessed an interaction between a customer and the 2 ladies working the cash register, that quite frankly was uncalled for. A customer had paid for his food and accidentally left his food on the counter and left the store. The cashier saw it, opened the bag, and brought it to the guys who prepare food and asked who's it was. No one could figure it who the order belonged to.
Then, the customer returned asking the cashier about his forgotten bag. The 2 ladies played dumb and said they didn't see any bags left behind. The customer said it was left on the counter just for a few minutes, how could they not notice it? The cashier kept saying they aren't responsible for any bags left behind. They bantered back and forth, I was about to chime in. But then the guy who was preparing food grabs the bag that was given to him by the cashier and hands it to him. The customer then left.
This is how the cashiers treat their customers. What a class act. They knew they had the customers food and they played dumb. I will never return to this place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
You can walk from the MET. I had the green onion cream cheese bagel and the cheese was rich and delicious. However, the person taking the order is a bit unfriendly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
We stopped by Pick A Bagel in New York on our way to the Met, and I have to say, it was easily one of the best bagels I’ve ever had. We ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese, and it was absolutely perfect.
The bagel had a crunchy outer layer and a soft, chewy inside, and the cream cheese was incredibly fluffy and delicious. Everything about it was just spot on. I’m giving it a straight-up 5 stars. If you’re looking for an amazing bagel experience in NYC, this is the place to go!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cream Cheese Spreads, Everything
Was a regular customer time for a change foods good
Pick A Bagel offers standard texture bagels, but they can prepare your order within minutes, saving you the disappointment of heading to the nearby Starbucks. The bagel egg sandwiches costed $5.61. While there's a small seating area and the sound level is acceptable, there are no restroom facilities available.
Overall, I had a positive experience, mainly due to the quick service they provide.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Fast paced, busy bagel shop. Used to always come here when I worked at the hospital but since then prices have become ridiculous and the cashiers have become more rude. $28 for lox & chive cream cheese on a flat bagel with OJ?! Bagel was over salted and not even as enjoyable to rationalize that outrageous cost. Would not come back, theres plenty of good bagel spots in NYC. Disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Scallion Cream Cheese, Fish, Everything, Pick a Bagel
I order all the time and always is something people they take orders by phone first they have attitude plus when I order always send me run order no sugar no salt no ketchup,is like you money don’t have a value,please I inform to the manager change this people take the orders I think they don’t like to work there,I don’t recommend this place not good if is a revue lest the one ⭐️ star I give you cero 0️⃣
Went in to get a quick bite for lunch with my two hungry, hot and tired kids. Service was great and fast. We had soup and sandwiches and everything was delicious. I’d drive back from Toronto to get the chicken noodle soup again.. was some of the best soup I’ve ever had! We will pop in again on our next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is good but the
Menu was a bit confusing for first timers
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I expected much better, dry bagel, mediocre toppings but the worst part is the welcome! Not at all friendly with tourists, the one at the checkout with a headband on her head was the worst of all! I won't go back there, that's for sure! There are a lot better and nicer things! The New Yorkers are nice, if we don't understand well they explain to us, or speak slowly, nothing! We felt it when they laughed at us.... Horrible with children too
? not patient at all
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Loading...