Pick A Bagel

1101 Lexington Ave, New York
(212) 517-6590

Recent Reviews

Sort by
flor orbegoso

Manager so highly rude!!!! I complain but nobody give me info about owner!!! I DO NOT RECOMMEND TO PEOPLE TO GO TO THIS HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!!.

nik nik

Very expensive 8.32 one bagel non toaster with cream cheese

Vladimir Romanovich

The worst bagel in the city, overpriced.
Specifically asked not toasted they still make it toasted. Only two kind of bagels were available. If I could give zero stars I would.

Juan Guzman

Staff very rude and unfriendly. Food overpriced.

Patrick Ronan

Simply outstanding in every aspect of the dining experience!

Elizabeth P

I rarely give bad reviews, however had to share my experiences with this place. The prices were too high, and the staff were rude. I got the wrong panini, and it was cold when I received it. I also ordered a large cappuccino, which was only filled halfway with coffee and leaking. Not returning.

Peter Martin

I wish I could get breakfast here everyday!! They've got a great selection of bagels and spreads. You can also get bacon, eggs cheese sandwich on a bagel, and smashed, a must to eat on the go. Coffee is great too. So close to the subway, makes for grab and go. 10/10 would recommend.

Fnot Gebre

I had the “Greek omelette” platter that just consisted of tomatoes & feta, over a bed of potatoes (which were good). Had I known I would’ve asked them to add some spinach and olives maybe. Doesn’t include any toast but was approx $15. I might give them one more try to try the actual bagels

Jessie Deardorff

They make up random prices but I decided to take it as a fun joke, like we’re friends and you’re kidding with me even though she wasn’t. She just wanted to be somewhere else doing anything else, anywhere but here. Daydreaming. I respect that fully and If you saw me crying after you said $12 - non negotiable for a simple pumpernickel bagel with jelly, it wasn’t cause I’m broke- it was because I also want to be somewhere else doing anything but this

ZROD

Breakfast was sandwich was great and window seating available, unfortunately sea food was placed together with cold cuts which it causes cross contamination bad for those with seafood allergies

Myron Gaskins

I popped into this place after seeing my Dr. at Lennox hospital for a check-up.
I was very impressed with the service
And even more impressed with the tastey bagel I was served. Great visit. I may get sick more often so I can go there after leaving the hospital

Celine Chen

Tried three times.
The bagel is not good at all.
Will not try again.

Izzie D

These were the rudest employees I’ve ever seen at a bagel place. Never going back

Eliza Appezzato

no prices listed…. ordered a bagel with salmon and cream cheese and paid $19 lol

titico hernandez

What an amazing panini do they
I love it

Loading...