Pick A Bagel on 23rd street
210 E 23rd St, New York
(212) 686-1414
Customers' Favorites
Sesame Flat Bagel with Garlic Herb Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel
Smoked Salmon
Flat Bagels
Croissant
Lox
Menu
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I had a doctor's appointment nearby and hadn't had breakfast so I decided to go in and order. Since it was my first time I decided to go for the classic, plain toasted bagel with butter and a cup of black coffee. I paid almost $6 which for me is a little pricey, but given the circumstances, economy and location, it's understandable ( I'm trying to avoid the owner giving me a breakdown of expenses in the review LOL ) just kidding. The bagel was quite large...
Place is fantastic. Previously living next to a Tompkins square bagel for a number of years.
Don’t be afraid to toast the bagel! Normally I would recommend to not toast a fresh bagel, but these bagel stay soft inside even with the toasting. Also, their flat everything best is my favorite.
I recently moved in next door and was hesitant to even go after reading the reviews... I have been half a dozen times in the last two weeks and haven't...
Don’t be afraid to toast the bagel! Normally I would recommend to not toast a fresh bagel, but these bagel stay soft inside even with the toasting. Also, their flat everything best is my favorite.
I recently moved in next door and was hesitant to even go after reading the reviews... I have been half a dozen times in the last two weeks and haven't...
Always love Pick-A-Bagel but I specifically came to this franchise because of the owner’s care in responding to all of his reviews good and bad. I was intrigued. Honestly, on a late Sunday morning it was peaceful with a steady stream of customers. I ordered egg and cheese on an everything for me and the same but gluten free for my wife (they don’t make the GF bagels). Both bagels were great either way. They were ready quickly and the staff was kind and patient. I asked to...
You May Also Like
Que Rico Restaurant - 221 E 23rd St
![]()
Dominican, Spanish
Zhong Jie - 219 E 23rd St
![]()
Chinese
Baked by Luigi - 221 E 23rd St
![]()
Pizza, Italian