The calzones are delicious, and then strangely the pizza is not very good. My husband and I used to order their calzones all the time though when we lived in the neighborhood we loved them so much. Delicious ricotta cheese filling. Just pass on the pizza.
Francia Riesco (Fr4nc3)
I got this order from Grubhub, but they didn't respond to my request and blamed the driver. Terrible service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alex Scarpetta
Excellent pizza at reasonable pricesVery friendly staff
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
John C
The service was really weird. One of the employees kept screaming.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ryan Calish
After waiting over 2 hours I called and asked when it would be delivered. They said it has already left. Another 45 minutes goes by and I call them again to find out they cancelled the order. When I asked what happened they tried to blame me and said I canceled it. Never order from this sad excuse for a business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dom M.
Now I will be honest. The pizza is the best in the UWS. Hands down. However, I noticed the employees are rude to the black customers.
David
Just not a very good pizza. Low quality ingredients. Half the dollar slice places in the city are better than this.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ben
Love the pie pie original
Scott S.
Really good, big NY Pizza. Very nice people. Price seemed fair. Very fast service. I recommend.
Very good NY style pizza. Rated them lower because after I picked up my pies and got home I realized they left the pepperoni off my pepperoni pie. Grrrr
Ken Pesile
Pie Pie Pizza makes a pretty decent pizza but I wouldn't tell visitors to go out of their way to try it. For those that live in the neighborhood, it's not a bad option to have but I don't feel like it offers enough to make it truly standout.The slices are fairly thin, which I do prefer, but the pizza is also really oily. The cheese and sauce both don't really have a standout flavor so everything just kind of tastes like one thing instead of a bunch of complimentary ingredients.Will I go back? Sure. Will it be my go-to pizza place? No.
Food: 4
Kay
Ordered from Uber eats and got what looked like 4 of the stalest, driest pizzas I have ever seen in my life. Literally had one slice had the worse case of food poisoning almost instantly. Never never ever ordering from them again. Alll 4 pizzas went to the trash!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dariel Diaz
*this is your signal to buy*
Cubanitaz CubaMiAmor
THE WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD SINCE I HAVE LIVED IN NYC.I have lived in New York City for more than 25 years and I have never in my life had garbage pizza like this.This pizza shop should not even be open and or they should have different people working in this pizza shop.Today my son went to this Pizzeria and order two slices of pizza. The first slice of Pizza had sausage, pepperoni and cheese on it. So I also wanted onions, mushrooms and peppers added to this slice.However, the person that’s working in this Pizzeria took the slice of pizza that had cheese, sausage and pepperoni and just added raw onions and raw mushrooms on the top and he didn’t even bother to cook it.This was the garbage slice of pizza that was given to my son.Incompetent people, they shouldn’t even own a pizza shop if this is how you’re going to treat the customers totally disgusting
The calzones are delicious, and then strangely the pizza is not very good. My husband and I used to order their calzones all the time though when we lived in the neighborhood we loved them so much. Delicious ricotta cheese filling. Just pass on the pizza.
I got this order from Grubhub, but they didn't respond to my request and blamed the driver. Terrible service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent pizza at reasonable pricesVery friendly staff
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service was really weird. One of the employees kept screaming.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
After waiting over 2 hours I called and asked when it would be delivered. They said it has already left. Another 45 minutes goes by and I call them again to find out they cancelled the order. When I asked what happened they tried to blame me and said I canceled it. Never order from this sad excuse for a business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Now I will be honest. The pizza is the best in the UWS. Hands down. However, I noticed the employees are rude to the black customers.
Just not a very good pizza. Low quality ingredients. Half the dollar slice places in the city are better than this.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Love the pie pie original
Really good, big NY Pizza. Very nice people. Price seemed fair. Very fast service. I recommend.
Delicious pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Cheese
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good NY style pizza. Rated them lower because after I picked up my pies and got home I realized they left the pepperoni off my pepperoni pie. Grrrr
Pie Pie Pizza makes a pretty decent pizza but I wouldn't tell visitors to go out of their way to try it. For those that live in the neighborhood, it's not a bad option to have but I don't feel like it offers enough to make it truly standout.The slices are fairly thin, which I do prefer, but the pizza is also really oily. The cheese and sauce both don't really have a standout flavor so everything just kind of tastes like one thing instead of a bunch of complimentary ingredients.Will I go back? Sure. Will it be my go-to pizza place? No.
Food: 4
Ordered from Uber eats and got what looked like 4 of the stalest, driest pizzas I have ever seen in my life. Literally had one slice had the worse case of food poisoning almost instantly. Never never ever ordering from them again. Alll 4 pizzas went to the trash!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
*this is your signal to buy*
THE WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD SINCE I HAVE LIVED IN NYC.I have lived in New York City for more than 25 years and I have never in my life had garbage pizza like this.This pizza shop should not even be open and or they should have different people working in this pizza shop.Today my son went to this Pizzeria and order two slices of pizza. The first slice of Pizza had sausage, pepperoni and cheese on it. So I also wanted onions, mushrooms and peppers added to this slice.However, the person that’s working in this Pizzeria took the slice of pizza that had cheese, sausage and pepperoni and just added raw onions and raw mushrooms on the top and he didn’t even bother to cook it.This was the garbage slice of pizza that was given to my son.Incompetent people, they shouldn’t even own a pizza shop if this is how you’re going to treat the customers totally disgusting