Pizza is good, the sauce is great ! In my opinion not worth almost $25 to spend on a small vegan pie unless your into that give it a try !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Miriam Villacañas
I ordered a margarita pizza for a picnic from Lucille’s and was an amazing idea! Everybody liked. The pizza was really nice, the ingredients are very tasty. I usually buy pizza from this place and always is good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia Nixon
Pizza is the best we have had in NYC... MVP - delish. The crust was unlike any other! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jeremy Hess
Authentic pizza spot about 12 minutes walk from yankee stadium. Not any seating but benches outside in nice weather. Lots of options - Sicilian, traditional and some excellent sausage!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madelaine Holden
Best pizza in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Craig
Our fave local pizza. Order delivery/to go from here regularly. Love the square pies too.
Chad Harris
Lasagna was delicious. Hit the spot for the craving. I like that it has beef and pork in the sauce. Ordered delivery through their website.
Mark Dold-McIntosh
The BEST pizza there is. Particularly found of The Grandma. Square cut/Siclian style. It reminds me of my Chicago roots.
Jake Roberts
I have been going here for a lil while now and my experience was good for the first few times but now every time i order the lunch special my pizza has no structure and is flopping all over the place. The people there are great and the service is amazing but if the plane pizza slice had a bit more structure and a lil crunch to it, i would have no complaints. Its like I'm eating warm dough cheese and marinara sauce
Cee Ramos
I only gave 4 stars for the atmosphere because i just went to pizza by lucille's to go place not the restaurant. But the pizza, it was so good!!!! I got a lslice of the meatball burrata and the arthur ave slice.
Best pizza around by a large margin. The mvp is such a great pie.
Rob Cruz
This area is just horrible you can’t call for pick up but when you there they make you wait and over the phone Rude Mexican but than again this area is dirty so I can understand the service being the same DONT SPEND YOUR MONEY HERE
And I Stand By what I Said. So don’t be upset I’m a a US citizen who pays taxes like we all do and will state my opinion The Mexican. You do know who is the president now god bless America 🇺🇸
BLUE RIVVON
Lucille’s Pizza in Harlem is a gem! This small, very New York-style pizza spot has an authentic vibe. The pizza is phenomenal—crispy crust, fresh toppings, and perfect flavors. A must-try spot for pizza lovers!
Kate Cohen
I can’t get over how good Lucille’s pizza is. Their vodka sauce pizza has become my new obsession. The sauce is amazing, the homemade mozzarella is insane, and the crust—the crust!—it’s so delicious in and of itself; it definitely gives me the sense that Lucille’s put some work and care into perfecting their pizza dough.
Delivery is really fast and reliable. I need to check them out in person soon.
Michelle Lesperance
Not only was the ravioli I ordered flavorless but I was truly shocked by the serving size of about 8 pieces I received for a $30 delivery. I am giving three stars because I ordered cheesecake as well, which was delicious.
Pizza is good, the sauce is great ! In my opinion not worth almost $25 to spend on a small vegan pie unless your into that give it a try !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
I ordered a margarita pizza for a picnic from Lucille’s and was an amazing idea! Everybody liked. The pizza was really nice, the ingredients are very tasty. I usually buy pizza from this place and always is good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is the best we have had in NYC... MVP - delish. The crust was unlike any other! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Authentic pizza spot about 12 minutes walk from yankee stadium. Not any seating but benches outside in nice weather. Lots of options - Sicilian, traditional and some excellent sausage!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our fave local pizza. Order delivery/to go from here regularly. Love the square pies too.
Lasagna was delicious. Hit the spot for the craving. I like that it has beef and pork in the sauce. Ordered delivery through their website.
The BEST pizza there is. Particularly found of The Grandma. Square cut/Siclian style. It reminds me of my Chicago roots.
I have been going here for a lil while now and my experience was good for the first few times but now every time i order the lunch special my pizza has no structure and is flopping all over the place. The people there are great and the service is amazing but if the plane pizza slice had a bit more structure and a lil crunch to it, i would have no complaints. Its like I'm eating warm dough cheese and marinara sauce
I only gave 4 stars for the atmosphere because i just went to pizza by lucille's to go place not the restaurant. But the pizza, it was so good!!!! I got a lslice of the meatball burrata and the arthur ave slice.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza around by a large margin. The mvp is such a great pie.
This area is just horrible you can’t call for pick up but when you there they make you wait and over the phone Rude Mexican but than again this area is dirty so I can understand the service being the same DONT SPEND YOUR MONEY HERE
And I Stand By what I Said. So don’t be upset I’m a a US citizen who pays taxes like we all do and will state my opinion The Mexican. You do know who is the president now god bless America 🇺🇸
Lucille’s Pizza in Harlem is a gem! This small, very New York-style pizza spot has an authentic vibe. The pizza is phenomenal—crispy crust, fresh toppings, and perfect flavors. A must-try spot for pizza lovers!
I can’t get over how good Lucille’s pizza is. Their vodka sauce pizza has become my new obsession. The sauce is amazing, the homemade mozzarella is insane, and the crust—the crust!—it’s so delicious in and of itself; it definitely gives me the sense that Lucille’s put some work and care into perfecting their pizza dough.
Delivery is really fast and reliable. I need to check them out in person soon.
Not only was the ravioli I ordered flavorless but I was truly shocked by the serving size of about 8 pieces I received for a $30 delivery. I am giving three stars because I ordered cheesecake as well, which was delicious.
Loading...