PIZZA CITY

1760 1st Ave., New York
(646) 719-1664

Recent Reviews

Daniel smith

Tried 4 times to eat here and was always closed

Ben Lerner

Accepted a mobile order on grubhub and said they were open, took my money and were closed without reason in the middle of the day. These are scammers

Daniel Hallett

Very good would

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Aaron Mulder

I got the Sicilian pizza and it's nothing like their menu photo showed. It's not actively bad, just really bland: about the same as you'd get if you microwaved some tomato sauce, pepperoni, and mozzarella on white bread.

59 Evergreen

Pizza was not very warm but warmed it up and forget about it. Was great

Indio Raj

This pizza is pretty good. They just close before 9pm so by the time I walk by there at night they are usually closed.

Surfraz Syed

Ordered pizza and it arrived ICE COLD! Completely unacceptable. Do not order from here.

The Vibe

Decent slice does the job.

Tony C.

I agree with other reviewers on the quality of the pizza. There are many better options in the area but it's good value for the price. I'm happy to pay $6.50 for 2 slices and a canned beverage if I happen to be right there.

Viktor Epifanov

Stayed at a hotel right around the corner and decided to order a pizza from here. One of the best pizzas I've had in a long time.

Claire Millett

Solid New York slice, no frills.

Colino Deani

Listen.. you want New York Pizza? This is one of those places.. if your looking for Pleasantries and kindness go up the block this place doesn't even answer the phone because Screw their customers lol. But if your just looking for some GOOD frickin' Pizza? Put your NYer hat on, Walk in like you own the place, order your Pizza and eat like a Boss! XD The Pizza is THAT GOOD!

alfarouk majid

Hey this guy is a robber, I ordered one slice and a soda and lady behind me ordered two and a soda, I got charged $5.75 where he charged her $6 for her two versus my one. Someone please tell me if I'm doing the math wrong, do not eat here they are robbers

Crystal H.

I ordered on seamless and 5 min after the order was supposed to be delivered I got an email my order was refunded. So I called to ask what was going on just so I was aware. The dude on the phone was rude and said it was cancelled because I didn't order a minimum amount. I told him he should make that a qualification if the case cause seamless allowed me to order. He was rude and unfriendly. Will never try this place again.

Orlando Cosme

This place has awful customer service that pins their mistakes on customers. I put an order for a pie for pickup and had multiple friends who heard my order when I called and corroborated that I put the correct order in. When I picked up it turned out they messed up my pie, and the man working the counter, Pedro Vazquez, refused to simply make me a new pie even though HE was the one who messed up. The ridiculous thing is that I said I would have waited for the new pie but the guy just refused to admit he made a mistake and refused to make a new one. He was also incredibly rude. This has been multiple times now that the people working here have been incredibly rude. Go to the tens of other pizza places in the area.

Load More