Potbelly Sandwich Shop

333 Park Ave S, New York
(646) 289-4212

Recent Reviews

Sort by
John Arzomand

Great food and a great staff!

Sindi Meli

They have a sweet deal on shakes and their turkey club is yummy!!

Carol Tong

I got the chicken salad with provolone cheese. It wasn't as bad as I expected. Love the chicken, it tasted great.

David Acton

The cheese and broccoli soup was outstanding. Clean and comfortable eatery - would definitely recommend.

David Zhang

Could do a lot worse for a quick cheap lunch. Usually alternated between the wreck and the meatball sandwiches.

Ananya Gupta

The staff is very friendly, courteous and accommodating. The two 'BIG' sandwiches however, that I ordered, at this location were long but were certainly lacking the right quantity of stuffing. It was a lot of bread and seemed like the 'regular' amount of filling. Potbelly's brownie cookies are an incredible alternative to the lack of Insomnia Cookies in NY/NJ. You may need to point that out ahead while placing your order.

David Stephens

You know what it is

drew tarvin

It's good for a quick lunch, assuming the line isn't too long. If you get a milkshake, you'll also get a little cookie on your straw.

Lou Carulli

If you like the toasted sub concept, this place does it pretty well. I got the Italian and found the meat quality to be good as well as the bread for a chain shop. Sub was very tasty, service was fast

Amber Vittoria

The chicken & cheese on multigrain with mayo, lettuce and tomato is my default. A filling, yummy sandwich.

John Paterakis

Decent food, but it just seems too ... complicated ... to order here. Service seemed forced and grudging.

David Zhang

Wreck on white, provolone, and all the fixings minus mustard and oil. Dream bar for dessert if it's one of those days.

Jason Hartley

Great sandwiches, horrible service.

Jonathan L.

If you're a Baruch College student, show your ID for a free cookie. Save $1.40

Jeff Petriello

Mediterranean w/ everything is a pretty decent vegetarian sandwich.

Loading...