Writing this review for my husband and his cousin: This restaurant has sliding glass window type of doors to let fresh air in, which is nice, but it also lets in cigarette smoke from people walking by on the street - not so nice. As for the food, it LOOKED good, but the steaks were very bland. The Tomahawk was not cooked to order (it was undercooked) and the server brought back what looked to be the same steak that was burnt by a blow-torch. Sadly, the meal highlights were the bread basket, calamari, mozzarella sticks and side salad. Regarding the service, the server, Sal, brought the check to the table (which includes a surprise service charge) and stared down my husband while standing over him in an intimidating manner (as if to prepare for dine-and-dashers). Two thumbs down to the food & service. Will never come here again when visiting NYC. Highly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Esthepany Francisco
We stopped by this restaurant late (around 11:45 PM - a rare find in NYC!) and were so impressed by the entire experience. From the moment we walked in, the vibe was welcoming and relaxed. We kicked things off with drinks; the lychee martini and spicy margarita were both delicious and strong, just the way we like them!
For food, we ordered the lobster ravioli, lobster bisque, tuna tartare, and wedge salad. everything was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented.
What really made the night special was the service. Every server was genuinely pleasant and incredibly attentive, constantly checking in to make sure we were doing well. Shoutout to Tolly (I believe he was the closing manager) he was so warm, friendly, and made us feel like family. We ended up chatting for a bit before we left, and his energy truly added something special to the evening.
Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great late-night dining spot with top-tier hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Power Performance
Don’t Waste Your Money! $58 ribeye that was so tough, the table was shaking. Wasn’t very well seasoned, and even the $12 Mash Potato Side was Bland. I could get better food for 1/3 the cost at a chain Restaurant. BUT service was Fantastic. Our Server, Host, and Busser were all Great and saved the experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Madison Hutchinson
We came here for dinner before we went to a show. The lobster à la vodka with linguine was the best I ever had. The staff was wonderful. I will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kat Vancko
I really liked the ambiance. The music was good and not too loud. I didn’t even need to wear earplugs, as I often do these days to protect me from getting much worse migraines.
I sat at the bar, since it was only me, but tho the bar wasn’t busy and service was friendly, it was very slow.
The food was wonderful! I’m glad I made the choices I did, tho of course nothing I wanted was included in the happy hour specials. The fried calamari was some of the best I’ve had tho it was observed with a little bit of cocktail sauce and a huge thing of tartar sauce. I’m sure I could have gotten more cocktail sauce, since I don’t like tartar sauce, but it wasn’t necessary. The calamari was so good.
The lobster bisque was delicious and the picture can’t show you that it was full of lobster. There was a LOT more lobster than a lobster bisque normally contains and the price was about normal for a lobster bisque with one tiny piece of lobster.
The iced tea was a bit out of control. If I’m going to be charged $5 per glass of iced tea, that glass should be larger than the ones they use AND not 90% ice. That much for a glass of ice with a splash of iced tea is extreme.
I’d still return, since the food was wonderful and hopefully I just got unlucky with the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Jennifer St. Andrews
Amazing happy hour prices and very kind and friendly people. It was probably our favorite place to eat in the city
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jack Sincere
Ordered the lobster ravioli in marinara sauce. The meal came in a vodka sauce. The sauce was delicious, however the ravioli had little to no lobster and mostly ricotta cheese. The ravioli and sauce were delicious- but expected lobster. My wife had the grilled chicken sandwich. This too was disappointing. All the sandwiches but the chicken sandwich say that fries are included . With that we ordered a side of mashed potatoes. We were surprised to see the chicken sandwich came with fries. We mentioned this to the waiter who promptly removed the mashed potatoes from the bill as requested. I don’t think it is our responsibility to question all aspects of the menu. During your visit I would question everything to prevent surprises during the food offering .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
SAVVAS SAVVA
Bait and switch. Dishonest. $1.75 an Oyster special. Told staff I wanted to eat the special Oysters, they sat me at a table knowing full well I had just requested the Oyster special. When my party of 2 arrived we asked if we could eat more Oysters on the special. They then disclosed it was $4.50 per Oyster. We paid the bill and left. DO NOT GO TO THIS RESTAURANT.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sheharyar Quadri
It was ok food. The waiter was busy talking to people walking outside instead of taking order. The kitchen staff took my plate, not the waiter. On top of that, there was approx 30% auto service charge for 1 person. This was not disclosed anywhere. Based on the service it deserved a 10% tip... A rip off. I would find other restaurants in time square.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Luke Griffin
Visiting NYC for the second time and this was my second time stopping at Prime Catch. Great steak, and amazing drinks. Will definitely come back on my next visit.
Nice steak house, Service was amazing. Thank you Eni 😊
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jamul Brown
Amazing environment darra the bartender is the best bartender on the planet good vibes good atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Opentable Diner
Had dinner following a Saturday matinee show. We thought the staff was extremely friendly. We got seated early, and our entire service team was pleasant and attentive. The veal chop and steaks were cooked perfectly.
James
Our meal was excellent as was the service. The staff was professional and very attentive to our needs.
Writing this review for my husband and his cousin: This restaurant has sliding glass window type of doors to let fresh air in, which is nice, but it also lets in cigarette smoke from people walking by on the street - not so nice. As for the food, it LOOKED good, but the steaks were very bland. The Tomahawk was not cooked to order (it was undercooked) and the server brought back what looked to be the same steak that was burnt by a blow-torch. Sadly, the meal highlights were the bread basket, calamari, mozzarella sticks and side salad. Regarding the service, the server, Sal, brought the check to the table (which includes a surprise service charge) and stared down my husband while standing over him in an intimidating manner (as if to prepare for dine-and-dashers). Two thumbs down to the food & service. Will never come here again when visiting NYC. Highly disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
We stopped by this restaurant late (around 11:45 PM - a rare find in NYC!) and were so impressed by the entire experience. From the moment we walked in, the vibe was welcoming and relaxed. We kicked things off with drinks; the lychee martini and spicy margarita were both delicious and strong, just the way we like them!
For food, we ordered the lobster ravioli, lobster bisque, tuna tartare, and wedge salad. everything was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented.
What really made the night special was the service. Every server was genuinely pleasant and incredibly attentive, constantly checking in to make sure we were doing well. Shoutout to Tolly (I believe he was the closing manager) he was so warm, friendly, and made us feel like family. We ended up chatting for a bit before we left, and his energy truly added something special to the evening.
Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great late-night dining spot with top-tier hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don’t Waste Your Money! $58 ribeye that was so tough, the table was shaking. Wasn’t very well seasoned, and even the $12 Mash Potato Side was Bland. I could get better food for 1/3 the cost at a chain Restaurant.
BUT service was Fantastic. Our Server, Host, and Busser were all Great and saved the experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
We came here for dinner before we went to a show. The lobster à la vodka with linguine was the best I ever had. The staff was wonderful. I will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really liked the ambiance. The music was good and not too loud. I didn’t even need to wear earplugs, as I often do these days to protect me from getting much worse migraines.
I sat at the bar, since it was only me, but tho the bar wasn’t busy and service was friendly, it was very slow.
The food was wonderful! I’m glad I made the choices I did, tho of course nothing I wanted was included in the happy hour specials. The fried calamari was some of the best I’ve had tho it was observed with a little bit of cocktail sauce and a huge thing of tartar sauce. I’m sure I could have gotten more cocktail sauce, since I don’t like tartar sauce, but it wasn’t necessary. The calamari was so good.
The lobster bisque was delicious and the picture can’t show you that it was full of lobster. There was a LOT more lobster than a lobster bisque normally contains and the price was about normal for a lobster bisque with one tiny piece of lobster.
The iced tea was a bit out of control. If I’m going to be charged $5 per glass of iced tea, that glass should be larger than the ones they use AND not 90% ice. That much for a glass of ice with a splash of iced tea is extreme.
I’d still return, since the food was wonderful and hopefully I just got unlucky with the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Amazing happy hour prices and very kind and friendly people. It was probably our favorite place to eat in the city
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered the lobster ravioli in marinara sauce. The meal came in a vodka sauce. The sauce was delicious, however the ravioli had little to no lobster and mostly ricotta cheese. The ravioli and sauce were delicious- but expected lobster. My wife had the grilled chicken sandwich. This too was disappointing. All the sandwiches but the chicken sandwich say that fries are included . With that we ordered a side of mashed potatoes. We were surprised to see the chicken sandwich came with fries. We mentioned this to the waiter who promptly removed the mashed potatoes from the bill as requested. I don’t think it is our responsibility to question all aspects of the menu. During your visit I would question everything to prevent surprises during the food offering .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Bait and switch.
Dishonest.
$1.75 an Oyster special.
Told staff I wanted to eat the special Oysters, they sat me at a table knowing full well I had just requested the Oyster special.
When my party of 2 arrived we asked if we could eat more Oysters on the special.
They then disclosed it was $4.50 per Oyster.
We paid the bill and left.
DO NOT GO TO THIS RESTAURANT.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It was ok food. The waiter was busy talking to people walking outside instead of taking order. The kitchen staff took my plate, not the waiter. On top of that, there was approx 30% auto service charge for 1 person. This was not disclosed anywhere. Based on the service it deserved a 10% tip... A rip off. I would find other restaurants in time square.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Visiting NYC for the second time and this was my second time stopping at Prime Catch. Great steak, and amazing drinks. Will definitely come back on my next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice steak house, Service was amazing. Thank you Eni 😊
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Amazing environment darra the bartender is the best bartender on the planet good vibes good atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had dinner following a Saturday matinee show. We thought the staff was extremely friendly. We got seated early, and our entire service team was pleasant and attentive. The veal chop and steaks were cooked perfectly.
Our meal was excellent as was the service. The staff was professional and very attentive to our needs.
Yummy Butterflied-Branzino
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...