Proto's Pizza NYC

50 2nd Ave, New York
(212) 432-4044

Recent Reviews

Dillon Walls

Pepperoni roll was 10/10 for a midnight snack, service was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian F.

Their pizza may be fine, but their spaghetti is the ABSOLUTE WORST. Beyond awful. Tastes like spaghettios. They should also take it easy on their techno music. A big screen features some demonic head. Overall, everything about this place sucks.

Mike Z.

Stopped in for a quick sandwich before an event. Fast service, fresh food, exactly what I needed

Denise Foster

Love love love! Their dinners and heros are amazing. Sorry haven't tried the pizza yet. Best sauce I have had since my mom's!!! The bread they use is delish. Portions are good. Delivery is fast and friendly,and food arrives hot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sandwich

John O'Neill

Good slice of pizza. Nothing special but staff was friendly and the price was fine. The place is clean and well kept up.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

M Koti

Mediocre pizza at astronomical prices; two plain slices for $9 !!!!I understand there is inflation, but this is highway robbery. Definitely not worth the money. No atmosphere at the place either. I’m not sure why I’m giving them an extra star.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Mudassar Hussain

Old management and pizza was better than now after

Food: 1

Melyssa W.

This is a really good slice, from someone who rarely likes slices. I'm more of a fresh pie person typically. Great crust, quality toppings, savory sauce not the sweet ketchup-y kind. And really cool people work there. I left with one slice and was back an hour later.

Darek Berg

This place underwent renovations. Looks nice and clean. We stopped by on the way home, and ordered a simple Cheese Pie to go. Great flavor. Service was prompt. Overall very happy.

Carwin Brice III

Great slice of crispy, medium-thin crust, at a great price and because of new management there is AC! The workers are happier now :) a happy team makes the product MUCH better!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eduardo Carrasco

One of the best pizza in NYC, service was

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bella Tokyo

Friendly staff and great pizza!! Buffalo chicken slice is the best I’ve had, and the plain is delicious!

Matt

Worst pizza I have ever had, ordered one pie and two sodas. Pizza arrived cold and with no soda, when we opened the box it looked like the box had been kicked down the street, all the pizza was loaded up on one corner of the box and the cheese had slid off. We called and the owner called me a liar and refused a refund even after seeing the pictures. The owner was rude stated that the 20 dollars didn't make a difference to him but refused to do the right thing. On top of that the pizza was far and away the most greasey disgusting pizza I have ever had, we threw it out.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Anna G.

Friendly, quick service and excellent pizza. I usually get the white pizza. TVs with sports and Mr. Bean.

randy weinberg

You want a great fresh slice of pizza that's actually crispy ..can't find ? Well always at Protos ..I stopped eating pizza while ago cause they all are doughy soft ridiculous..not Protos .and there entrees are always fantastic..I just wish the boys would have some shrimp ,clams ,and calamari on the menu .miss my cold seafood anti pasta salad .and linguini and clams ..guess the kids today don't eat that .

Load More