Quality Meats

57 W 58th St, New York
(212) 371-7777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Donald

The waiter was not really interested in explaining certain dishes. Carrot side dish at $18.00 was way overpriced for a small portion . The N Y Strip Steak was served cold and needed a chain saw to cut. The side order of Parmesan Fries was also served cold. I didn't complain because we had guests who could not afford the price point of this restaurant and my wife and myself did not want to ruin their experience. Will not return to this restaurant.

Deborah

Beautiful space with great service and even better tasting food and drinks. Can't wait to return.

PG

The food was nice and high-quality, and the service was great. We had a good time and a good experience. We will definitely go back again.

Casey

Food was ok but for the price I would say not worth it. Much better steakhouses in NYC. The service was surprisingly under whelming and we waited almost 30 minutes between finishing dinner and getting dessert. I was shocked at the lack of superb service for a steakhouse in NYC

Arislennia

✨ First Impressions That Last ✨ This was my very first time visiting, and I can already say it won't be my last. From the moment I walked in, I was impressed by the atmosphere—the lighting was soft, warm, and delicately set, creating the perfect mood for an enjoyable meal. The food was truly a highlight. Every dish was thoughtfully prepared and beautifully presented. The flavors were balanced yet bold, making each bite memorable. The green salad, in particular, stood out—it was one of the freshest and most flavorful I've ever tasted, crisp and vibrant in every way. Service was equally excellent. The staff managed to be both attentive and welcoming without ever being overbearing, which really elevated the overall dining experience. In the end, everything came together seamlessly: atmosphere, food, and service. It was a wonderful experience from start to finish, and one I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a place that blends elegance with great taste. I'll definitely be coming back again!

Susan

Wonderful experience with Quality Meats. Family style was ample for three women to share. Outdoor seating was great for people watching. The indoor looked lovely as well. 

Kelsey

Our sever Louis was absolutely outstanding. Truly a hospitality professional. The backserver Sarook was a gem also ! The whole team was truly a treat, the food is just the top to a great experience. We CANNOT wait to come back !

Ned

Despite an early reservation and an empty restaurant, I was shunted by a disinterested host to sit at the bar while waiting for my guest. We were shown to a table next to a table for 20 created down the length of the dining room. Every square inch of the room was packed with diners sitting elbow to elbow. Soon, the noise level was truly excruciating. It was impossible to have a conversation, enjoy the food or get a waiter's attention. Despite the very good steak and sides, I cannot recommend a restaurant with such impossible conditions.

Fred

Great service, However portion sizes for the steaks leave a lot to be desired given the prices.

Charlotte

Absolutely delicious experience. I used to host events here and it was so fun to bring my girlfriend for a great date night. The staff was fantastic.

Jacob

Quality Meats is a top-notch experience. Excellent food and service. They really know how to take care of guests.

Leslie

Another wonderful lunch at Quality Meats! Service was excellent and our NYC Strip Steaks were cooked to a perfect Medium! Highly recommended!

Maricarmen

This place is a MUST!!! The meatballs are out of this world spectacular. We ordered Hanger Steak which was cooked to PERFECTION and Filet Mignon which melted in my husbands mouth. Tye veggies we ordered as sides were equally as delicious. The service and staff are phenomenal. Very friendly. When going to NYC, do yourself a favor and go to Quality Meats. I know we will be going back every single time we have the chance.

Reva

Excellent service and food. Delicious steak, lobster and chicken. Complimentary dessert to celebrate our daughters' high school graduations

Steven

Great food as always. Terrific atmosphere. Very helpful sommelier. Excellent service. Prices seemed more reasonable, but maybe I am just getting used to the current level of prices.

Loading...