Quality Meats

57 W 58th St, New York
(212) 371-7777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Reva

Excellent service and food. Delicious steak, lobster and chicken. Complimentary dessert to celebrate our daughters' high school graduations

Steven

Great food as always. Terrific atmosphere. Very helpful sommelier. Excellent service. Prices seemed more reasonable, but maybe I am just getting used to the current level of prices.

Christian

Great steakhouse. Also delicious shrimp, oysters and crab. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal.

Bob

Everything was great. We had 2 children (ages 8 and 10) with us. The staff was great and helped us with ordering. Food was wonderful, we started with the Dressed oysters and shrimp cocktail. We had the sirloin and the rib steak. We asked them if they could slice both for us and the 4 adults shared the 2 steaks. Sides were wonderful also. The cream brûlée corn is a must try. Would definitely come back and highly recommend it.

Connor

Came here for date night and the food was amazing, the steaks were cooked perfectly! Would recommend to anyone coming to the city and wanting experience fine dining! The table side truffle butter service was a must have.

Seth

It's a pretty fun place, but the quality of the steaks is just not as high as other old-school steakhouses

Yechiel

Might be the best steakhouse in nyc. Robert the sommelier was impeccable and outstanding. Portions are large and tasty. Staff is amazing.

Ryan

We had planned our anniversary dinner at Wolfgang's, which was so awful we left before the waiter could take our order (granted, we sat at the table for 25 minutes finishing our cocktails we'd ordered at the bar before doing so and no one came by). Luckily, Quality Meats came through with availability so we quickly pivoted uptown and the meal was outstanding. Not only were the staff lovely and attentive, but the food was delicious and they even did a nice gesture to congratulate us on our anniversary. I'd tell you to skip all the other steakhouses and just come here, but I don't want it getting too popular so please ignore my review.

Michael

Went with my girl for my bday the restaurant was recommended to me by one of the door men at the One hotel my fav place to stay when I visit NYC directly across the street . Started at the bar with a couple of very well made drinks before dinner thumbs to the bartenders. We had the cracked Lobster cocktail for an app fresh tasty and easy to eat being I'm from bean town Lobster was on point. I had the the aged tomahawk and she the filet mignon both perfectly cooked and delicious literally took the hawk down to bone we had 2 sides Brussel sprouts mouth watering and mash potatoes which were just as good topped off with a bottle of Catana Alta Malbec which was perfect the meal. Wasn't gonna have dessert but the servers whom were all very professional and perisonalble over heard it was my Bday and brought us strawberry ice cream crumble with a cone on top and candle which made the ending to the night perfect ! Highly recommend Quality meats def lives up to its name ... service was great ambiance was chill and friendly and the prices reasonable thank you for a great experience!

Bergen

Celebrated our wedding anniversary with a wonderful dinner at Quality Meats. Steaks melt in your mouth and service was A+

Roman

Service - bad. The waiter that sat as at the table didn't know items from the menu. Sommelier took order of 2 drinks and ran away when a person at my party hesitated for a second. After the meal the waiter did not come to take dessert order for a long time. Everyone was running around as if no tomorrow. Food - good steak for sure but bare on a plate, no sauce (had to ask for peppercorn for 6$), just a slab of a bit burned meat. It was a bit cold when served. Noise - very noisy. We won't come back.

Carlos R

Of the few restaurants that made me a Penicillin, and it was immaculate. Thank you! The meat and food were, as usual, outstanding. Wait staff and hostess were amazing. Awesome business lunch.

Dana

Waiter seemed annoyed. Food was delicious. Would have been better with kinder service. Beautiful space.

Andrew

Great bar for pre dinner drinks, excellent food and service, remains one of my favourite restaurants in NYC

kobe kaba

Luxury restaurant they only take a certain demographic of people in the restaurant

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...