Regina's Grocery - Mulberry

Had this place saved for ages, stumbles across it while going for a walk & decided let me give it a try. Unfortunately, the sandwich I got was soo underwhelming I forced myself to finish it, bc HEY…it was. $17.50 & I wasn’t tossing it away in THIS economy. I had the Uncle Phil, with BARELY any balsamic glaze in it. Personally wouldn’t get that again.

Bread was stale which ruined the whole sandwich. Mozzarella was a bit dry and rubbery. Such a shame, I was excited about this. Really hesitated to write this review.

Stale bread on a 19 dollar sandwich and 1 dollar extra for arugula. This neighborhood breaks my heart.

Great sandwiches. Cannot go wrong.

I hesitate to write this review, mostly because I want to support local businesses and I’ve eaten here about 20 times over the years. Unfortunately, the past two trips have confirmed what I feared to be happening: the quality and quantity of sandwich is cratering, especially for the price. To charge $16 for a razor-thin slice of dry prosciutto on stale bread isn’t justified, even on Mulberry. These sandwiches used to absolutely crush, and were filled with lots of ingredients. That doesn’t seem to be the case anymore, which super stinks. Hopefully we can turn it around!

My go-to sandwich place!

Best meatball parm in NYC

We had the uncle Phil and uncle Jimmy!
Delish!!!!

My first time here and I love this place! The owner is so nice and welcoming. And I saw how he was giving fresh free baguettes to less fortunate man who stopped by, such a rare thing to see in NYC!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So authentic and the service was great— I’ll come back here all the time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 12 Cannoli's, Baguette

Great small sandwich shop! Family owned and tons of history. Definitely stop in if you are craving a sandwich or just want a small shop vibe with quick services.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was walking around “little Italy” and came across this very pleasant and familiar place. Very good sandwich (I asked for the house's recommendation). Two people eat well! Worth the visit!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Big, tasty Italian sandwiches! I got the Uncle Jimmy and the ingredients were fresh and delicious! I wish that my sandwich came with a little more meat, but it was still really good (I especially loved the hot pepper spread!). A bit pricey, but the sandwiches are large.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Uncle Jimmy

My sandwich was AMAZING! But even more impressive is the calm, non-sceney, welcoming atmosphere created at Regina's in the heart of SoHo. 100 stars!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

In the mood for an Italian style sandwich and was on my way to Parisi but only to discover that it didn't open on Sunday lol....found Regina on Google Map - it is a success ?

The place is super chill and I love love love the nostalgic decor. I wouldn't mind chilling here if not busy even tho this place is more for order-n-go.

Food was good, generous sizing at a reasonable price. I managed to finish about 1/3 of the Big Anthony which was the first item I saw on the menu.

Not my usual go-to but I adore the mustard punch tho wish it was stronger. Next time I will try my benchmark for Italian style sandwiches - tuna (Grandma Lucy) on the menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Big Anthony Sandwich