Risotteria Melotti NYC

309 E 5th St, New York
(646) 755-8939

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Caroline

All of our food was amazing and we couldn't believe it was all gluten free! Amazing service as well - our server was so thoughtful and helpful!

jennyl

Lovely dinner with delicious food. So nice to have a restaurant with all gluten free dishes.

Shauna

The food was fantastic! If you didn't know it was gluten free, you wouldn't believe it was! The service was friendly, warm, and attentive without being annoying. Dessert was to die for! I love that they aren't trying to sell subpar gluten free pasta, but naturally gluten free risotto.

jennie keating

I very rarely write reviews, but for this restaurant, it was a must. It was amazing from food to service. I will absolutely be back!!

shagun sodhi

Pet friendly and Good service
Good food 😋
They allowed our cat and dog with happy smile
Must recommended 👌

Christine L

Wow. What an absolute gem. A little restaurant in town with intimate seating and a homey atmosphere. The staff is super friendly. The food is delicious and made well. There is a mushroom risotto with mixed wild organic mushrooms and Grana Padano P.D.O. cheese. That was mouthwateringly good. The arancini of the day was a must have as well. The mixed berry sorbet was too sweet for me but half of it was the perfect treat. I will definitely be back to try more dishes!

Now for my standard comments. Easy to walk to in town. There is a good amount of seating but it is a bit packed. Still quite comfortable and cozy to dine in.

S. Haynes

Came here specifically for the risotto and it did not disappoint.

Beatriz

This is an amazing restaurant! Best risotto's ever! I go there everytime I go to NYC Is a must!

David

The food was excellent, and the service was exceptional. We would happily dine here again.

Julie Lee

Risottos from Risotteria is pretty decent, the first taste feels not too special but feels like home cooked meal. The portion was not enough for boyfriend, but it was very filling for me.
Their wild mushroom risotto is really delish with perfect cheesy(or salty?)ness. But their shrimp risotto is little questionable—not that it’s not good, but just too simple flavors with just lemon taste to it.
Their wine lists are little disappointing, though, because it felt like they only source the wines from particular town in Italy, which is understandable, but it was hard to decide/match with the food we’re getting. It felt like some wines just don’t fit or too cheap to drink with the food.(Wine itself is cheap but their price is not.. they charge you a price of the bottle for a glass lol)
The servers are mostly nice, but they will rush you out if you don't order desserts. Little intimidating if you don’t like being starred at for few mins even when you’re not done with your wine/mimosa. The server will get rid of the empty glass right away without even asking if you’d like a second glass.
Would go back to try some other menus but felt slightly expensive for the taste, vibe, and the service you get.

Alex

The desserts were to die for. Risotto was good, but will definitely be coming back for the desserts.

Josh Zuniga

Entirely GF and delicious

Jonah Neustadt

If you like cozy ambience, friendly staff and authentic Italian food that will blow your mind, you MUST come here. I can’t say enough good things about this place. It’s hands down my favorite restaurant in New York. The best risotto I’ve ever had in my life. And you are treated like family every single time! This place is so special. Go here go here go here!

Wehtahnah Tucker

The most authentic, tasty gluten free Italian food in NYC

Carlos

Don't miss this place. Come for the best risotto in town, great menu, delicious. Great service in a very nice ambience. From appetizers to dessert, the best options to enjoy in a lovely place. Highly recommended

Loading...