Rosa Mexicano

9 E 18th St, New York
(212) 533-3350

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cody

Overall I'd give this a 3.5 stars. It took exactly 26 minutes to get water and drinks from the time we were sat down

Alexandra

So family-friendly! The servers were incredibly kind and understanding with our group of 5 young children.

Gabrielle Ciaccia

One of my favorite restaurants! The food, the atmosphere, the service… all fantastic! Shout out to our server, Isabel F, who was excellent and very attentive. We had to catch a show and she made sure everything came out quickly! Thank you Isabel!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jess V.

We drove from Westchester to this place because someone mentioned the food was good, which was OKAY. (ABSOLUTELY NOT WORTH THE DRIVE- should've just gone to Bar Taco). The guac and cheese dip were the best part of the night. Drinks were ok.
Our experience was the complete opposite of what we expected. First of all, the table they sat us in was SO wobbly, our waters kept spilling. The waitress finally came and changed us to a different table. After we placed our order, not even 20 minutes after our appetizers came out, they brought out our main courses. We had a small table of two - there was no room for all the dishes. I MYSELF had to take the initiative to move the dishes around, placing them on the table next to us, because these ppl were just putting dishes on top of menus which were STILL on our table. To make it clear, this wasn't the waitress, these were bus boys or bus girls, and what looked like a chef because he had a white uniform. Completely unprofessional. Of course, the waitress was nowhere to be found. Eventually we had to ask the manager for a drink.
Probably one of the poorest experiences I've ever had.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sarah

Tall male host was incredibly condescending and treated everyone like garbage. Watched it happen to two other parties before he treated me like an idiot. Won’t be back! Tasty guacamole though.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ritz _Essence

Had an appointment in Union Square and stumbled upon this gem to grab a quick lunch! Discounted high end cocktails & a wide selection of delicious Mexican food menu options. I got something less traditional (the Mexican fried rice) but it was delicious nonetheless! Andres was very hospitable!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Olivia Lanza

I’ve been to the other locations many times and they’re consistently great, which is why this experience was such a disappointment. This location did not match the quality or service of the others at all. I honestly wish I had taken the extra 20 minutes to go to the Lincoln Center location instead.

We were seated at a tiny table in the bar area, squeezed between two crowded tables. Once we sat down, it took about 10 to 15 minutes before our server even came over. We ordered shrimp nachos, empanadas, and chile rellenos with a side of rice and beans. The drinks came out quickly, but the food service was another story.

The empanadas arrived looking burnt. When we pointed it out, the server insisted that the dark color was because of beets in the crust. After tasting them, it was obvious they were actually burnt and they didn’t taste good at all. The nachos were the only thing that came out well.

After those first two dishes, we waited an additional 30 to 45 minutes for the entree. By the time it finally arrived, I asked for it to go. Even then, they forgot the beans. We tried asking another server who was helping a nearby table and she said she’d let someone know, but never followed through. We watched her walk around the restaurant without mentioning it to anyone. Eventually our original server returned and we were finally able to get the missing beans.

Overall, this location needs serious improvement with both service and food quality. I’ve had great experiences at the other locations, but I won’t be returning to this one.

EDIT: I would like to add I just tried the Chile rellenos I took home and it did not compare to previous times I’ve ordered this. It was extremely disappointing. I order that dish every time I go and it has never tasted this bad before. I am extremely disappointed.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Karl O' Toole

You start in the door with an unhelpful, unpleasant and generally useless host. He seems to specialize in wiping down the menu covers not so much dealing with people. With a party of ten I would have thought a little attention was in order. The table wasn't ready on time so we were shipped to the bar area. There was no follow up to find us as promised. That was on we customers and another unpleasant grunting session from our miserable non host. The guacamole was good. The main course not worth a revisit. The coffee stunk. The room was noisy and too cold for all. Our waiter was decent. None of our group would go back. Adios non Amigos!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Karl

You start in the door with an unhelpful, unpleasant and generally useless host. He seems to specialize in wiping down the menu covers not so much dealing with people. With a party of ten I would have thought a little attention was in order. The table wasn't ready on time so we were shipped to the bar area. There was no follow up to find us as promised. That was on we customers and another unpleasant grunting session from our miserable non host. The guacamole was good. The main course not worth a revisit. The coffee stunk. The room was noisy and too cold for all. Our waiter was decent. None of our group would go back. Adios non Amigos!

Nicole Ueno

Our waiter was amazing! Super friendly and professional :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Paul

Lovely, fun, and elegant at the same time. Good food and service. A little pricey, but worth it once in a while.

Heather Cooksey

Great food and ambience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lori Mon

Delicious table side guac, $5 frozen cucumber and pomegranate margaritas. Service very attentive

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kerri B.

Celebrated my 50th birthday here with a handful of friends. Service and food was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Meekah

We had an amazing evening. The food was great and the staff was attentive! We will return for another awesome evening!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...