Food and service were terrific, but it is extremely noisy, making normal conversation challenging.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Roque
So, somehow, someway, on Valentine’s Day. A day where they were fully booked throughout the night. In a prefixed menu, they ran out of half of the items on the menu. No grilled octopus, no tuna crudo, no lobster tagliatelle, even didn’t have one of the two desserts being offered. On top of that, the waiter came back and told us they restocked the tuna crudo, only to come back 5 minutes later to say they ran out again. After all that, they brought out my steak which was a 20 dollar upcharge somehow, cooked beyond well done. Charred and looked like a leather shoe. How on earth did the cooks in the kitchen plate serve and send that dish to the table? Incredibly disappointing dining experience. The food was average, and the food we would have ordered was not even available. On Valentines’ Day of all days… don’t usually leave Google reviews but I will if it it’s a tremendous experience or a horrendous experience. This leans toward the latter. One of my worst dining experiences in recent memory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
Erin Kibby
A staple for a reason. Good menu selections and drinks. We had a group of 4, but there were parties much larger and smaller date nights. At Christmas, had trees and garland, very cute. Long wait even with a reservation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Alija
Hostess unwelcoming and not helpful in accommodating. Food was good. Too noisy tho even for a Tuesday night, difficult even to talk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Angela Campbell Earl
Man! I’m so sad I don’t live in NYC-hands down our favorite restaurant. Highly recommend.
Meghan
Service couldn't have been better. Our waitress was so friendly. All 3 courses came out with perfect timing. Olive oil cake dessert was excellent.
DJ
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie
We got the spicy arrabiata pasta, carbonara and the orecchiette. The charcuterie board was honestly the best part for me! The focaccia is a must get.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Santiago
Food was excellent. The best Italian food I've had in a long time. Service is very good too. Wines are a little bit overpriced.
ayngelics
Went here for dinner, I had made reservations earlier in the afternoon but since I was with my friend we decided to cancel it because we were running late. Thankfully once we were done shopping we did walk in instead later in the night. The hostess squeezed us in for an available table for 2 that had a time limit of an hour since it was packed which we didn't mind at all. I liked the food and drink the Salento Spritz cocktail, Ppaperdelle Verdi, and Caprese foccacio! Our server was nice, and very attentive, I would of loved to hear the dessert. I will definitely be back!
In town for a girls trip and had the most amazing experience at Marcellino! Oscar was an amazing waiter. The penne vodka was divine, and the garlic bread to die for. I shared a great tiramisu with my good friend and enjoyed great conversation. The service was truly incredible! We will absolutely be back. Thank you for the great service and great food!
Stephanie Moya
Food is always consistently delicious here - try the foccacia and all the pastas! The drinks are also lovely, and the bar area always has plenty of space to stand and hang / wait for your table. Love this spot! Quintessentially West Village.
Steven Murray
Andy was incredible tonight!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina Lozano
Amazing restaurant, felt like a taste of Italy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Felicity
Rosemary's has a cozy and elegant atmosphere. We had Pasta and Foccacia. The service was a little slow, but overall a good space to gather and have some fresh food.
Food and service were terrific, but it is extremely noisy, making normal conversation challenging.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
So, somehow, someway, on Valentine’s Day. A day where they were fully booked throughout the night. In a prefixed menu, they ran out of half of the items on the menu. No grilled octopus, no tuna crudo, no lobster tagliatelle, even didn’t have one of the two desserts being offered. On top of that, the waiter came back and told us they restocked the tuna crudo, only to come back 5 minutes later to say they ran out again. After all that, they brought out my steak which was a 20 dollar upcharge somehow, cooked beyond well done. Charred and looked like a leather shoe. How on earth did the cooks in the kitchen plate serve and send that dish to the table? Incredibly disappointing dining experience. The food was average, and the food we would have ordered was not even available. On Valentines’ Day of all days… don’t usually leave Google reviews but I will if it it’s a tremendous experience or a horrendous experience. This leans toward the latter. One of my worst dining experiences in recent memory.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
A staple for a reason. Good menu selections and drinks. We had a group of 4, but there were parties much larger and smaller date nights. At Christmas, had trees and garland, very cute. Long wait even with a reservation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hostess unwelcoming and not helpful in accommodating. Food was good. Too noisy tho even for a Tuesday night, difficult even to talk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Man! I’m so sad I don’t live in NYC-hands down our favorite restaurant. Highly recommend.
Service couldn't have been better. Our waitress was so friendly. All 3 courses came out with perfect timing. Olive oil cake dessert was excellent.
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got the spicy arrabiata pasta, carbonara and the orecchiette. The charcuterie board was honestly the best part for me! The focaccia is a must get.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was excellent. The best Italian food I've had in a long time. Service is very good too. Wines are a little bit overpriced.
Went here for dinner, I had made reservations earlier in the afternoon but since I was with my friend we decided to cancel it because we were running late. Thankfully once we were done shopping we did walk in instead later in the night. The hostess squeezed us in for an available table for 2 that had a time limit of an hour since it was packed which we didn't mind at all. I liked the food and drink the Salento Spritz cocktail, Ppaperdelle Verdi, and Caprese foccacio! Our server was nice, and very attentive, I would of loved to hear the dessert. I will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
In town for a girls trip and had the most amazing experience at Marcellino! Oscar was an amazing waiter. The penne vodka was divine, and the garlic bread to die for. I shared a great tiramisu with my good friend and enjoyed great conversation. The service was truly incredible! We will absolutely be back. Thank you for the great service and great food!
Food is always consistently delicious here - try the foccacia and all the pastas! The drinks are also lovely, and the bar area always has plenty of space to stand and hang / wait for your table. Love this spot! Quintessentially West Village.
Andy was incredible tonight!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing restaurant, felt like a taste of Italy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rosemary's has a cozy and elegant atmosphere. We had Pasta and Foccacia. The service was a little slow, but overall a good space to gather and have some fresh food.
Loading...