Sandwell
412 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 321-7911
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Pesto Burrata Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Mushroom Cheese Steak
Baked Hash Brown Patty
Broccoli Cheddar Melt
The Everything Hoagel
Breakfast Sandwiches
Spicy Eggplant Parm
Pesto Chicken Salad
Turkey Meatball Sub
Featured items
Mac & Cheese & Peas
gf cavatappi, cheddar, colby, english peas, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Turkey Meatballs
braised in marinara, parmesan, arugula
Turkey Meatball Sub
turkey meatballs in classic sunday sauce, provolone, parmesan, basil oil, baby arugula
Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie
1 for $4, 3 for $10. gf rolled oats with our own maple-chocolate-hazelnut spread
Broccoli Cheddar Melt
crunchy broccoli, cheddar, turkey bacon bits, melty cheese sauce, caramelized onions, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Mushroom Cheese"steak"
truffled roasted mushrooms, cacio e pepe sauce, provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Large - 24 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Crunchy Broccoli
vegan avocado ranch, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice - 10 oz
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Regular - 16 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Sandwiches
Broccoli Cheddar Melt
crunchy broccoli, cheddar, turkey bacon bits, melty cheese sauce, caramelized onions, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Buffalo Chicken Sub
baked chicken cutlet, vegan buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crisps, pickled carrots and celery, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Chicken Pesto Burrata
grilled chicken breast, basil pesto, whipped burrata, roasted red peppers, tomato, sauteed spinach
Lunchbox Special
our own maple turkey and thick-cut turkey bacon, cheddar, avocado mash, pickles, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Mushroom Cheese"steak"
truffled roasted mushrooms, cacio e pepe sauce, provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers
Spicy Eggplant Parm
baked eggplant cutlet, whipped burrata, marinara, parmesan, chile oil, toasted gf breadcrumbs, baby arugula
The Remy (vegan)
roasted red peppers, baked eggplant cutlet, caramelized onions, marinated cherry tomatoes, zesty zucchini pickles, basil oil, baby spinach & toasted cannellini spread
The Wild Bird
grilled chicken breast, provolone, turkey bacon bits, caramelized onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, hot cherry peppers, vegan spicy secret sauce
Turkey Meatball Sub
turkey meatballs in classic sunday sauce, provolone, parmesan, basil oil, baby arugula
Salads
Buffalo Chicken Salad
baked chicken cutlet, bleu cheese crisps, romaine, pickled carrots and celery, vegan wing sauce dressing
Green Goddess Caesar Salad
romaine, parmesan, green goddess caesar dressing, gf parmesan croutons, marinated cherry tomatoes
Pesto Chicken Salad
grilled chicken breast, whipped burrata, baby spinach, baby arugula, marinated cherry tomatoes, crunchy broccoli, pesto vinaigrette
Sides
Crunchy Broccoli
vegan avocado ranch, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Kid's Meal
choice of baked chicken cutlet or turkey meatballs. served with mac and cheese, roasted broccoli, and box of Mott's apple juice. limited to children under 13
Kosher Dill Pickles
two classic spears, brined in-house
Mac & Cheese & Peas
gf cavatappi, cheddar, colby, english peas, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie
1 for $4, 3 for $10. gf rolled oats with our own maple-chocolate-hazelnut spread
Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie - 3 for 10
1 for $4, 3 for $10. gf rolled oats with our own maple-chocolate-hazelnut spread
Turkey Meatballs
braised in marinara, parmesan, arugula
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Harmless Harvest Coconut Water
8.75 oz
Just Spring Water
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice - 10 oz
Mighty Leaf Hot Tea
Selection of Mighty Leaf Specialty Hot Tea Blends - 12 oz
Natalie's Fresh Orange Juice
8 oz
Organic Black Iced Tea - Regular - 16 oz
Mighty Leaf Organic Black Iced Tea Blend
Organic Black Iced Tea - Large - 24 oz
Mighty Leaf Organic Black Iced Tea Blend
Poppi Classic Cola
prebiotic low-sugar classic cola soda
Poppi Orange Soda
prebiotic low-sugar orange soda
Saratoga Sparkling Water
Spindrift Seltzer - Grapefruit
unsweetened natural grapefruit juice sparkling water
Spindrift Seltzer - Pineapple
unsweetened natural pineapple juice sparkling water
Stumptown Hot Coffee - Regular - 12 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Hot Coffee
Stumptown Hot Coffee - Large - 20 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Hot Coffee
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Regular - 16 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Large - 24 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Merchandise
Sandwell Cap
adjustable vintage blue
Featured items
Chicken Pesto Burrata
grilled chicken breast, basil pesto, whipped burrata, roasted red peppers, tomato, sauteed spinach
The Sandy Special
homemade chicken apple sausage patty, eggs, cheddar, avocado mash, sandwell hot sauce
Turkey Meatball Sub
turkey meatballs in classic sunday sauce, provolone, parmesan, basil oil, baby arugula
The Wild Bird
grilled chicken breast, provolone, turkey bacon bits, caramelized onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, hot cherry peppers, vegan spicy secret sauce
Lunchbox Special
our own maple turkey and thick-cut turkey bacon, cheddar, avocado mash, pickles, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Mushroom Cheese"steak"
truffled roasted mushrooms, cacio e pepe sauce, provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers
The Spicy Shakshuka
eggs, tomato sauce, harissa aioli, za'atar, chile oil, roasted red peppers
The Morning Cobb
egg whites, thick-cut turkey bacon, avocado mash, blue cheese crisps, sauteed spinach, tomato
Buffalo Chicken Sub
baked chicken cutlet, vegan buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crisps, pickled carrots and celery, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice - 10 oz
Breakfast
Baked Hash Brown Patty
shredded potatoes, baked golden brown
Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie
1 for $4, 3 for $10. gf rolled oats with our own maple-chocolate-hazelnut spread
Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie - 3 for 10
1 for $4, 3 for $10. gf rolled oats with our own maple-chocolate-hazelnut spread
Side of Chicken Apple Sausage
two homemade classic patties, uncured & all-natural
Side of Turkey Bacon
thick-cut, uncured, all-natural, made in-house
The Fun Guy
truffled roasted mushrooms, eggs, provolone, sauteed spinach, cacio e pepe sauce
The Italian Job
homemade chicken apple sausage patty, eggs, whipped burrata, tomato, basil pesto
The Morning Cobb
egg whites, thick-cut turkey bacon, avocado mash, blue cheese crisps, sauteed spinach, tomato
The OG
thick-cut turkey bacon, eggs, cheddar
The Sandy Special
homemade chicken apple sausage patty, eggs, cheddar, avocado mash, sandwell hot sauce
The Spicy Shakshuka
eggs, tomato sauce, harissa aioli, za'atar, chile oil, roasted red peppers
Sandwiches
Broccoli Cheddar Melt
crunchy broccoli, cheddar, turkey bacon bits, melty cheese sauce, caramelized onions, toasted gf breadcrumbs
Buffalo Chicken Sub
baked chicken cutlet, vegan buffalo sauce, bleu cheese crisps, pickled carrots and celery, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Chicken Pesto Burrata
grilled chicken breast, basil pesto, whipped burrata, roasted red peppers, tomato, sauteed spinach
Lunchbox Special
our own maple turkey and thick-cut turkey bacon, cheddar, avocado mash, pickles, lettuce, tomato, vegan avocado ranch
Mushroom Cheese"steak"
truffled roasted mushrooms, cacio e pepe sauce, provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers
Spicy Eggplant Parm
baked eggplant cutlet, whipped burrata, marinara, parmesan, chile oil, toasted gf breadcrumbs, baby arugula
The Remy (vegan)
roasted red peppers, baked eggplant cutlet, caramelized onions, marinated cherry tomatoes, zesty zucchini pickles, basil oil, baby spinach & toasted cannellini spread
The Wild Bird
grilled chicken breast, provolone, turkey bacon bits, caramelized onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, hot cherry peppers, vegan spicy secret sauce
Turkey Meatball Sub
turkey meatballs in classic sunday sauce, provolone, parmesan, basil oil, baby arugula
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Harmless Harvest Coconut Water
8.75 oz
Just Spring Water
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice
Martinelli's Organic Apple Juice - 10 oz
Mighty Leaf Hot Tea
Selection of Mighty Leaf Specialty Hot Tea Blends - 12 oz
Natalie's Fresh Orange Juice
8 oz
Organic Black Iced Tea - Regular - 16 oz
Mighty Leaf Organic Black Iced Tea Blend
Organic Black Iced Tea - Large - 24 oz
Mighty Leaf Organic Black Iced Tea Blend
Poppi Classic Cola
prebiotic low-sugar classic cola soda
Poppi Orange Soda
prebiotic low-sugar orange soda
Saratoga Sparkling Water
Spindrift Seltzer - Grapefruit
unsweetened natural grapefruit juice sparkling water
Spindrift Seltzer - Pineapple
unsweetened natural pineapple juice sparkling water
Stumptown Hot Coffee - Regular - 12 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Hot Coffee
Stumptown Hot Coffee - Large - 20 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Hot Coffee
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Regular - 16 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Stumptown Iced Coffee - Large - 24 oz
Stumptown Fresh Roasted Iced Coffee
Merchandise
Sandwell Cap
adjustable vintage blue
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Excellent turkey meatball sandwich, served super hot and fresh (they make everything to order so you never get a sandwich that’s been sitting around). Staff was awesome, and the cashier showed a clear passion for the food as his recommendations were detailed and genuine, and importantly the place was very clean. Looking forward to coming back at some pour!
November 2024
My sandwich was so delicious. I just wanna go right back to bed now. My first five and the best sandwich I ever had?
Vegetarian options: Will do it’s the best ?
Vegetarian options: Will do it’s the best ?
October 2024
You May Also Like
Amorino Gelato - 414 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Macarons, Gelato, Ice Cream, Pet Friendly
La Sirène - 416 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Brasseries, French, Wine Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian
Sushi Nonaka - 410 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar
Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian and gluten free options, but unsafe for celiacs.