The best!!! Nick is an impeccable manager and the food is so consistent and delicious. Pastas and sauces are especially fab. Romantic great ambiance. Classic spot, highly recommend for special occasion or just a nice night out!
Bina
As usual good food and very cozy restaurant. Menu hasn't changed since god knows how many years !
phil
This was our 3rd time at this restaurant, and the food is always impeccable! It is a must for us to dine here every time we are in NYC!
Michael Pomarico
We had an event in the neighborhood and were searching for a nice restaurant and wow did we find a winner!
Scalini Fedeli was exceptional.
From the moment we walked in the door to the moment we left it was an exceptional dining experience.
The restaurant interior is beautiful, soft vaulted ceilings, comfortable seating and the lighting is just right. We arrived early and were offered a corner booth type table which was perfect for the two of us.
Each course of the fixed price menu was excellent.
We look forward to returning and highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zijun
The food was outstanding and beautifully prepared, the atmosphere was elegant yet comfortable, and every staff member from the front desk to the servers, treated us with such warmth and professionalism. It was truly a memorable evening, and I can't wait to come back again!
Miguel Carrilho
It’s as good as it gets. Amazing experience. Best Italian restaurant in NYC. Try the shrimp and lobster pasta!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lloyd Holmes
The kitchen values fresh ingredients while the front of house values fresh approaches. The employees show professionalism. Many different offerings have earned my praise. You'll notice the interesting atmosphere. This place offers something new.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Louis Barbaccia
Great Italian food. Always fresh good quality meat.
Sandeep
Absolutely delightful culinary experience maintaining its overall charm, quality & style. While most restaurants lose their core essence; this one maintains its originality!
Jude Jhons
Just enough surprise to keep things interesting. Their employees create an atmosphere of belonging. This place understands flavor. They offer delicious food in an unpretentious setting with attentive staff and happy customers. Visit this place immediately.
The food was extraordinary. The service was a bit weird, being that it was our first time at this restaurant and NY service is mostly excellent, our waiter was kind of serious and not to talkative. They started bringing us courses and we had to stop and ask about our options. Then he explained the “tasting menu” or the a la carte option. Other than that everything that came out was extremely delicious.
Thomas
First time diner Excellent food and service Had the veal which was excellently prepared. The deserts were amazing as well. Really nice dining room, you don't find tables as spread out that much anymore. Wine list is great however much too expensive in my view Other than that, a great experience overall and we will
Karen
The food was phenomenal as always. Excellent price. Had them pair wines with our courses. Not sure if they show that as an option but Nick did great matches
Neal
Always a wonderful experience. The food prices are very reasonable for quantity and taste. The alcohol is a little on the pricey side.
maria
Incredible experience, romantic and intimate. Very good service and tasty food. Would highly recommend for date night or special occasion.
The best!!! Nick is an impeccable manager and the food is so consistent and delicious. Pastas and sauces are especially fab. Romantic great ambiance. Classic spot, highly recommend for special occasion or just a nice night out!
As usual good food and very cozy restaurant. Menu hasn't changed since god knows how many years !
This was our 3rd time at this restaurant, and the food is always impeccable! It is a must for us to dine here every time we are in NYC!
We had an event in the neighborhood and were searching for a nice restaurant and wow did we find a winner!
Scalini Fedeli was exceptional.
From the moment we walked in the door to the moment we left it was an exceptional dining experience.
The restaurant interior is beautiful, soft vaulted ceilings, comfortable seating and the lighting is just right. We arrived early and were offered a corner booth type table which was perfect for the two of us.
Each course of the fixed price menu was excellent.
We look forward to returning and highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was outstanding and beautifully prepared, the atmosphere was elegant yet comfortable, and every staff member from the front desk to the servers, treated us with such warmth and professionalism. It was truly a memorable evening, and I can't wait to come back again!
It’s as good as it gets. Amazing experience. Best Italian restaurant in NYC. Try the shrimp and lobster pasta!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The kitchen values fresh ingredients while the front of house values fresh approaches. The employees show professionalism. Many different offerings have earned my praise. You'll notice the interesting atmosphere. This place offers something new.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great Italian food. Always fresh good quality meat.
Absolutely delightful culinary experience maintaining its overall charm, quality & style. While most restaurants lose their core essence; this one maintains its originality!
Just enough surprise to keep things interesting. Their employees create an atmosphere of belonging. This place understands flavor. They offer delicious food in an unpretentious setting with attentive staff and happy customers. Visit this place immediately.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The food was extraordinary. The service was a bit weird, being that it was our first time at this restaurant and NY service is mostly excellent, our waiter was kind of serious and not to talkative. They started bringing us courses and we had to stop and ask about our options. Then he explained the “tasting menu” or the a la carte option. Other than that everything that came out was extremely delicious.
First time diner Excellent food and service Had the veal which was excellently prepared. The deserts were amazing as well. Really nice dining room, you don't find tables as spread out that much anymore. Wine list is great however much too expensive in my view Other than that, a great experience overall and we will
The food was phenomenal as always. Excellent price. Had them pair wines with our courses. Not sure if they show that as an option but Nick did great matches
Always a wonderful experience. The food prices are very reasonable for quantity and taste. The alcohol is a little on the pricey side.
Incredible experience, romantic and intimate. Very good service and tasty food. Would highly recommend for date night or special occasion.
Loading...