Food was ok, but the staff is awesome ! Not a bad choice to have a couple drinks , and some bar food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Shepard's Pie
Milton Marshall
I ordered a bacon cheeseburger that was too thick to pick up and eat, and I had to cut it and eat it with a fork. Beer prices were good for happy hour, and the bartender was helpful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallywags Burger
Lynsey Sim
Scallywags NYC thank you for the most amazing experience, great beer 🍺 great company, amazing bar staff (Katherine 😀) and we had the pleasure of meeting the owners who were very welcoming and even bought us a drink 🍺🗽🍀 💯 recommended 😀
Mathieu Dumoulin
It’s a good, standard Irish pub. Very Loud so not ideal to have conversations. Quite packed with good atmosphere. Slow service. NYC prices. Good enough location not too far from Times Square.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 3
Anne Jackson
Great food and the staff are brilliant. Would highly recommend going there. The best Irish bar in New York, but you don`t have to be Irish to go there all welcome
Juan Pablo Reyes
Very good bar!! Good Beers!
Cadillac Jones
Awesome place! The food was great and the hospitality was unmatched. Go say hi to Rose for us. I’ll definitely be back.
Diane Dronzek
Just had a couple of nightcaps. Great Irish bar. Staff is wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Ann Marie Kurasz
This was a great little place. It was pretty busy when we walked in but we were seated at the bar immediately. (By the very cheerful owner, we later found out)The bartender, Catherine, was wonderful. Friendly, great service, quick witted and made a killer drink. We stayed for 3 more and had some nachos while we visited. They were very good. Next time we visit the city, I'm going back to this place. We had a great time with very reasonable. prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan Murray
In from Kansas and saw this bar was near my hotel. I sat at the bar for a drink, so not sure about the food. But the bartender Catherine was the best! She still has the great Irish accent and pours a great drink. Will come back the next time I’m in the city.
Probably my quickest and worst visit to a pub. I took a seat at the bar and ordered a Guinness. The lady bartender asked for my name to open a tab as I handed her my credit card. I politely responded that I didn’t want to keep the tab open and requested she close it immediately.
She asked for my name again, which seemed unnecessary since I wasn’t opening a tab. I repeated my request to close it, assuming she didn’t understand me the first time. At that point, there was no need for her to ask for my name. Right?
After visiting hundreds of bars, I’ve never encountered a situation like this. What happened next was shocking. She looked at me like I was the one being unreasonable, and as I was about to explain myself, she turned away to enter my order into the system. That’s when I noticed she typed my name as “DICK.” She did this almost in front of me, without hesitation. When I asked her, out of curiosity, what she had typed, she responded with, “Guy.” But I clearly saw “D.I.C.K.” on the screen.
I left immediately, not even taking a sip of my beer. I couldn’t help but feel insulted, especially as she seemed to act superior, possibly because of her age compared to mine. While I respect experience and professionalism in bartenders, treating a customer with such disrespect is unacceptable.
I won’t be returning to this bar, and I’d caution others to consider how customers are treated here before visiting.
Service: 1
Megan Justice
Great bartender ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryliss Bod
I have made it a point to eat at Scallywags every time I am in New York. The Irish Meatloaf is divine, the salads are great, and the blackened salmon is so fresh!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Scallywags Burger
Chesdin Yeager
We had such an unexpectedly amazing and pleasant time! We walked across the street from our hotel and were immediately greeted by “Ro” who was friendly from the start and only made our visit more amazing by the minute!!! She showered our 11 year old with absolute celebration and adoration for his birthday weekend visit, and just outdid herself at every turn. I have never experienced someone so generous and she just made our visit the very best. Thank you, Ro! We’ll be making the 3 hour journey back every birthday year now!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tristan Mildenhall
Wonderful lil bar, lovely waitress always making sure we're happy with full bellies of beer and nibblies.
Would come here over and over again if I wasn't flying out tomorrow, top notch place, nice and cheap throughout the day and night, about 7-9USD a drink.
Food was ok, but the staff is awesome !
Not a bad choice to have a couple drinks , and some bar food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Shepard's Pie
I ordered a bacon cheeseburger that was too thick to pick up and eat, and I had to cut it and eat it with a fork. Beer prices were good for happy hour, and the bartender was helpful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallywags Burger
Scallywags NYC thank you for the most amazing experience, great beer 🍺 great company, amazing bar staff (Katherine 😀) and we had the pleasure of meeting the owners who were very welcoming and even bought us a drink 🍺🗽🍀 💯 recommended 😀
It’s a good, standard Irish pub. Very Loud so not ideal to have conversations. Quite packed with good atmosphere. Slow service. NYC prices. Good enough location not too far from Times Square.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 3
Great food and the staff are brilliant. Would highly recommend going there. The best Irish bar in New York, but you don`t have to be Irish to go there all welcome
Very good bar!! Good Beers!
Awesome place! The food was great and the hospitality was unmatched. Go say hi to Rose for us. I’ll definitely be back.
Just had a couple of nightcaps. Great Irish bar. Staff is wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
This was a great little place. It was pretty busy when we walked in but we were seated at the bar immediately. (By the very cheerful owner, we later found out)The bartender, Catherine, was wonderful. Friendly, great service, quick witted and made a killer drink. We stayed for 3 more and had some nachos while we visited. They were very good. Next time we visit the city, I'm going back to this place. We had a great time with very reasonable. prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
In from Kansas and saw this bar was near my hotel. I sat at the bar for a drink, so not sure about the food. But the bartender Catherine was the best! She still has the great Irish accent and pours a great drink. Will come back the next time I’m in the city.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Probably my quickest and worst visit to a pub. I took a seat at the bar and ordered a Guinness. The lady bartender asked for my name to open a tab as I handed her my credit card. I politely responded that I didn’t want to keep the tab open and requested she close it immediately.
She asked for my name again, which seemed unnecessary since I wasn’t opening a tab. I repeated my request to close it, assuming she didn’t understand me the first time. At that point, there was no need for her to ask for my name. Right?
After visiting hundreds of bars, I’ve never encountered a situation like this. What happened next was shocking. She looked at me like I was the one being unreasonable, and as I was about to explain myself, she turned away to enter my order into the system. That’s when I noticed she typed my name as “DICK.” She did this almost in front of me, without hesitation. When I asked her, out of curiosity, what she had typed, she responded with, “Guy.” But I clearly saw “D.I.C.K.” on the screen.
I left immediately, not even taking a sip of my beer. I couldn’t help but feel insulted, especially as she seemed to act superior, possibly because of her age compared to mine. While I respect experience and professionalism in bartenders, treating a customer with such disrespect is unacceptable.
I won’t be returning to this bar, and I’d caution others to consider how customers are treated here before visiting.
Service: 1
Great bartender ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have made it a point to eat at Scallywags every time I am in New York. The Irish Meatloaf is divine, the salads are great, and the blackened salmon is so fresh!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Scallywags Burger
We had such an unexpectedly amazing and pleasant time! We walked across the street from our hotel and were immediately greeted by “Ro” who was friendly from the start and only made our visit more amazing by the minute!!! She showered our 11 year old with absolute celebration and adoration for his birthday weekend visit, and just outdid herself at every turn. I have never experienced someone so generous and she just made our visit the very best. Thank you, Ro! We’ll be making the 3 hour journey back every birthday year now!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful lil bar, lovely waitress always making sure we're happy with full bellies of beer and nibblies.
Would come here over and over again if I wasn't flying out tomorrow, top notch place, nice and cheap throughout the day and night, about 7-9USD a drink.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...