CASA TuLuM NYC
229 Front Street, New York
(212) 433-5800
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
wow this place has a great vibe. new management, new menu, total 180. I'm too full to order any thing else but I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was good, but we didn't think it was anything special. The cocktails followed suit. We had the enchiladas suiza ($26) and cochinita pibil ($32), which seemed like small portions especially considering they didn't come with any sides. A small bowl of rice or beans was $6 each. We asked for hot sauce with our guacamole and were charged $5 for a tiny serving. The bottom line is we felt it was overpriced and ended up with a bill over $200 for the two of us. The atmosphere was cool and the service was great, but overall we were disappointed with our experience.
My friends and I planned to go to dinner at a neighboring place but they were closed for a private event. So we decided to meet here instead. Best. Idea. Ever. I'm picky about Mexican food. I've lived in Mexico. This is some of the best Mexican I've had in the city, hands down. We shared guacamole to start and it was super fresh. I opted for the enchiladas for my main. The sauce was delicious and the chicken tender. My friends had various tacos, rice, and elote. All very well flavored. We shared the churros with Mexican chocolate for dessert. The service was lovely. We met the manager Louis as he made an effort to come over and say hello and welcome us. Apparently they're not even a month old. But I'm certain they'll last for years to come. Buen provecho!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baja Fish Taco, Chicken Enchiladas
Staff were super friendly here but food was average. Portions were small for both cocktails and entree.
The drinks were good. The food was interesting as the menu was recently changed and we couldn't order the stuff we saw on Google. We ordered the lobster caveche and while it was decent, it wasn't as fulfilling as we would have liked it to be.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great atmosphere and delicious.high highly recommend it
Perfect meal outside and lovely staff. Had brunch menu. High quality ingredients and perfectly cooked steak with my very orange eggs.
Nice Seafood Selection, especially the octopus salad, gotta try it!
tldr: eating here ruined my night, and I would not recommend this place if you have any sort of food allergens.
I have celiac, so the first thing I did was confirm what gluten free options they had. I was told that they had a gf gnocci and ordered it, stressing once again that it needed to be gluten free. The place was pretty empty for a Saturday night, so the food came out fast.
My date and I stayed a while after finishing, and everything was going good until it suddenly wasn’t. A feeling of sickness struck my entire body, and I barely had time to make it to the bathroom. After fighting for my life on the toilet, I asked one of the waiters if he was sure that the food I ate was definitely gluten free because the brain fog, dizzyness, and joint pain I was starting to feel was telling me otherwise. Surprise! It wasn’t.
The manager apologized, refunded (only) my meal, and offered to give me a voucher for a free one if I came back…which I definitely won’t considering their food poisoned me. My date and I had an entire night of plans and reservations for the rest of the night that I unfortunately wasn’t able to go to. Instead, I had to head straight home to wait out the sickness that was only getting worse. Thankfully the Uber drive I took was willing to pull over when I started vomiting.
I really would not recommend this place if you have ANY sort of food allergies because seriously, what if I had a gluten allergy instead of celiac and ended up asphyxiating? It literally could be life threatening. It’s not even like they had to change the recipe. They have a gluten free alternative, but I was straight up given the dish that has it. If they can’t handle that, I really wouldn’t trust them with much else.
Anyways, I’m still waiting to feel better, but I definitely regret eating here. Save yourself the trouble and eat literally anywhere else (I wish I did).
Great new Mexican restaurant at the Seaport. Aquachile was amazing. Will definitely go back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Attention was good and the aesthetic, chill, Cancún environment i loved it But in terms of food the pollo borracho was kinda dry and unflavored and the enchiladas verdes the recipe could be better.
Love it. So cute. Great custom cocktails
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this restaurant vibe and the food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crispy skin duck with dark chocolate mole was outstanding. Great drinks and service as well. Excellent addition to Front St!
Amazing
Loading...