SHOGUN OMAKASE | Manhattan Sushi Restaurant

I had been eager to try this place after reading the reviews, especially the omakase box to-go, which is on the pricier side at $68. Finally, I made a reservation with a friend for her birthday, and they kindly gifted her a can of sake, which was a nice touch.

Unfortunately, the experience was underwhelming and a bit of a letdown. It felt like they were trying too hard, focusing more on elaborate toppings than on the quality of the fish itself. The toppings didn't complement the fish well, and the combination felt forced, detracting from the overall authenticity of the meal. I wasn't surprised to learn that the restaurant is Chinese/Taiwanese-owned rather than Japanese.

We opted for the $150 omakase set B, which includes 19 courses--four appetizers, 11 pieces of nigiri, uni rice, a wagyu tasting, a hand roll, and dessert. The crab and lobster appetizers seemed frozen, and the lobster was overcooked and tough. The oyster appetizer, loaded with fish eggs, cucumber, and way too much mayonnaise, was overwhelming and unbalanced. The wagyu tasting was fine, though the chef recommended pairing it with cucumber to balance the flavors, alongside some strawberries. I didn't really get the idea behind that pairing--it felt unnecessary. The wagyu would have been fine on its own with foie gras, fish roe, and uni, without the added distractions.

The nigiri pieces were decent, but none of them stood out as particularly memorable.

At this price point, the meal is certainly a good value, but I wouldn't return. It seems they tried to be innovative with the flavors and combinations, but in doing so, they sacrificed authenticity and the natural taste of the fish. It felt overdone.

Nice affordable omakase in manhattan!

The service was impeccable—attentive yet unobtrusive, While it’s certainly a splurge, every bite was worth it. This is the kind of meal you book for a special occasion… or simply to treat yourself to something extraordinary.

Amazing Omakase experience! Every dish was fresh, beautifully presented, and full of flavor. The chef’s attention to detail and passion really stood out. Great atmosphere and top-notch service. One of the best meals I’ve had—highly recommend!

Good entry in the <$100 omakase category. If all you need is a cheaper sushi fix with a standard offering then this spot will likely fill the need. But it’s hard to stand out in this category as NYC is completely saturated with affordable options. My category leaders here are Korami and thirteen water. Shogun will search the itch and still better than the recent surge of AYCE spots which are generally terrible. Verdict: would return to satisfy a craving on short notice assuming I can’t find a resy anywhere else.

Loved it. Sat at the bar.
Very friendly chef. Coming back
For sure!

Amazing omakase. Really good value. I went for the option b and it was all incredible

Food were delicious and service was great. Price is reasonable as well.

This is a clear, traditional Japanese style restaurant, a great choice for sushi lovers. I enjoyed their authentic dishes very much.

Fantastic omakase. Worth every penny.

Beautiful experience! Sat at the counter and had the most phenomenal 12 course meal! Definitely coming back and recommending this to everyone!

Great all around. Generous servings, luxurious ingredients and fresh fish all within reasonable price. Would come back!

I came here for the 19-course omakase dinner to celebrate a friend’s birthday. Our reservations were originally for 7:45 PM, but they seated us early when we arrived at 7:12 PM. I love how this restaurant offers table seating for those who prefer more privacy instead of the counter. The table seating definitely allows for a more intimate experience while still enjoying everything the restaurant has to offer.

The sushi was fresh and delicious, and I especially loved the A5 Wagyu, which just melted in my mouth. The dessert was just as amazing as the dinner, and they ended the night by providing a thoughtful birthday gift to the birthday celebrant, which was such a nice touch.

On a non-food-related note, I want to mention that I visited the bathroom, and it was nice and clean, which I really appreciated after having such a great dinner. I don’t think there was anything I disliked about this place. Even the waitstaff was attentive, which made the experience all the more enjoyable.

We had an amazing experience at Shogun! The omakase was really good, the fishes were fresh and the rice was perfect. Chef Ryan makes the experience even more pleasant and delightful! Hope to come back soon!

This place was AMAZING! Delicious food, kind service, but Chef Donj (aka Ryan) was SPECTACULAR! We went for our anniversary and they made it so special. We will be back!