Sicily Osteria

330 W 46th St, New York
(646) 609-3417

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Timothy

Excellent food, probably the best Italian food I've had, however in addition to putting it was a Birthday Celebration on the reservation and ALSO telling our waiter, who said they could accommodate with candles etc, nothing was done when desserts were delivered and they dropped the ball on that. Otherwise, great food and service.

Mary Ellen

Came here for a pre-show dinner and we were not disappointed. I ordered Chicken Polletto and my husband had the Pollo Parmigiano. Both were cooked perfectly and delicious! The parmigiano came with a side of spaghetti which was al dente with a lovely marinara. the polletto came with vegetables all in a tasty lemon caper sauce. I had also ordered a Capri Crush cocktail which was delicious and a macchiato coffee to finish the meal. My only complaint would be that the drinks were over-priced in my opinion. The cocktail was $18 and the coffee $6.50. For the price I was expecting a larger cup of coffee and what I got was what looked like a tiny cup of espresso which I could finish in one gulp. Overall though, it was a wonderful meal and I would definitely go back.

Ali

Nice place for after-show dinner. Staff warm and welcoming. Appetizers good. Mains okay. Prices reasonable

joe

Hood was very good. So was the service. Loved the eggplant parm, the grilled artichoke with burrata, and the chicken parm. The bread and EVOO WAS DELICIOUS. The only problem was the noise level. Too much.

John

food was very good vermentino wine was excellent service was also very good if i am back in the theatre district again would definitely revisit

Ruth

We were expecting the brunch menu as shown on the website but there was a standard menu. Perfectly wonderful. Great vegetarian choices as well as hearty meat dishes. All prepared and presented beautifully. The restaurant is much larger than it initially appears but still feels like a local trattoria in Italy. Our waiter was friendly and helpful without being intrusive. We had a lovely lunch and hope to return soon.

Stefan

Great drinks and food. No wait with reservation. Quick, attentive service. Highly recommend.

Teodora

Extremely loud! Could barely hear my friend. Also I had the salmon with spinach and potatoes which was disappointing. I could not chew the spinach and the salmon was nothing to boast about either.

Emily

The most beautiful lemon dessert I have ever seen! It was almost too pretty to eat! Service was lovely and the rest of the meal was wonderful. In and out in time for our show.

Wendy

Wouldn't seat us outdoors. Tried to seat us in loud area; we asked for a quieter spot (with my 88 YO grandmother) and got seated next to restroom. Asked for linguini - got spaghetti. Not a good experience.

Leonard

Excellent traditional food and solid service. Perfect spot for a relaxed dinner before a show.

Tulio

Muy amable y rápida atención, de las entradas lo mejor el pulpo y la burrata, las pastas muy buenas, para mi amigo a la entraña le faltaba un poco de sal, el postre homenaje a Nueva York excelente, nos dieron limoncelo de cortesía, recomendable 100%

Kari

We had a lovely classic Italian dinner with tortellini, clam linguini, spaghetti, pizza, and great wine. Roberto our server was charming and helpful, the location was quiet and historic. Overall, a great value and meal! We highly recommend.

Judith

Great food and great service in a very convenient location. Portion sizes were just right, so we could enjoy dessert. Would definitely go again

Gaby

Hi - unfortunately we didn't order the best entree. The bread and Brussel sprouts were delicious, but the pasta alla Norma was barely edible. It was like it was thrown together and then some grated cheese that wasn't even melted was tossed on top of it. Super disappointing. We looked at other diners and they were having quite a different experience -

Loading...