Smithereens

414 E 9th St, New York

Recent Reviews Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Lobster Roll

Photos

+11 photos

+10 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Limited selection of fresh seafood. The halibut was delicious and the wine was served at the appropriate temperature which is rare in nyc. The service was spot on and I look forward to going back

November 2025

Food was good. Not every dish was a homerun, but still pretty good. My only issue was the kitchen/bar seating is very cramped and uncomfortable, and the service was good but didn’t standout for the price point.

October 2025

Echoing what a lot of other reviewers have said unfortunately smithereens has a serious problem with their culture and service. I took my sister for her birthday and our server was rude and aloof the second we sat down. The food itself was phenomenal, standouts in no particular order were - The buckwheat pancake with blue fish, The rice with clams, and The Halibut.

All in all I wouldn’t go back or recommend this spot to anyone looking for a joyful time. Service...

October 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in New York, NY

Smithereens

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Smithereens