Smithereens
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Roll
Menu
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Such fun and unexpected food. We had only 3 dishes: fish head terrine, lentils with eel and whole mackerel. Great preparation and seasoning. Didn’t go for any of the limited dessert offerings. Space is rather dull. Staff and server were delightful. Recommend thus restaurant for adventurous pescatarians
One of the top five dining experiences of my entire life. This establishment should win accolades. I am blown away. Besides their outrageous food and impossible wine list, the customer service brought my girlfriend and me to tears upon reflection our entire way home. They made us feel like celebrities for just a 26th birthday dinner, even suggesting we taste a special wine that was bottled 26 years ago. A true delight. Run, don’t walk.
Just Okay; Food was pretty bland—nothing really stood out. The kitchen counter seating is a no-go: hot, super loud, and uncomfortable. Feels more like sitting in a workshop than a restaurant. Overall, not terrible, just not worth a second visit.
You May Also Like
Whitmans - 406 E 9th St
![]()
American, Burgers, Hamburger, Vegetarian
Cafe Mogador - 101 St Marks Pl
![]()
Moroccan, Middle Eastern, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Thursday Kitchen - 424 E 9th St
![]()
Korean, American, Tapas/Small Plates, New American, Vegan