I ordered delivery, the square chicken parmesan pizza and chicken parmesan calzones. The square pizza was absolutely delish, tasted fresh, was a perfect temputure with a nice crunchy crust. I highly recommend. I only take away one star from total review because the calzones were a bit toasty almost burnt in some areas. I can only guess that maybe the calzones were baked too close to the sides of the oven or left in there too long? Oh yes and I also ordered garlic knots. The garlic knots were soo good, fresh minced garlic, delicious. The order came in less than one hour on a Saturday night which is amazing.I would love to visit in person to rate the atmosphere, etc and to give the calzones another try. I plan to update this review once I go in person.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pies, Garlic Knots
Space Dandy
Delicious pizza, reasonable prices, and quick service. The plain slice is thin and crispy with a well-balance between the cheese and sauce. Highly recommend stopping by and trying the plain slice. Cash and credit are both accepted. ATM is available. Metered street parking, but it is a busy area and difficult to find parking. 12/2023
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pie
Rahul V.
amazing service and very nice man behind the counter always happy. best pizza I have ever had
Keith Irizarry
The only vegan pizza my son will eat is offered here. Love this place so much. I only wish there was an option to order online a vegan cheese pizza, but this is close enough to pick up luckily. Great customer service also as I was paranoid of the vegan cheese actually being vegan. It tastes so good that it worries me,actually. Highly recommend and a big thank you to the boss man of this place.Vegetarian options: Vegan friendly.Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pies
Roderick A. Jr
I stop by like once a Month. Its GREAT
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley L.
Not the best NY pizza that you will find, but when you have had a few drinks and want a snack before bed, you might think it. Perfect crunch on the bottom, delicious and flavorful sauces. Lots of varieties to try from (buffalo chicken, pepperoni, cheese, margarita, you name it)Have had both the normal cheese and pepperoni slices, but tried the cauliflower last night and it honestly surprised me. Delicious and great texture!
Joanna L.
what we ordered:$5 per slice buffalo chicken margarita chicken parm lasagna .this is one of the crispiest pizza ive ever had! you can definitely hear the crunch when you bite into it. flavors are great and super fresh too. love that it's thin crusted too. overall, really great spot and will definitely be frequenting here if i ever crave pizza.
Benjamin Jones
Pizza’s meh - kinda gagged trying to get it down - typical end to LES night…just wouldn’t come here for the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Catherine C.
I'm so grateful to Square Pizza being open late into the night/morning. This has become one of my most visited pizza establishments in NYC because of its convenience, variety/ scrumptiousness of each slice, and friendliness of the staff. Let's start with the most important topic- the PIZZA! I have only arrived to this establishment after midnight and often they do not have all of the pizzas that are on the menu out for purchase- literally what you see is what you can get. However, you can't go wrong because all of their pizzas have been DELICIOUS. I love that the staff is so friendly, even in the wee hours of the morning. They have always been accommodating to my friend and I who insist on adding hot honey to whichever slice we order. This pizza establishment needs to be on your list of places to go to when it is late at night. After trying many that are open past midnight, this is the one I seek out. Make sure you put it on your list.
Randall H.
As good a NY slice as I've ever had. $2.50 for a "regular" (cheese) slice. The crust was the perfect NY firm bottom and the sauce was the star. The service was fast and friendly. It's a take out place with a few seats and is bright and welcoming.
10/10 spot to grab a slice late at night, I mean look how good that looks. Midnight pizza always hits the spot.
Nora E
I love this place! I live in PA and am not in NYC often, but I make it a point to stop here every time I come in. Thin crust, crispy and tasty…awesome!! My personal favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza and my husband loves the Margarita.
Julia Curtis
truthfully one of the best (if not the best) slices in nyc and i eat a lot of pizza
S J
This may honestly be the worst slice in NYC. I am appalled by how bad this pizza is. Tastes like frozen pizza. Never again.
Thomas Jefferson
Very good service, quick and tasty! I can get a slice or 2 in 1 minute, and a whole pie in 6! Best tasting pizza I've almost ever had, crust is good and always is hot. Only bad thing about it is that it's insanely greasy, but the give plates.
I ordered delivery, the square chicken parmesan pizza and chicken parmesan calzones. The square pizza was absolutely delish, tasted fresh, was a perfect temputure with a nice crunchy crust. I highly recommend. I only take away one star from total review because the calzones were a bit toasty almost burnt in some areas. I can only guess that maybe the calzones were baked too close to the sides of the oven or left in there too long? Oh yes and I also ordered garlic knots. The garlic knots were soo good, fresh minced garlic, delicious. The order came in less than one hour on a Saturday night which is amazing.I would love to visit in person to rate the atmosphere, etc and to give the calzones another try. I plan to update this review once I go in person.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pies, Garlic Knots
Delicious pizza, reasonable prices, and quick service. The plain slice is thin and crispy with a well-balance between the cheese and sauce. Highly recommend stopping by and trying the plain slice. Cash and credit are both accepted. ATM is available. Metered street parking, but it is a busy area and difficult to find parking. 12/2023
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pie
amazing service and very nice man behind the counter always happy. best pizza I have ever had
The only vegan pizza my son will eat is offered here. Love this place so much. I only wish there was an option to order online a vegan cheese pizza, but this is close enough to pick up luckily. Great customer service also as I was paranoid of the vegan cheese actually being vegan. It tastes so good that it worries me,actually. Highly recommend and a big thank you to the boss man of this place.Vegetarian options: Vegan friendly.Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pies
I stop by like once a Month. Its GREAT
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not the best NY pizza that you will find, but when you have had a few drinks and want a snack before bed, you might think it. Perfect crunch on the bottom, delicious and flavorful sauces. Lots of varieties to try from (buffalo chicken, pepperoni, cheese, margarita, you name it)Have had both the normal cheese and pepperoni slices, but tried the cauliflower last night and it honestly surprised me. Delicious and great texture!
what we ordered:$5 per slice buffalo chicken margarita chicken parm lasagna .this is one of the crispiest pizza ive ever had! you can definitely hear the crunch when you bite into it. flavors are great and super fresh too. love that it's thin crusted too. overall, really great spot and will definitely be frequenting here if i ever crave pizza.
Pizza’s meh - kinda gagged trying to get it down - typical end to LES night…just wouldn’t come here for the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
I'm so grateful to Square Pizza being open late into the night/morning. This has become one of my most visited pizza establishments in NYC because of its convenience, variety/ scrumptiousness of each slice, and friendliness of the staff. Let's start with the most important topic- the PIZZA! I have only arrived to this establishment after midnight and often they do not have all of the pizzas that are on the menu out for purchase- literally what you see is what you can get. However, you can't go wrong because all of their pizzas have been DELICIOUS. I love that the staff is so friendly, even in the wee hours of the morning. They have always been accommodating to my friend and I who insist on adding hot honey to whichever slice we order. This pizza establishment needs to be on your list of places to go to when it is late at night. After trying many that are open past midnight, this is the one I seek out. Make sure you put it on your list.
As good a NY slice as I've ever had. $2.50 for a "regular" (cheese) slice. The crust was the perfect NY firm bottom and the sauce was the star. The service was fast and friendly. It's a take out place with a few seats and is bright and welcoming.
Restaurantji Recommends
10/10 spot to grab a slice late at night, I mean look how good that looks. Midnight pizza always hits the spot.
I love this place! I live in PA and am not in NYC often, but I make it a point to stop here every time I come in. Thin crust, crispy and tasty…awesome!! My personal favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza and my husband loves the Margarita.
truthfully one of the best (if not the best) slices in nyc and i eat a lot of pizza
This may honestly be the worst slice in NYC. I am appalled by how bad this pizza is. Tastes like frozen pizza. Never again.
Very good service, quick and tasty! I can get a slice or 2 in 1 minute, and a whole pie in 6! Best tasting pizza I've almost ever had, crust is good and always is hot. Only bad thing about it is that it's insanely greasy, but the give plates.