I don't doubt that the proprietor is an incredible chef, but I feel that with his pizza there is a lack of balance, as he chooses to chase maximising flavors. I've tried both this location and the new slice shop in Brooklyn and I felt the same both times.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Max
waaaay better than the other location
AstroGalaxy
Yummers
Saloni G
The place was nicely decorated and the pizza & garlic bread were both great. We got the Old Town pizza with a couple of dipping sauces which went really great together, especially the Stretch sauce. I wish they gave more sauce with the garlic bread but they’re probably trying to get you to buy the larger ones, which we did end up getting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Varuna
Was so excited to go here because my friend and I both wanted pizza and this place had great reviews
Unfortunately the service was so bad that a good pizza didn’t make up for it at all
It started when my friend asked for the marinara sauce that came with the garlic bread to be warmed up. It was ice cold. The lady who later identified herself as the manager said she wasn’t sure she could do it! This place is a restaurant. They can’t heat a small bowl of marinara sauce?
Then when it came to dessert I wanted the chocolate ice cream but asked her not to add the whipped cream and marshmallows that she said she added on top! I didn’t understand why and she said it’s because she was told that’s how they did it. Again I wanted her to give me chocolate ice cream and not put the whipped cream or Marshmallows on top. These desserts are not pre made. She comes back after 3 minutes and says she checked with the head chef and he said it was okay to not put the toppings on the ice cream!
This is the manager of the place!
We paid our bill and walked out - without dessert.
So disappointed and of course will not go back here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Sohum Daftary
Pickle pizza was incredible. Dips were not.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
MARK ONDRACEK
Ordered two signature pizzas to go. Got two small mediums for $60+. Just pathetic
Javier Kohen
Very good pizza, loved the toga party. The squash appetizer was pretty good, too, and the apple pie on a pizza slice with cheese pretty cool l, but the soft serve stole the dessert show, because of its complex flavor.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris P
Excellent pizza, some of the best we’ve had in Manhattan. The menu also includes delicious Italian non-pizza options. There is also a full bar.
Service was also friendly and attentive.
Nice spot for a sit down lunch/dinner or just a slice and a drink at the bar.
Nice small place. The buffalo pizza was very great! We just ordered pizza and waited for it. Friendly staff offered water while we were waiting. Pizza place is part of Resy so we could use the Amex Plat Resy credit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Aaron Minsky
Date night for 2, more like date night for 1. Portions were too small to really enjoy. Ordered 2 appetizers and a pizza and left feeling hungry and wanting more. We won’t be back.
Asch
Love the pizza, love the square pie, fantastic service and yummy food. I finally found a new york style pizza that I loved!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cody Gahol
This spot offers delicious pies at a good price. The crust is the star of the show on both their round and square pies! We tried the Classic Cheese, Al Pastor, and the Buffalo Chicken Square.
My favorite was the Buffalo Chicken Square the crust had a crispy undercarriage, soft and fluffy middle. The blue cheese was the perfect complement.
The Classic Cheese and Al Pastor were also delicious, featuring an extra crispy crust that had no flop. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yu-San Huoh
Don't understand why there isn't a line out the door. This is seriously great pizza! Never had anything quite like it. Great cocktails on draft too!
I don't doubt that the proprietor is an incredible chef, but I feel that with his pizza there is a lack of balance, as he chooses to chase maximising flavors. I've tried both this location and the new slice shop in Brooklyn and I felt the same both times.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
waaaay better than the other location
Yummers
The place was nicely decorated and the pizza & garlic bread were both great. We got the Old Town pizza with a couple of dipping sauces which went really great together, especially the Stretch sauce. I wish they gave more sauce with the garlic bread but they’re probably trying to get you to buy the larger ones, which we did end up getting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Was so excited to go here because my friend and I both wanted pizza and this place had great reviews
Unfortunately the service was so bad that a good pizza didn’t make up for it at all
It started when my friend asked for the marinara sauce that came with the garlic bread to be warmed up. It was ice cold. The lady who later identified herself as the manager said she wasn’t sure she could do it! This place is a restaurant. They can’t heat a small bowl of marinara sauce?
Then when it came to dessert I wanted the chocolate ice cream but asked her not to add the whipped cream and marshmallows that she said she added on top! I didn’t understand why and she said it’s because she was told that’s how they did it. Again I wanted her to give me chocolate ice cream and not put the whipped cream or Marshmallows on top. These desserts are not pre made. She comes back after 3 minutes and says she checked with the head chef and he said it was okay to not put the toppings on the ice cream!
This is the manager of the place!
We paid our bill and walked out - without dessert.
So disappointed and of course will not go back here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Pickle pizza was incredible. Dips were not.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ordered two signature pizzas to go. Got two small mediums for $60+. Just pathetic
Very good pizza, loved the toga party. The squash appetizer was pretty good, too, and the apple pie on a pizza slice with cheese pretty cool l, but the soft serve stole the dessert show, because of its complex flavor.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza, some of the best we’ve had in Manhattan. The menu also includes delicious Italian non-pizza options. There is also a full bar.
Service was also friendly and attentive.
Nice spot for a sit down lunch/dinner or just a slice and a drink at the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So good! That potato chip salad is epic!
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice small place. The buffalo pizza was very great! We just ordered pizza and waited for it. Friendly staff offered water while we were waiting. Pizza place is part of Resy so we could use the Amex Plat Resy credit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Date night for 2, more like date night for 1. Portions were too small to really enjoy. Ordered 2 appetizers and a pizza and left feeling hungry and wanting more. We won’t be back.
Love the pizza, love the square pie, fantastic service and yummy food. I finally found a new york style pizza that I loved!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This spot offers delicious pies at a good price. The crust is the star of the show on both their round and square pies! We tried the Classic Cheese, Al Pastor, and the Buffalo Chicken Square.
My favorite was the Buffalo Chicken Square the crust had a crispy undercarriage, soft and fluffy middle. The blue cheese was the perfect complement.
The Classic Cheese and Al Pastor were also delicious, featuring an extra crispy crust that had no flop. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don't understand why there isn't a line out the door. This is seriously great pizza! Never had anything quite like it. Great cocktails on draft too!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...