Incredible experience eating in a small room that felt like a relative's house. The food was outstanding, comforting, Italian food everything full of flavor excellent night.
Henry
All the food is consistently delicious. My only issue is that many of the dishes are not available all days.
Kari
Portions huge but that's not the most important thing for me. Had mixed green salad for 1 (you order salad pp) with added buff mozz. Fresh but $30?? (1slice of mozz cut in 2. Pasta aglio e olio was fine. The garlic slices in the dish were not fresh. Def pre cut. The risotto was undercooked. Mini veal meatballs were the star. 1 and done for us
Cindi
Really nice vibe, friendly staff and delicious food! Loved the fennel salad and the angel hair pomodoro!
Tim
Food was excellent. Had a great table to accommodate our party of 7. Noise levels between music and guests were good! We could easily talk to each other without having to yell. Food runners and bus boys were very nice. Our main server was just okay. Food orders were accurate and everything came out on time and hot. However, our server was very short with us and kind of rude. I've eaten at other Frank-related restaurants and never had a problem with servers before. I'll chalk it up to a bad night for them. Overall, a great place, though.
Gretchen
We thoroughly enjoyed everything. The service, wine and food. Will return next time we're in New York. Thank you!
Jacob C
Everything is good
Sophia Cohen
I went to Supper for a friend’s birthday dinner. They were able to accommodate our table of 8 easily. We started with drinks and appetizers for the table, which all came quickly and were delicious. Most of us ordered their signature pasta - spaghetti al limone, which was excellent and would highly recommend!!! We all had clean plates by the end of the meal. Great vegetarian options. Note this restaurant is cash only, so come prepared. But there is an ATM on site.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Giancarlo Martins
Pretty average all round. The place’s Description alludes to it being authentic northern Italian, but in reality it was an Americanized version of that. The food was tasty but I wouldn’t bother visiting again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Daniel Venegoni
Went on a Friday night for special occasion. Group of 7. Sat in the back room. It’s well decorated. Food is large portions. Consider splitting an entree. Ask to see the wine list before ordering the wine because they will steer you towards the more expensive wines. The food was great. Everyone had a great time. The only bad part was the cash only. Our groups bill was $700 plus tip. That’s too much cash to expect people to carry around. They took a charge card to hold the reservation? At this price point I have to call bullshit on not accepting charge cards.
Standard Italian fanfare, good not great, but big portions
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Berny Contreras
LEMON PASTA IS TO DIE FOR!!! You gotta try this if you’re going here. Chicken parm was outstanding. Service was awesome. Thank you to the cooks and servers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Caldari
Great food. Fun staff and music.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Bolognese
Tudor Leriu
Just to be clear upfront, I did not eat here so I can't speak for the quality of the food but the only reason I didn't is because this is the only spot I've visited in this city where paying by card was allegedly not possible (cash only). Not only is this very backwards for such a big city where even some homeless people accept digital payments but it's also suspicious, especially when, upon insisting we could not pay cash, we were offered to use a card anyway but with a 3% tax for the "convenience". Maybe this is a lovely spot for locals to gather together and socialise but I will never know because for a lowly tourist with a bank card, it's quite a deal-breaker. In the end it was all a blessing in disguise as it forced us to try another Italian restaurant nearby which blew all of our socks off.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 3
Linda Louise
The food was fantastic! Note it was cash only. This limited what we ordered since it was apparent when we made our reservation. It was a bit loud inside. But the lighting and friendliness of the staff was absolutely delightful. Loooved the lemon pasta. The pesto gnocchi was also very good! And the Monday risotto was fabulous! Note some items on the menu were day specific. Overall, very tasty! We will go again!
Incredible experience eating in a small room that felt like a relative's house. The food was outstanding, comforting, Italian food everything full of flavor excellent night.
All the food is consistently delicious. My only issue is that many of the dishes are not available all days.
Portions huge but that's not the most important thing for me. Had mixed green salad for 1 (you order salad pp) with added buff mozz. Fresh but $30?? (1slice of mozz cut in 2. Pasta aglio e olio was fine. The garlic slices in the dish were not fresh. Def pre cut. The risotto was undercooked. Mini veal meatballs were the star. 1 and done for us
Really nice vibe, friendly staff and delicious food! Loved the fennel salad and the angel hair pomodoro!
Food was excellent. Had a great table to accommodate our party of 7. Noise levels between music and guests were good! We could easily talk to each other without having to yell. Food runners and bus boys were very nice. Our main server was just okay. Food orders were accurate and everything came out on time and hot. However, our server was very short with us and kind of rude. I've eaten at other Frank-related restaurants and never had a problem with servers before. I'll chalk it up to a bad night for them. Overall, a great place, though.
We thoroughly enjoyed everything. The service, wine and food. Will return next time we're in New York. Thank you!
Everything is good
I went to Supper for a friend’s birthday dinner. They were able to accommodate our table of 8 easily.
We started with drinks and appetizers for the table, which all came quickly and were delicious. Most of us ordered their signature pasta - spaghetti al limone, which was excellent and would highly recommend!!! We all had clean plates by the end of the meal. Great vegetarian options.
Note this restaurant is cash only, so come prepared. But there is an ATM on site.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pretty average all round. The place’s Description alludes to it being authentic northern Italian, but in reality it was an Americanized version of that.
The food was tasty but I wouldn’t bother visiting again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Went on a Friday night for special occasion. Group of 7. Sat in the back room. It’s well decorated. Food is large portions. Consider splitting an entree. Ask to see the wine list before ordering the wine because they will steer you towards the more expensive wines. The food was great. Everyone had a great time. The only bad part was the cash only. Our groups bill was $700 plus tip. That’s too much cash to expect people to carry around. They took a charge card to hold the reservation? At this price point I have to call bullshit on not accepting charge cards.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Standard Italian fanfare, good not great, but big portions
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
LEMON PASTA IS TO DIE FOR!!! You gotta try this if you’re going here. Chicken parm was outstanding. Service was awesome. Thank you to the cooks and servers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food. Fun staff and music.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Bolognese
Just to be clear upfront, I did not eat here so I can't speak for the quality of the food but the only reason I didn't is because this is the only spot I've visited in this city where paying by card was allegedly not possible (cash only). Not only is this very backwards for such a big city where even some homeless people accept digital payments but it's also suspicious, especially when, upon insisting we could not pay cash, we were offered to use a card anyway but with a 3% tax for the "convenience". Maybe this is a lovely spot for locals to gather together and socialise but I will never know because for a lowly tourist with a bank card, it's quite a deal-breaker. In the end it was all a blessing in disguise as it forced us to try another Italian restaurant nearby which blew all of our socks off.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 3
The food was fantastic! Note it was cash only. This limited what we ordered since it was apparent when we made our reservation. It was a bit loud inside. But the lighting and friendliness of the staff was absolutely delightful.
Loooved the lemon pasta. The pesto gnocchi was also very good! And the Monday risotto was fabulous!
Note some items on the menu were day specific. Overall, very tasty! We will go again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto
Loading...