Surreal Creamery

538 2nd Ave, New York
(646) 455-0093

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ray

Not even worth a dollar.

Peter Radziwon

Great place! I don’t know why Apple Maps does not show this location on my phone. I will definitely stop by in the future to try more flavors!

aman narsaria

If I were to die and the only thing that can save me is boba from Surreal Creamery, I would rather die

Jessica Heller

Hidden gem - staff is super friendly and the Boba tea and ice cream is amazing !! Love this spot

Andrew Oleniach

Got the cake jar sampler pack for a gathering. Took about a 20 minute drive, and they were refrigerated after arrival for probably 2 hours. When we opened them, the frosting in half the jars was liquid. Like colored water. $50 and half the pack was unedible.

Corey Won

The Earl Grey was disappointing and was just vanilla ice cream in a jar with some cereal sprinkled on it. I'd rather buy a tub from trader joes for 5 bucks than spend 12 dollars here. Cashier seemed like he wanted to die. Went to Trader Joe's to buy toilet paper after buying a jar from here and the toilet paper was so much more amusing than the jar that I forgot I left the jar on the toilet paper rack where it belonged. I gave it two stars because it was next to Trader Joes, if TJ was not there it would be 1 star.

Erica

Delicious! Taro milk tea with a matcha taro twist on top. Great service, great servings, very happy

Katie Greco

We love surreal and miss it now that it moved away from our area. No other ice cream place has the unique flavors and combinations of Surreal. The Earl grey Vietnamese coffee or the Matcha and Tarro flavors are the best.

Urgent Care

No better than mister softee but at 4x the price. Not worth it. Hottest day of year and it’s empty. Should have known

Randall Stempler

Good soft serve, especially the chocolate. Friendly service.

David Gómez Sánchez

Way overpriced, nothing special and they don't ask you for basic stuff like the level of sweetness that you'd like

Lydia Pitea

The ice cream looked amazing, but the shop is not in the best area... It has tons of garbage cans blocking most of the store front so it didn't even look open. We went inside and the clerk never greeted us or asked if we were ready to order... We just stood there for a while and decided to leave.

Also there is NO SEATING. For anyone who is mobility challenged, has small kiddos, or elderly folks with them.

Isabella Grandic

Massive boba ice cream. Very sweet. It’s best through the straw vs eating the ice cream on its own. The earl grey ice cream was pretty subtle - slightly too subtle for me.

Cassia A

When I laid eyes ok this I thought it was gonna be gross. But it’s actually good!!! The early grey rice cream with brown sugar milk tea is pretty fire. Great combo.
The ice cream itself is really silky and satisfying.
It’s just so. Big. They should have a small size, imo. Three of us couldn’t finish it all together.
There’s room to stand but no where to sit.
Solid spot for soft serve.

Karly S

This place is pretty good, the bubble tea and flotea are decently priced, they taste good, it's a big serving. But, the ice cream alone is SUPER overpriced, a tiny cup for $8? NEVER get the ice cream, get the floatea instead, more icecream plus bubble tea for only $2 more is much better

Loading...