Surreal Creamery
538 2nd Ave, New York
(646) 455-0093
Customers' Favorites
Nom Nom Cookie Mason Jar Special
Taro Bubble Tea Matcha Taro
Bubble Tea & Ice Cream
Earl Grey Everyday
Taro Matcha Swirl
My Birthday Cake
Matcha Ice Cream
Biscoff Cookies
Taro Ice Cream
Cookie Monster
Menu
Photos
+40 photos
+39 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We love surreal and miss it now that it moved away from our area. No other ice cream place has the unique flavors and combinations of Surreal. The Earl grey Vietnamese coffee or the Matcha and Tarro flavors are the best.
The ice cream looked amazing, but the shop is not in the best area... It has tons of garbage cans blocking most of the store front so it didn't even look open. We went inside and the clerk never greeted us or asked if we were ready to order... We just stood there for a while and decided to leave.
Also there is NO SEATING. For anyone who is mobility challenged, has small kiddos, or elderly folks with them.
Also there is NO SEATING. For anyone who is mobility challenged, has small kiddos, or elderly folks with them.
When I laid eyes ok this I thought it was gonna be gross. But it’s actually good!!! The early grey rice cream with brown sugar milk tea is pretty fire. Great combo.
The ice cream itself is really silky and satisfying.
It’s just so. Big. They should have a small size, imo. Three of us couldn’t finish it all together.
There’s room to stand but no where to sit.
Solid spot for soft serve.
The ice cream itself is really silky and satisfying.
It’s just so. Big. They should have a small size, imo. Three of us couldn’t finish it all together.
There’s room to stand but no where to sit.
Solid spot for soft serve.
You May Also Like
The Crooked Knife - 540 2nd Ave
![]()
Bar, Gastropubs
Fáilte - 531 2nd Ave
![]()
Pubs, Irish, Irish Pub