Sushi Sushi

1504 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 866-7876

Recent Reviews

MIN

I mean, the atmosphere is pretty decent, but the food is terrible. We paid $60 for 3 rolls, and all the rice was ice cold. The fish tasted very fishy; I think it was frozen and not fresh. After barely finishing the meal, we felt like throwing up all day. If you're just trying to have a quick lunch or enjoy good sushi, avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Dusk Music

I bought sushi here, three rolls for 60 for three people (18 yuan per roll). There was no price written on the menu. After eating, my friend and I found our stomachs very uncomfortable and started to feel nauseous and vomited. This store is just expensive and the quality is not good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tina Zhu

Very disappointed. I came back due to a previous decent experience dining in the restaurant. This time I got the lunch special for take-out. There are options for either 2 rolls or 3 rolls with miso soup, or a six-piece sushi nigiri set with miso soup (I went with this option: ~$15 after tax). I chose 2pc of each salmon, striped bass, and tuna.The only redeeming quality was the fish, and only barely so. The rice was inexcusably mushy, like literally wet slimy mochi topped with fish. One piece of my 6 pieces I could understand, but FIVE?? I can tolerate slightly overcooked rice, but soggy?? Hands-down the worst sushi rice I have ever experienced, and for $15 for 6 nigiri pieces. The prices are comparable to midtown Manhattan ($2-3/piece) without any of the quality to back it up. I cannot explain how the chef would knowingly mold the visibly wet and conglomerated rice into a ball and stick fish onto it. I can only assume they intentionally did so to use up the bad rice on a small take-out order. Not only that, I pulled a bone(!) out of the salmon (~1.5 cm) which is equally also inexcusable. Scales, I can understand to a certain extent, but a whole pin bone?? Hazardous, ridiculous, and neglectful behavior.The other option on the block is not only cheaper, but does not serve inedible food. The miso soup was decent. I also assume that since I ordered take-out, the staff could care less if I enjoyed the food, as long as I wasn't seated in their restaurant with the potential to complain. Please do better, pin bones can hurt people (never mind be unpleasant) and the very basics of a sushi restaurant, the RICE, cannot be made inedible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Jazmin Gabriella

Went inside at 6pm Friday night, It was busy with online orders, but the girl who works there handled everything well. While dining in, she made sure I had everything I needed.Shout out to her for being awesome, such a sweetheart. Great food, a little pricey, but it's good quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sushi, Roll

Kim A

When I called to place an order, I had a lot of questions, but the girl who answered was so nice and explained everything in detail. Customer service is all about little things like her patience, so thank you.Delivery was quick and the food was packaged great. Will order again.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Belkis St

The girl working there is amazing! If i come back it’s because of the lady working there!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Alana D.

one of my faves to order from , especially as a vegetarian always arrives super fast , infused sake is fab , same for the twinkies tempura . super affordable too , especially the dinner / lunch specials , and even moreso if you order directly from them by phone or their site ! truly love , my fave weekly treat

Bismarck Nuñez

They are amazing rolls are very very good , costumer service are

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lexi J.

The ambiance was amazing and food was delicious, servers were kind enough to help answer questions

Edson P.

Honestly, I've always gotten sushi from this place. I've ignored the fact that the price has gone up but I recently came in to get some sushi and while asking a question about one of the sushi rolls I got a response that was filled with attitude for no reason. Nobody wants to be answered with a smart-ass response.

Asha Tangri

I’ve enjoyed a sushi from your restaurant for a while but suddenly you have up charged everything on the menu $2 dollars and I want to know why the price increase? Really sick of price gouging because companies can. ie lunch price has been 3 rolls + soup for $16.99 Jul 2022 and is now $18.37 Sep 2023 same for 2 roll + soup + 2 piece sushi $18 -> $20.20 in a week. Why?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Tamara Bryan

The manager was externally rude and unprofessional. I would like to speak owner. I made an honest mistake of thinking my full order was not delivered and reported to seamless mistakenly. I was then called a thief after I’d offered to pay for the mistake I even went into the establishment to pay and correct the mistake. This person should not be working in the service industry.To make it worst the sushi was not good

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sushi

Asha T.

I've enjoyed a sushi from your restaurant for a while but suddenly you have up charged everything on the menu two dollars and I want to know why the price increase? Not very cool to switch up prices over the phone.

Alejandra Ramos

Ordered a spicy tuna roll for delivery. It tasted like old used oil. Absolutely unacceptable. Didn’t had high expectations but this I couldn’t even eat so I lost my money. I will call tomorrow and try to get my money back.

Food: 1

Olivia Mancini

I LOVE THIS PLACE! Sushi is HUGE! I’ve been in person and I get delivery all the time. They are fast (way faster and nicer than Amsterdam Sushi next door) and always so friendly. Literally love it here so much.Vegetarian options: MANY veggie options without fish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sushi

Load More