Amazing place and just the best way to end our last night In New York. Thank to all the staff
Cheryl
A lovely venue with great ambiance. Excellent band, musicians very much jazz and crooner style and suited the bar very well. Loads of cigar smoke (no surprise) but even if you don't smoke, be prepared to go home smelling like an ashtray. Great wines and a wonderful night out.
Reilly
Absolutely amazing vibes. Best date night ever and one of the most memorable memories we made here in New York.
Yvette
After two failed attempts, I was finally able to snag a reservation for Sinatra Saturdays, and it was absolutely worth the wait! We ended up with general seating for the 8 PM show, and the whole experience was amazing from start to finish. The live music was incredible — each set captured the spirit of Sinatra perfectly and ended with a lively rendition of “New York, New York.” My boyfriend is an avid cigar smoker, and surprising him with this night out was such a hit. The atmosphere, music, and overall vibe made for an unforgettable evening.
Wes
One of the most incredible experiences I've had in NYC. We ended up having the best two seats in the house, right in front of the band. Steven Maglio was phenomenal, the band was amazing, and the atmosphere was absolutely perfect. We had such a great time and will back for another Sinatra Saturday date night soon. Worth every penny. Well done!
colleen
The absolute rudest hostesses I've ever come in contact with. Terrible customer service. We left.
Linda
Frank was great and the band. Was so fun ! Next time I would go to the later show the only reason why I gave food to one store because it was mandatory but we did not eat there. Highly recommend!!
Stephan
The Sinatra Show was simply incredible. The energy and atmosphere is absolutely outstanding. Thank you to the great musicians and the unique Steven Maglio. Almost as if Frank was in the room. This has been the greatest night ever.
Caitlin M
Charlotte, the reservations manager was an incredible help and super timely in her responses. Definitely recommend this place!!
il barone
Everyone, literally everyone, is either smoking, drinking, or smoking and drinking. It's a disgrace. Server refused to make me a smoothie. No vegan options on menu. Music mostly old Sinatra-era crap.
Always an amazing experience at the CC! I've been coming here for years and never get tired of it. There truly is no other place like it in NYC and it feels like old New York. Steve Maglio is such an incredible performer and their cigar collection is chef's kiss. It would be amazing if they opened a 2nd location that has a slightly bigger standing room which would allow some dancing 🕺 (especially with the recent surge of popularity because of TikTok)!🍷🚬🎷
Sun Flower
First time in New York, we weren’t fans of the traffic and congestion. But when we stepped foot into the Carnegie Club life slowed down. The atmosphere was very soothing and relaxing. The service was top tier. We enjoyed our quiet time so much, we came back the next day. If we ever come back to New York we will also come back to the Carnegie Club.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
ALDO
it's one of my favorite places my friends really enjoyed. I recommended to everyone. I also was there recently on Friday night and they have the jazz music which is amazing and of course the Frank Sinatra night has already been well established. I've seen it many many times it's outstanding.
Susan
Great place for drinks and cigars. Nice wines on the menu and food is very good. Service is very professional!
Amazing place and just the best way to end our last night In New York. Thank to all the staff
A lovely venue with great ambiance. Excellent band, musicians very much jazz and crooner style and suited the bar very well. Loads of cigar smoke (no surprise) but even if you don't smoke, be prepared to go home smelling like an ashtray. Great wines and a wonderful night out.
Absolutely amazing vibes. Best date night ever and one of the most memorable memories we made here in New York.
After two failed attempts, I was finally able to snag a reservation for Sinatra Saturdays, and it was absolutely worth the wait! We ended up with general seating for the 8 PM show, and the whole experience was amazing from start to finish. The live music was incredible — each set captured the spirit of Sinatra perfectly and ended with a lively rendition of “New York, New York.” My boyfriend is an avid cigar smoker, and surprising him with this night out was such a hit. The atmosphere, music, and overall vibe made for an unforgettable evening.
One of the most incredible experiences I've had in NYC. We ended up having the best two seats in the house, right in front of the band. Steven Maglio was phenomenal, the band was amazing, and the atmosphere was absolutely perfect. We had such a great time and will back for another Sinatra Saturday date night soon. Worth every penny. Well done!
The absolute rudest hostesses I've ever come in contact with. Terrible customer service. We left.
Frank was great and the band. Was so fun ! Next time I would go to the later show the only reason why I gave food to one store because it was mandatory but we did not eat there. Highly recommend!!
The Sinatra Show was simply incredible. The energy and atmosphere is absolutely outstanding. Thank you to the great musicians and the unique Steven Maglio. Almost as if Frank was in the room. This has been the greatest night ever.
Charlotte, the reservations manager was an incredible help and super timely in her responses. Definitely recommend this place!!
Everyone, literally everyone, is either smoking, drinking, or smoking and drinking. It's a disgrace. Server refused to make me a smoothie. No vegan options on menu. Music mostly old Sinatra-era crap.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place for a cigar and a drink
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Always an amazing experience at the CC! I've been coming here for years and never get tired of it. There truly is no other place like it in NYC and it feels like old New York. Steve Maglio is such an incredible performer and their cigar collection is chef's kiss. It would be amazing if they opened a 2nd location that has a slightly bigger standing room which would allow some dancing 🕺 (especially with the recent surge of popularity because of TikTok)!🍷🚬🎷
First time in New York, we weren’t fans of the traffic and congestion. But when we stepped foot into the Carnegie Club life slowed down. The atmosphere was very soothing and relaxing. The service was top tier. We enjoyed our quiet time so much, we came back the next day. If we ever come back to New York we will also come back to the Carnegie Club.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
it's one of my favorite places my friends really enjoyed. I recommended to everyone. I also was there recently on Friday night and they have the jazz music which is amazing and of course the Frank Sinatra night has already been well established. I've seen it many many times it's outstanding.
Great place for drinks and cigars. Nice wines on the menu and food is very good. Service is very professional!
Loading...