Called to ask a question, was put on hold for over an hour (proof attached). Tried calling from different numbers and no one picked up, straight to voicemail.
C. Reaser
Best atmosphere for cigars in the city. Like walking into the Great Gatsby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cop Doctor
Embarrassing as an establishment to even offer a seat ON THE STAIRCASE to someone who reserved months in advance. Staff was unhelpful and frankly extremely rude. Left before even placing an order. I will never attend here again and I advise anyone looking at booking here to strongly consider booking elsewhere. Would give 0 stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Yuri Soriano
I am from Miami, where we have the best cigar lounges with great atmosphere, service, and the best cigars. I came to NYC on vacation and tried visiting this lounge twice. Both times, it was closed for private events. No prior notice or announcement online. Tried calling, but no one answered the phone. You should care more about new customers because that is how you get new service and future recommendations. The door man doesn’t even allow you to step foot inside. I will never visit this place again and don’t recommend. If you are in NYC and want to have a cigar, go to Macanudo Cigar Club. Nice selection, nice place. and nice service.
Service: 1
Dan Walker
The server was excellent, the ambience was so cool and the toasted marshmallow old-fashioned was superb. I'll return again upon my next visit
The prices of the cigars is laughable. $42 for a Melanio lol, I can get those for $8 online.
Alicia Kazi
My favorite place in NYC. I’ve been coming here for a few years, back when the place used to be packed with an older crowd. Within the last few months, TikTok has brought in the younger generations and the only downside is that reservation spots go super quick now! I’m glad people are catching on because this place is truly one of a kind; I haven’t found another jazz club quite like it. The Carnegie Club truly encapsulates old New York. The drinks and cigar selection are the cherry on top. Please never stop Sinatra Saturdays!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Howells
Love it here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Zaslav
Beautiful place with awesome service and cigars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lydia Hain
We were looking for an authentic cigar lounge with a good whiskey menu and Carnegie Club did not disappoint! We spent a wonderful Friday night here and will for sure come back! The atmosphere was fantastic, the service great and there was even some amazing live music. The food to share was just amazing: we had a nice (very big) meat platter and some flatbread with hummus, so good!
It was my first time smoking a cigar and since I told that to the very kind waitress, she explained me everything I needed to know, which was very helpful. I felt a little conscious to tell her at first but she was so friendly and open that I had no doubt I didn’t need to be embarrassed telling her. She offered to help pick the cigars too and was overall very nice and provided exceptional service.
What we also liked very much was the wide variety of whisky options and the overall menu.
Vegetarian options: There’s a wide variety of nice foods—also of vegetarian options. We loved the flatbread with excellent dips to share. There’s a variety of dip options to choose from, but of course there’s other vegetarian dishes too. This is only the vegetarian dish we shared and from which I can tell it was amazingly delicious!
Dietary restrictions: The waitress asked if there’s food allergies to consider, so if you have any, you’re in good hands!
Wheelchair accessibility: Carnegie Club is in the basement and wheelchair accessible.
Called to ask a question, was put on hold for over an hour (proof attached). Tried calling from different numbers and no one picked up, straight to voicemail.
Best atmosphere for cigars in the city. Like walking into the Great Gatsby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Embarrassing as an establishment to even offer a seat ON THE STAIRCASE to someone who reserved months in advance. Staff was unhelpful and frankly extremely rude. Left before even placing an order. I will never attend here again and I advise anyone looking at booking here to strongly consider booking elsewhere. Would give 0 stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I am from Miami, where we have the best cigar lounges with great atmosphere, service, and the best cigars. I came to NYC on vacation and tried visiting this lounge twice. Both times, it was closed for private events. No prior notice or announcement online. Tried calling, but no one answered the phone. You should care more about new customers because that is how you get new service and future recommendations. The door man doesn’t even allow you to step foot inside. I will never visit this place again and don’t recommend. If you are in NYC and want to have a cigar, go to Macanudo Cigar Club. Nice selection, nice place. and nice service.
Service: 1
The server was excellent, the ambience was so cool and the toasted marshmallow old-fashioned was superb. I'll return again upon my next visit
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Absolutely Fantastic, Smoked Cigars
The prices of the cigars is laughable. $42 for a Melanio lol, I can get those for $8 online.
My favorite place in NYC. I’ve been coming here for a few years, back when the place used to be packed with an older crowd. Within the last few months, TikTok has brought in the younger generations and the only downside is that reservation spots go super quick now! I’m glad people are catching on because this place is truly one of a kind; I haven’t found another jazz club quite like it. The Carnegie Club truly encapsulates old New York. The drinks and cigar selection are the cherry on top. Please never stop Sinatra Saturdays!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love it here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful place with awesome service and cigars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were looking for an authentic cigar lounge with a good whiskey menu and Carnegie Club did not disappoint! We spent a wonderful Friday night here and will for sure come back! The atmosphere was fantastic, the service great and there was even some amazing live music. The food to share was just amazing: we had a nice (very big) meat platter and some flatbread with hummus, so good!
It was my first time smoking a cigar and since I told that to the very kind waitress, she explained me everything I needed to know, which was very helpful. I felt a little conscious to tell her at first but she was so friendly and open that I had no doubt I didn’t need to be embarrassed telling her. She offered to help pick the cigars too and was overall very nice and provided exceptional service.
What we also liked very much was the wide variety of whisky options and the overall menu.
Vegetarian options: There’s a wide variety of nice foods—also of vegetarian options. We loved the flatbread with excellent dips to share. There’s a variety of dip options to choose from, but of course there’s other vegetarian dishes too. This is only the vegetarian dish we shared and from which I can tell it was amazingly delicious!
Dietary restrictions: The waitress asked if there’s food allergies to consider, so if you have any, you’re in good hands!
Wheelchair accessibility: Carnegie Club is in the basement and wheelchair accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A nice place to smoke cigars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best cigar club i've ever been. I dont think anything can beat this place. Best thing of all is the house blend cigar made by Oliva.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Plate
The place is incredible, it is quite a spectacle inside, everything is excellent and the espresso martini and old fashioned delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really nice ambience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sinatra Saturday was incredible. Absolutely brilliant performance by all. Can’t wait to go back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...