The Garret Cocteleria

349 Broome St, New York
(917) 398-3044

Recent Reviews

Vivian Lin

Came here when it was decorated for Dia De Los Muertos and it was adorable! So well decorated and inviting. The food was also pretty good. A little overpriced but you’re paying for the ambiance and decor

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tacos Y Guacamole

Carlos G

Arrived for first night of “Coctelería de Amor” love installation and it was such a vibe!First off, the hostess/server was dope, super friendly and gave great recommendations.Ordered from their seasonal menu, and started with the cocktail for two, “Passion Pit”, served in a cute pig shaped glass. The “shrimp ceviche”, and “house nachos” bites were top notch. The “sweet potato” and “short rib birra” tacos were savory and so worth it!Aesthetics are extra cute, each booth is filled with love letters, roses, and couple photos from celebrities! Music was a perfect boost, expect romantic songs across all genres. Great date night for the month of February.

Carlos G.

Arrived for first night of "Coctelería de Amor" love installation and it was such a vibe! First off, the hostess/server was dope, super friendly and gave great recommendations.Ordered from their seasonal menu, and started with the cocktail for two, "Passion Pit", served in a cute pig shaped glass. The "shrimp ceviche", and "house nachos" bites were top notch. The "sweet potato" and "short rib birra" tacos were savory and so worth it! Aesthetics are extra cute, each booth is filled with love letters, roses, and couple photos from celebrities! Music was a perfect boost, expect romantic songs across all genres. Great date night for the month of February.

Vic Pinto

Fun place for drinks. Cool and festive decorations. Latin music all night ?

Delaney Zybko

very overpriced. it was decorated so cute for Christmas and our drinks were adorable. the tacos were very good, but SO small. the portions were so tiny for both drinks and food, to be so expensive.

Chris M

Nice decor for holidays. Decent cocktails

Tanvi Arora

Stumbled across this place and went in for a quick drink. Sat at the bar. Loved the holiday decor and the vibe.

George Theodoropoulos

Didn't try this for the food just the drinks and the holiday decor. Drinks were pretty good, expected a bit more flavor around the holiday drinks they had listed like the Santa tiki Claus that I had. That being said it's a quaint little spot and the holiday decorations are a nice added touch. Definitely a place to give a try, will probably return.

d t

Made a reservation last year to come here but we were forced to cancel our trip due to covid. We were so happy to be able to make a new reservation this year for our trip. We were sat outside despite open spots inside and it was pouring rain. We sat and waited for 20 minutes to be served - despite waitress walking by multiple times she never came to see us so we got up and left. Decor very underwhelming but cannot comment on food or drinks as we didn’t get the chance to try them. Disappointing… don’t waste the trip here!

Kate H.

Ho ho hold up a minute!? This place is a hidden gem among nyc holiday pop up bars! It was so much more accessible for reservations and had really respectful distancing compared to other bars CRAMMED with people like sardines in a can. The drinks were great and the menu was really festive and food sensitive. You can tell the staff cares about this establishment and work hard to offer a jolly atmosphere. It's like Christmas in Florida or a Mexican tiki bar on the beach?? Whatever it is, it's endearing and extra edible! The taco tower definitely serves 3 hungry adults or as an appetizer (not meal) for 4-5 people. I would say it's better as a meal for 3 hungry adults! Can't wait to try this again sometime! It's pricey but you are paying for a really creative and fun seasonal experience. I took my friends here from out of town and everything was absolutely perfect. I didn't know what to expect and I loved it. Even the people at tables near us were similarly friendly and just a joy to generally be around. We lucked out with a great experience.

Elizabeth X.

Came in to have holiday drinks at a Christmas decorated bar. Holiday drinks were expensive. Good, but definitely pricey and didn't wow me that much.The Christmas decor was nice - lights everywhere. Staff was nice. We just came in for a drink - maybe we should give the food a try.

Glenn C.

This was one of the gimmick spots advertising on Halloween in a whole lot of places and as someone who likes those spots wanted to go, we did. The décor is a bit tacky but the ceiling is nice and colorful. They have Monopolio, a Mexican craft beer on tap which is nice. This is available either as Clara (American Lager) or Negra. I got the latter and it was similar to Negra Modelo and it was $8 which is fine for the area. Service was slow and inattentive but it was understandable as a couple of us didn't want to drink and no one wanted (their admittedly overpriced) food. Someone had a mixed drink which they found very sweet and others had Topo Chico. Alright spot.

hakjik lam

Here's what I got:* I'm a margarita on fire: this is the one in the second pic, they light this one in front of you! It's kinda tart from the prickly pear flavor but really refreshing.* A place beyond the Pina: this is the one in the ceramic pineapple cup. It tastes like a tequila pina colada on the rocks!* Yuval El Salvavidas: my favorite drink here, made with mezcal, rum, passion fruit and coffee bitters.* Halibut Ceviche: super good - I've actually tried all their ceviches just didn't snap the other visits) and can confidently say they all taste great and they don't skimp on the fish!* Short Rib Birria Tacos: I will always order these when I'm here!! You don't dip them but they come already drenched in the birria sauce and topped with lime, it's delicious.

hakjik l.

Here's what I got:* I'm a margarita on fire: this is the one in the second pic, they light this one in front of you! It's kinda tart from the prickly pear flavor but really refreshing.* A place beyond the Pina: this is the one in the ceramic pineapple cup. It tastes like a tequila pina colada on the rocks! * Yuval El Salvavidas: my favorite drink here, made with mezcal, rum, passion fruit and coffee bitters.* Halibut Ceviche: super good - I've actually tried all their ceviches just didn't snap the other visits) and can confidently say they all taste great and they don't skimp on the fish!* Short Rib Birria Tacos: I will always order these when I'm here!! You don't dip them but they come already drenched in the birria sauce and topped with lime, it's delicious.

Miriam Rendon

The food is very delicious but the noise from the DJ’s sooooo loudly!! Way too loudly for a dinner night. Friends that want to catch up and eat and drink nice, it’s no possible for the music too loud. Three stars because of that.

Load More