due to a poorly placed candle, the back of my hair caught on fire (like literally up in flames) and no one from the staff came to check on me or remove the candle. it was placed behind the ledge of a seating area and I know they saw it happen lol. the drinks were good though so whatever but now I need to get a haircut
Jonathan R.
My brother and I came here tonight with our cousins to celebrate our birthday. We had such a fun time in the front of the bar and then in the back room. Beautiful space. The food was amazing. I highly recommend the mac and cheese. The drinks were fantastic. They even had non alcoholic beers. Our waitress Hailey was the best. She was really sweet and attentive to all of us. Thank you so much for having us. We'll be back! 🤗
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Ginther
Great place to stop for a drink in the evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
amy
can’t see any reason to dock points. just a trusty american elevated pub. good happy hour! $16 for beer and cauliflower wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wayne Moncur
Great beer, happy hour was 5-8pm
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Esposito
I was here for a private event, but the place itself was great. Very friendly helpful staff, the food was really good, and the atmosphere was lively.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sharon Leigh
Was there for a Pre-Show Networking Reception with students and Alumni before going to the Theatre
Malvina Gasco
Amazing service, food, and drinks. Can’t recommend this place enough. Alesha (Elisha) is a gem, give her a raise. She let us watch F1 and was super attentive to your group. So thankful to have found this great spot in NYC!
Christopher Allen
Bartender ignored my friend for 20 minutes and even served someone else who physically pushed my friend out of the way to get the bartender's attention. I hope you have a better experience if you choose this place, margaritas were okay.
Great atmosphere and great service...plus Guiness. 😉
Kristi Flood
Grey Mare is a rare find. Andy makes this place so very special! He is attentive and makes a fabulous cocktail. Will definitely come back to Grey Mare - great experience!
Yolanda C.
We stopped by after the comedy show and Andy was one of the best bartenders we encountered during our time in New York. Very attentive and great bartender.
Brittany Chan
Food was really really good here. I especially loved the truffle fries and the sweet potato tots. The bartenders were also very efficient and masterful- ordered a few drinks and they were VERY well balanced and enjoyable. I was thoroughly impressed by food and drinks esp at this price point!
William Zheng
Kind staff but mediocre trivia night prizes. The food isn't that great.
due to a poorly placed candle, the back of my hair caught on fire (like literally up in flames) and no one from the staff came to check on me or remove the candle. it was placed behind the ledge of a seating area and I know they saw it happen lol. the drinks were good though so whatever but now I need to get a haircut
My brother and I came here tonight with our cousins to celebrate our birthday. We had such a fun time in the front of the bar and then in the back room. Beautiful space. The food was amazing. I highly recommend the mac and cheese. The drinks were fantastic. They even had non alcoholic beers. Our waitress Hailey was the best. She was really sweet and attentive to all of us. Thank you so much for having us. We'll be back! 🤗
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to stop for a drink in the evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
can’t see any reason to dock points. just a trusty american elevated pub. good happy hour! $16 for beer and cauliflower wings
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great beer, happy hour was 5-8pm
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I was here for a private event, but the place itself was great. Very friendly helpful staff, the food was really good, and the atmosphere was lively.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Was there for a Pre-Show Networking Reception with students and Alumni before going to the Theatre
Amazing service, food, and drinks. Can’t recommend this place enough. Alesha (Elisha) is a gem, give her a raise. She let us watch F1 and was super attentive to your group. So thankful to have found this great spot in NYC!
Bartender ignored my friend for 20 minutes and even served someone else who physically pushed my friend out of the way to get the bartender's attention. I hope you have a better experience if you choose this place, margaritas were okay.
Great service, and solid drinks
Restaurantji Recommends
Great atmosphere and great service...plus Guiness. 😉
Grey Mare is a rare find. Andy makes this place so very special! He is attentive and makes a fabulous cocktail. Will definitely come back to Grey Mare - great experience!
We stopped by after the comedy show and Andy was one of the best bartenders we encountered during our time in New York. Very attentive and great bartender.
Food was really really good here. I especially loved the truffle fries and the sweet potato tots. The bartenders were also very efficient and masterful- ordered a few drinks and they were VERY well balanced and enjoyable. I was thoroughly impressed by food and drinks esp at this price point!
Kind staff but mediocre trivia night prizes. The food isn't that great.
Loading...