I went to eat there after a show ordered our food 2 hours and tasted horrible and prices are ridiculous. I tell everyone reading this review STAY AWAY.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Donna Muglia
Left starving ! They give you such a small amount of food and very expensive!!! Never go again !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Charles Gamarekian Jr.
Plain and Simple…..A Gem! From the second you walk in until the end, this wonderful experience was perfection. Servers were in harmony with each other while presenting and changing courses, almost as it was choreographed. The politeness of the staff was unmatched. We went for a pre theatre dinner where the prefix is available 4-7pm. However, we asked if we could try more appetizers as an add-on, to which they complied. All of the first courses were amazing. Dinner was packed with flavor. I had the lamb and my wife had the halibut. This will be our new pre theatre date restaurant!
Owner/Management…. Well done.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Heldreth
Stopped in with a colleague for drinks. Amazing wines and great service. Spent some time with the owner - great guy. Definitely a spot to try. Can’t wait to go back for the food
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
L File
My daughter and I had reservations prior to going to the theater. Very good service and the atmosphere is nice. The roll delicious, I ordered the halibut with mussels and lobster(gave the mussels and lobster to my daughter) she ordered the pasta dish. The sauce with my halibut tasted off, so I removed it from the sauce, (not sure what it was…thought maybe an ingredient in it). However, we barely made it through our show and back to our hotel before I was mildly ill but my daughter was sick all night(GI issues…no temp or anything). Fine by am. Even without all of that, I wouldn’t recommend. We both like the nicer restaurants, but I don’t like paying 200.00 for not great food. Again, service was great!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Hillary Schuler (HS)
Everything was incredible. I went with my mother while we were on a special trip to the city. We dont normally get to dine at establishments as impressive as this one and it was a wonderful experience. I had the chorizo ravioli, the lambs saddle, and finished off with the ice cream. The presentation and the food were pure art. Even the bread was indulgent. The team that served us were knowledgeable and efficient. Every staff member made our visit so lovely. The restaurant even contacted us ahead of time to ask if we were seeing a Broadway show. They made sure we were finished with our meal in time to get there without rushing a single detail. This was an experience I will treasure forever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Narda
The Lambs Club is a beautiful, classic restaurant where every dish is both stunningly presented and genuinely delicious. The service feels almost orchestral — attentive, elegant, and truly beyond expectation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine S.
Our reservation was at 7pm and was able to get seat on time. The staff were friendly and helpful. Once we ordered, food came in decent time. The duck was tender and melts in your mouth. The scallops were delicious but too creamy for my taste. Otherwise we enjoyed the food and experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louie Mar Gangcuangco
Absolutely delightful dinner at the Lambs Club NYC 🥰 The lamb (as expected) was exquisite. I also had the steak tartar with caviar. I have not had caviar in a while, so that was such a treat! 🥰
Special thanks to Lydia who has been very attentive and accommodating. Definitely a five-star experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ivy moore
Beautiful atmosphere! Jazz music playing in the background and low lighting gives a nice ambiance. Service was great. I ordered the oatmeal with apples and raisins, wheat toast, orange juice and jasmine tea. Menu items are pricey but worth it. I'm in love with this place.
My wife and I had an absolutely wonderful breakfast at The Lambs Club. From start to finish, the experience was flawless. The service was top notch — the staff were warm, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect without ever being intrusive. The food was incredibly fresh, beautifully presented, and full of flavor. The coffee was strong and perfectly brewed, just the way a morning should start.
The atmosphere truly sets The Lambs Club apart — from the elegant furniture to the historic photos on the walls, every detail exudes character and sophistication. You can feel the rich history of the place paired seamlessly with genuine hospitality.
A perfect breakfast experience in every way — highly recommend to anyone looking for a memorable and refined start to their day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily DelaPeña
Our waiter was lovely and some of the food wasn’t awful but the sommelier or perhaps manager, a bald older white man was exceptionally rude and made it so that I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant to anyone, ever.
My guest ordered what they thought was a red wine and he brought out a white, which wasn’t actually what she asks for. We ordered another bottle of red and the “gentleman” came back and rudely told us they opened the other bottle of wine for us, so we needed to keep it. I explained we did not order or want white wine but he was insistent and we ended up taking the bottle with us, even though he was in the wrong, because we were hungry and didn’t want to ruin our meal. The situation was unfortunate, but had he been polite, it would have been fine.
He behaved like a tantruming child rather than an employee of an upscale restaurant. All of the food was too salty, as though to compensate for the lack of flavor. The brussel sprouts were very greasy and the bordelaise that came with my filet was thin and had little flavor. The filet itself was tough and medium rather than the medium rare I ordered.
There were also a couple of small fruit flies around the table after the food came out, which made me question the cleanliness of the entire place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Susan Seagroves
Everything was perfect! Impressive service, delicious menu and beautiful dining room✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dom Zed
Probably could consider to reply to their emails especially when 3 hotel guests have been trying to make a business dinner booking for 4 days.
To reply to business owner: check your emails sent on Sunday requesting a business dinner table for 3.
In reply to your question about the hotel that’s also the problem. I’ve called 3 times in 3 different days trying to be connected to the concerige and no one has picked up so they can make a booking for us. I’m not there yet in person since we wanted to book in advance for this important meeting.
I went to eat there after a show ordered our food 2 hours and tasted horrible and prices are ridiculous.
I tell everyone reading this review STAY AWAY.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Left starving ! They give you such a small amount of food and very expensive!!! Never go again !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Plain and Simple…..A Gem! From the second you walk in until the end, this wonderful experience was perfection. Servers were in harmony with each other while presenting and changing courses, almost as it was choreographed. The politeness of the staff was unmatched. We went for a pre theatre dinner where the prefix is available 4-7pm. However, we asked if we could try more appetizers as an add-on, to which they complied. All of the first courses were amazing. Dinner was packed with flavor. I had the lamb and my wife had the halibut. This will be our new pre theatre date restaurant!
Owner/Management…. Well done.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in with a colleague for drinks. Amazing wines and great service. Spent some time with the owner - great guy. Definitely a spot to try. Can’t wait to go back for the food
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
My daughter and I had reservations prior to going to the theater. Very good service and the atmosphere is nice. The roll delicious, I ordered the halibut with mussels and lobster(gave the mussels and lobster to my daughter) she ordered the pasta dish. The sauce with my halibut tasted off, so I removed it from the sauce, (not sure what it was…thought maybe an ingredient in it). However, we barely made it through our show and back to our hotel before I was mildly ill but my daughter was sick all night(GI issues…no temp or anything). Fine by am. Even without all of that, I wouldn’t recommend. We both like the nicer restaurants, but I don’t like paying 200.00 for not great food. Again, service was great!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Everything was incredible. I went with my mother while we were on a special trip to the city. We dont normally get to dine at establishments as impressive as this one and it was a wonderful experience. I had the chorizo ravioli, the lambs saddle, and finished off with the ice cream. The presentation and the food were pure art. Even the bread was indulgent. The team that served us were knowledgeable and efficient. Every staff member made our visit so lovely. The restaurant even contacted us ahead of time to ask if we were seeing a Broadway show. They made sure we were finished with our meal in time to get there without rushing a single detail. This was an experience I will treasure forever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Lambs Club is a beautiful, classic restaurant where every dish is both stunningly presented and genuinely delicious. The service feels almost orchestral — attentive, elegant, and truly beyond expectation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our reservation was at 7pm and was able to get seat on time. The staff were friendly and helpful. Once we ordered, food came in decent time. The duck was tender and melts in your mouth. The scallops were delicious but too creamy for my taste. Otherwise we enjoyed the food and experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delightful dinner at the Lambs Club NYC 🥰
The lamb (as expected) was exquisite. I also had the steak tartar with caviar. I have not had caviar in a while, so that was such a treat! 🥰
Special thanks to Lydia who has been very attentive and accommodating. Definitely a five-star experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful atmosphere! Jazz music playing in the background and low lighting gives a nice ambiance. Service was great. I ordered the oatmeal with apples and raisins, wheat toast, orange juice and jasmine tea. Menu items are pricey but worth it. I'm in love with this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I had an absolutely wonderful breakfast at The Lambs Club. From start to finish, the experience was flawless. The service was top notch — the staff were warm, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect without ever being intrusive. The food was incredibly fresh, beautifully presented, and full of flavor. The coffee was strong and perfectly brewed, just the way a morning should start.
The atmosphere truly sets The Lambs Club apart — from the elegant furniture to the historic photos on the walls, every detail exudes character and sophistication. You can feel the rich history of the place paired seamlessly with genuine hospitality.
A perfect breakfast experience in every way — highly recommend to anyone looking for a memorable and refined start to their day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our waiter was lovely and some of the food wasn’t awful but the sommelier or perhaps manager, a bald older white man was exceptionally rude and made it so that I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant to anyone, ever.
My guest ordered what they thought was a red wine and he brought out a white, which wasn’t actually what she asks for. We ordered another bottle of red and the “gentleman” came back and rudely told us they opened the other bottle of wine for us, so we needed to keep it. I explained we did not order or want white wine but he was insistent and we ended up taking the bottle with us, even though he was in the wrong, because we were hungry and didn’t want to ruin our meal. The situation was unfortunate, but had he been polite, it would have been fine.
He behaved like a tantruming child rather than an employee of an upscale restaurant. All of the food was too salty, as though to compensate for the lack of flavor. The brussel sprouts were very greasy and the bordelaise that came with my filet was thin and had little flavor. The filet itself was tough and medium rather than the medium rare I ordered.
There were also a couple of small fruit flies around the table after the food came out, which made me question the cleanliness of the entire place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Everything was perfect! Impressive service, delicious menu and beautiful dining room✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably could consider to reply to their emails especially when 3 hotel guests have been trying to make a business dinner booking for 4 days.
To reply to business owner: check your emails sent on Sunday requesting a business dinner table for 3.
In reply to your question about the hotel that’s also the problem. I’ve called 3 times in 3 different days trying to be connected to the concerige and no one has picked up so they can make a booking for us. I’m not there yet in person since we wanted to book in advance for this important meeting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...