The Meatball Shop

64 Greenwich Ave, New York
(212) 982-7815

Recent Reviews

Christine Waterhouse Marino

Delicious!!!! Love love this place. My new place to go for cozy food!! I love the atmosphere! Love my server Adreian. Loved the drinks! Loved the pesto and chicken meatballs. Very very safe. They Checked our vaccine cards and ID cards. Following all the procedures of a covid safe environment!!! I will be coming back soon! I will definitely become a regular.

Tracy Hartman

Fantastic food, with lots of Gluten-Free options!

Rob Mancebo

best meatball sub ever. great service. thanks Anthony

Jim Maloney

Great atmosphere, terrific food and exceptional service. So fun!!

Jeanne Marie O'Gara

Amazing staff and lots of yummy comfort food!

Daniela Ortega

Fabulous food, great service, very friendly staff, good atmosphere

D B.

The short rib plate, which came with mashed potatoes and a scattering of carrots and string beans, was inedible. Salty, stringy, and topped with a gross layer of connective tissue, the short rib was subpar in every way and unbelievably disappointing for both its $27 price point and taste. Never again.

Ricardo Paiva

A good value for the money. The meatball itself is very tasty!!!

Walter T.

If your lucky enough to seat at the bar for 1 or 2 people then do it , otherwise you probably seat in the tables w/ other people, but that's ok too you can order an appetizer a beer and a entree for under $20 . And it's a great deal in the west village area . Food is fast made so you can eat and be out in 35 minuets or so ... your menu is in front of you on a paper that you fill out your order as if you were in a hospital bed Version I not a dessert guy myself but there do make them good here too. It's a small place so on weekends it's pretty packed , so reservations are needed I was here the first weekend they were open and the place was spectacular, (5 stars ) but haven't been here for about 3-4 years in between, a good place to be at ... for the price in the hood' this review is base back on January 18 , 2019'

Joshua B.

Do not order the $48 drink for four. Only makes two small drinks. Ordered drinks with ice. Didn't get the ice but got a small mason jar or alcohol.

Tracy R.

My daughter and I revisited in October, 2019, and had an amazing meal with incredible service. It's nice to have come back and had a much better experience. It had been bugging me, and I knew we had to go back for another shot. Redemption. Thank you!!! :-)

Byron B.

Just got some takeout from this place. The Chicken Parm Smash is the best sandwich I've ever had. Stay strong! You guys rock!!!

Sarah Z.

Loved the meatballs, sauces, drinks and service! We ordered based off of recommendation, classic balls with tomato sauce and spicy pork balls with the spicy meat sauce. The spicy balls were ah-mazing! So flavorful and not so spicy it was unbearable, just lots and lots of good flavor. Overall an amazing spot that's definitely worth a try!

Luis C.

The day after I wrote my review I was contacted by the manager of the location. She DM'd me and was so pleasant and eager to fix the issues I had with our order. Never in my life did I expect that someone would contact me regarding my issues, but Waleska wanted to make things right. She addressed my issues with such graciousness it was really a breathe of fresh air of terrific customer service. You are amazing Waleska, thank you again and we will definitely head back to the location just to meet you!

Wendi K.

I love the concept and what a fun menu! Pick your ball type and sauce. They also have small plates, pasta, and sliders. We tried the Mini Buffalo Balls ($9) as well as a couple of the make your owns ($9 for 3 meatballs and a chosen sauce). Kind of pricey for the portions but the balls were fresh and tasty, lol. Lots of pun jokes to be made here. Casual setting with a good amount of seating.

Load More