The Original Little Italy

2 East 39th Street, 5th Ave Off, New York
(212) 661-1425

Recent Reviews

Ronald K.

They have a large selection of pizza slices and all the customers I saw bought slices. There is one table with four chairs and a wall ledge with stools for about eight more people. It's very clean and tiled like a washroom. I've had better pizza but this is about location. The clean look is nice and the price is okay. The cheese did not have the chewy consistency that I am used to having with mozzarella - it's more like a mild cheddar. The sauce was hard to discern. It's okay if you are on your way to a show but it's not a destination.

Nate Nordstrom

Surprisingly good. Small place. Great service. Did we mention good pizza??? ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ho hoho

The original grandma slice was great and margeritta was amazing as wellNot salty, crispy, chewy and delicious...

Sandeep Chandrasekhar

A+ service from Bobby, amazing guy and he gives the BEST service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cristina De Oliveira

Great food! Been ordering from them for a long time for our company lunches. Bobbi and his team are always a pleasure to work with. Thank you so much for your delicious lunches.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Umit Öztürk

It's a very bad venue manager, it's very bad, they close at 9.30, it says 10 on the internet.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jeff & Tonya DePasquale

Great pizza and nice people who will take care of you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shanna L.

Solid grandma slice! The crust is crispy. The pizza tasted fresh. The inside is minimal but it is a hole in the wall pizza shop. No bathroom. The slice was $4 which is a little expensive but for the location and quality it's deserving. The staff was nice. The man handling the pizza had his head covered and I saw him changing his gloves which I appreciate. Def a solid neighborhood addition.

Lissette Hurtado

Loved their pizza. Ordered catering for my job always. Food is amazing and great portions.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lucas Vargas Quintana

Best pizza around. It is almost the only pizza place where employees are nice and kind. They prepared me a single slice with the ingredients I

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patricia A S.

Prices different in store than on the menu online. Example - Snapple marked as 2.75 on menu but I was charged 6.77 for two Snapple's in the store. Gets really crowded around 3 pm weekdays with students from the HS. Pizza is ok

Karen Mondragón

We have been touring around manhattan trying traditional pizzas and this is great, the cooker even made a slice of pizza just for me!! Also great music ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carlos Quezada

This little place is absolutely amazing and the owners and workers are so nice! The pizza is so good. Nice crisp crust no slop. I tried two different slices and both were so good big slices also. Next time im in town I'll stop and try the calzones as those looked so good as well. Plus a pinwheel-looking pizza!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grandma, Meat Lover, Grandma Slice, Slice of Pizza

Daniel S.

Great pizza! Crispy crust. Can't wait to go back. Exactly as described. Must try if you are in NY.

Dominic Tucci

Quick, easy and decent amount of options for everyone in my group.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More